Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Ask Greg — November 11, 2026

Buy First or Sell First?

Five answers for move-up buyers who need to do both at once.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 11, 2026

If you already own a home in Southern Illinois and you want a different one, you have a timing problem. You need the money from the house you have to buy the house you want, and you need somewhere to live the whole time. It is the question I hear most from move-up buyers, and there is no one right answer. There is a right answer for you, though, and it comes down to your numbers. Here are the five questions I get most.

1. “Should I buy first or sell first?”

Here is the honest trade. Selling first is the safer move with money. You know exactly what you walked away with, you never carry two payments, and you shop as a clean buyer. The cost is that you might have to land somewhere for a while. Buying first is easier on your family. You move once, on your schedule. The cost is that you have to be able to carry both houses, or borrow against the one you have, until it sells. Most people don’t know which one they can actually do until a lender runs it. Do that before you decide anything.

2. “Can’t I just make my offer contingent on selling my house?”

You can. A home sale contingency says you only have to buy if your house sells. It protects you. But put yourself in the seller’s chair: your offer now depends on a stranger buying a house they have never seen. A lot of sellers will pass on that, or take it only with a clause that lets them keep showing and bump you if a cleaner offer comes in. A contingency gets much stronger when your house is already listed, priced right, and showing well. Strongest of all is when it is already under contract. That is why I tell people to get their own house ready first, even if they plan to buy first.

3. “Can I qualify for the new loan while I still own the old house?”

Maybe. A lender will generally count your current house payment against your income until that house is sold or under contract. For some families that is fine. For others it shuts the door. There are also ways to use the equity in your current home toward the next one. Whether any of that fits you is a lender’s call, not mine and not the internet’s. Ask them to run it both ways, with and without your current payment, so you see both doors before you walk through one.

4. “What if my house sells and I haven’t found the next one?”

This is the fear that keeps people from listing, and it is usually more manageable than it feels. Two common tools: ask the buyer for a longer closing date, which buys you shopping time, or negotiate to stay in the home for a short period after closing. Both have to be in the contract, and the buyer has to agree to them. Some will, some won’t, and price and terms trade against each other. Worst case, a short-term rental or a few weeks with family is a cheaper problem than two mortgages for six months.

5. “Can I close on both the same day?”

Yes. It happens all the time. Usually the sale closes first, and the money from it funds the purchase a few hours later. It works when everyone is lined up: both contracts, both lenders, and the title company. When one piece slips, the other one slips with it. The fix is to plan the dates early and leave yourself a cushion, not to hope it all lands the same afternoon. This is a big reason we keep sales, mortgage and title under one roof at SIRE. Fewer handoffs, fewer surprises.

What Greg Holthaus Makes of It

The order matters less than knowing your numbers before you pick one. The people who get stuck are the ones who fall in love with a house before they know whether they can carry two payments, or who list before they have any plan for where they are going.

Get three things first: a lender’s answer on what you qualify for, a realistic price on your current home, and a broker who will plan both sides with you. Then pick the order. If you want help with that, text me.

Ask Greg FAQ

Should I buy my next house first or sell my current one first?
It depends on how much cash and borrowing room you have. Selling first protects you from carrying two payments but means you may need a place to land. Buying first lets you move once but usually requires qualifying with both payments or using equity. A lender can tell you which one you can actually do.
What is a home sale contingency?
It is a clause in your offer that makes your purchase depend on your current home selling. It protects you, but sellers see it as risk, so it can make your offer weaker unless your house is already listed or under contract.
Can I qualify for a new mortgage while I still own my current home?
Sometimes. Your lender will count your current payment against your income unless the house is sold or under contract. Ask your lender to run the numbers both ways before you shop.
What if my house sells before I find the next one?
You can negotiate a longer closing date or ask to stay in the home for a short period after closing. Both must be written into the contract, and the buyer has to agree.
Can I close on both houses the same day?
Yes, it is common. You usually close the sale first so the proceeds can fund the purchase. It takes coordination between both contracts, both lenders and the title company, so plan the dates early.
Jarod Sanders, SIRE in-house lender

💰 Find Out Which Order You Can Afford

Before you list or write an offer, find out whether you can carry both payments or need to sell first. Free, no-pressure pre-qualification with Jarod Sanders, SIRE's in-house lender, right here in Marion.Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228

Get Pre-Qualified →

❓ Got a Question That Wasn’t on the List?

Send it over. If it is a good one it may end up in a future Ask Greg — and either way you will get a straight answer back.

📱 Rather Just Text Him?

Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He’ll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He’s open to a text any time.

Text Greg · 618.925.8654
Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About this post: This is general information based on how purchase contracts commonly work, not legal or financial advice, and it quotes no market statistics. Your contract, loan type and lender decide which options and deadlines apply to you. Nothing here is a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility. Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.

Moving Up This Winter?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us