Since Monday's Market Monday went out, my phone has had one question on it from two directions. Sellers ask, "Is my house next?" Buyers ask, "So can I lowball everything now?" Both questions come from the same number, so let me answer them from the same data.
Here are the six questions I got most this week, with the numbers from our own October 5 read of every active listing in our four-county feed.
1. “Is it true that half the houses have cut their price?”
Yes. 124 of the 248 houses in our feed are asking less today than when they listed. Not one house has raised its price. The median cut is $10,000, or 4.9%.
One caution I put in Monday's post and will repeat here: this is half of the houses still for sale, not half of all sellers. A house that cut and sold is gone from the count.
2. “So are sellers panicking this week?”
No, and that is the part people miss. Only 1 of the 124 cuts happened in the last seven days, and 15 in the last thirty. Fifty-four were made more than three months ago. The oldest is 257 days old, a house that has been sitting since January.
This is an accumulation, not a wave. Those houses came down, and then kept standing anyway.
3. “Where is the cutting happening?”
Everywhere with real inventory, at different rates. Carterville is at 14 of 22 houses (63.6%), Murphysboro 9 of 15 (60.0%), and Marion 39 of 73 (53.4%). At the bottom, West Frankfort is 3 of 15 (20.0%).
Small towns swing hard on a few listings, so read a town with eight or ten houses as a count, not a percentage. If you are selling in Carterville or Marion, you are in a crowd of sellers who have already moved.
4. “I'm selling. Should I cut?”
Ask the house. Look at how long it has been listed and how many people have come through. If you are past the median for your town and showings are thin, the market has already answered you.
And here is the uncomfortable part of Monday's number: half of the houses that cut are still standing. A cut that is too small to change the story does not sell the house. If you move, move far enough to land in front of a new set of buyers, and check it against what comparable houses actually closed for, not against the other unsold houses on the shelf.
5. “I'm buying. Can I lowball?”
You can offer anything. Whether it works depends on the house. A seller who cut three months ago and has had no showings is in a different spot from one who cut last Tuesday. Ask your broker when the price changed and how long it has been listed, then offer off the closings. A cut tells you the seller is moving, not that they are finished moving.
6. “Does land cut like houses do?”
Not close. Of 103 land and lot listings, 19 have cut (18.4%), and the median cut is $3,400 against $10,000 on a house. We can't tell you what is in a seller's head. From the desk, a house has carrying costs running whether anyone is inside, and a vacant parcel mostly does not.
What Greg Holthaus Makes of It
When half of a market has cut, the cut itself stops being news. What matters is whether yours was big enough, early enough, and aimed at the right comparison.
If you are on either side of one of these houses, text me and I will tell you what I would do. I would rather talk you out of a bad move than sell you a good-looking one.
Ask Greg FAQ
Are Southern Illinois home prices falling?
Are the price cuts recent?
Which towns have the most price cuts?
Do land sellers cut prices as much as house sellers?
Should I cut my price if half the market already has?
Should a buyer expect a discount on a house that has already cut?

💰 Pricing Starts With Real Numbers
Whether you are buying at the closing median or the asking median, know your real payment first — taxes and insurance included. Free, no-pressure pre-qualification with Jarod Sanders, SIRE's in-house lender, right here in Marion.Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228
❓ Got a Question That Wasn’t on the List?
Send it over. If it is a good one it may end up in a future Ask Greg — and either way you will get a straight answer back.
📱 Rather Just Text Him?
Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He’ll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He’s open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About the numbers: Listing counts, price-change counts, median cuts, cut ages and town figures come from our October 5, 2026 read of every active listing in our own four-county feed (Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties), as reported in that day's Market Monday. They describe houses still for sale on that morning, not all sellers and not closed sales; houses that cut and sold are not counted. Towns with fewer than ten houses move several points on a single listing. An honest limitation: the feed reflects one data source's coverage, not the complete local MLS, and asking prices are not sale prices. Nothing here is an appraisal, a loan offer, a rate quote, or legal or financial advice. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.
