Every Sunday we put two of our brokers in front of you, because a brokerage is not the two names on the leaderboard. This week the two have more in common than usual and cover less of the same ground than you would expect: Amy Smith and Renee Abbey both grew up in Herrin, both work out of the Herrin office, and both of their pages say 15+ years in the business. And then their specialties go in completely different directions.
Amy Smith — Broker

Broker · Williamson & Franklin Counties · 15+ years · Herrin office
Buyers & Sellers · Residential · Property Management Background
Amy is from Herrin and her page puts her at 15+ years in the business. What it leads on is not a sales figure, it is a temperament: a background in property management and accounting, and deadlines tracked, numbers checked and paperwork right the first time. Her page also records seventeen closings in the last twelve months — that is our own count of our own broker rather than an audited figure, and we say so.
Her territory is the part worth reading twice. All of Williamson County — Herrin, Marion, Carterville and Johnston City — plus Benton and West Frankfort over in Franklin County, which her page says have become a favorite part of her business. Hold on to that, because the numbers below are about exactly those two towns.
Direct: 618.923.4668 · asmith@sirealtyexperts.com
Why Amy’s Franklin County Habit Is the Interesting Part
Amy’s page names Williamson County and then names Benton and West Frankfort as well, which is less common than it sounds and turns out to matter. Those two towns hold twenty-one of Franklin County’s thirty-one houses on the market this morning, and Franklin is a different animal from Williamson:
| County | Houses | Median ask | Median year built | Built before 1976 | Asking under $200,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Franklin County | 31 | $129,000 | 1956 | 65% | 23 (74%) |
| Williamson County | 137 | $274,900 | 1983 | 42% | 52 (38%) |
Houses only — land, commercial and multifamily excluded. Year built comes from each listing record’s own detail page, and every one of the 168 houses in these two counties published one.
Read the two middle columns. The median house for sale in Franklin County was built in 1956 and asks $129,000. In Williamson it was built in 1983 and asks $274,900. That is twenty-seven years older and $145,900 cheaper, in two counties that share a border. 74% of Franklin’s houses ask under $200,000, against 38% of Williamson’s.
Here is the part that makes it one market rather than two, though. Inside the under-$200,000 band, the stock is equally old in both counties: 83% of it predates 1976 on each side of the line. Franklin is not cheaper because its cheap houses are older. Franklin is cheaper because a far larger share of its market sits in that band at all. That matches what we counted across all four counties yesterday: the median house asking under $200,000 was built in 1947 and 82% of them predate 1976.
Which is where a broker whose background is property management and accounting stops being a nice line on a bio page and starts being the reason a deal closes. A 1956 house generates paperwork a 2015 house does not: an older roof and furnace in the inspection response, a lender who wants more documentation, a repair credit to negotiate and track, and a closing date that moves when any one of those slips. We are not going to tell you Amy is better at this than anyone else — we have no way to measure that and neither does anyone quoting it at you. What her page does establish is that the discipline is what she leads with, and on a file like the ones above that is the discipline the file actually needs.
Renee Abbey — Broker

Broker · Herrin’s Hometown Expert · 15+ years · Herrin office
Buyers & Sellers · Residential · Commercial
Renee was born and raised in Herrin and her page also puts her at 15+ years, which is where the pairing comes from: between them these two have at least thirty years of this market, and they came up in the same town. Her page lists residential and commercial across Herrin, Marion, Carbondale and all of Southern Illinois, and she is an active member of the Herrin Elks Lodge.
Her page makes a point of availability — it says she picks up nights and weekends, when the right house hits the market or a question cannot wait. We will let that stand as her own claim about her own practice rather than make it a promise on her behalf. The part we can put numbers behind is the commercial half, and it is a bigger slice of those three towns than the residential noise suggests.
Direct: 618.694.3251 · rabbey@sirealtyexperts.com
The Commercial Half Nobody Counts
Residential gets all the attention, so here is the number. Across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties there are 72 commercial listings active this morning, from $50,000 to $4,789,400, median $249,950. And they are not spread evenly:
| Her three towns | Commercial listings |
|---|---|
| Marion | 22 |
| Carbondale | 10 |
| Herrin | 9 |
| Those three together | 41 of 72 (57%) |
41 of the 72 — 57% — sit in the three towns Renee’s page names, and the most expensive commercial listing in all four counties is in Marion, one of them. That is not a coincidence about Renee; it is where the commercial stock is. The point is that a broker who lists commercial alongside residential in those three towns is positioned over more than half of a market most buyers never see, because they are looking at houses.
One Town, Two Markets
Finish where they both started. Herrin has 37 active listings this morning — twenty-one houses at a median ask of $140,000, with fifteen of them under $200,000; nine commercial listings from $99,000 to $1,400,000; and five pieces of land.
That is a small town carrying two entirely separate markets at once, and this week’s pair happens to take one each. A $140,000 house is one kind of problem. A $1,400,000 commercial building is another kind entirely, with different financing, different diligence and a different buyer. Both of these brokers grew up inside that town and neither of them has to learn it.
🔮 What Greg Would Say About This Pair
If you are shopping the cheaper end of this market — and in Franklin County 74% of the houses are the cheaper end — the thing that costs you money is usually not the price. It is everything between contract and closing on a house of that age, and Amy’s whole pitch is that all of it gets tracked. And if you have been circling a storefront or a building in Herrin, Marion or Carbondale and assumed you needed a specialist from out of town, read that commercial count again: 41 of the 72 are right here, and Renee does that work from the Herrin office. Call whichever one of them matches your end of it — their direct lines are above.
👤 Want Amy or Renee On Your Deal?
One of them has spent fifteen years on houses and the paperwork that closes them; the other covers the commercial side of the same three towns. Tell us which end of it you are on and the right one of the two will call you back — and if it turns out to be neither, they will hand you to whoever it should be.
📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.
Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About this post: Every fact about each broker comes from that broker’s own profile page on this site, read on October 11, 2026. Nothing here was inferred, and nothing was taken from any other source. Three things on those pages were deliberately left out. The five-star client rating both pages display is attributed there to an outside listing portal, and we do not name portals in our posts, so it is not repeated here. The client testimonials on both pages are not reproduced — reciting our own site’s reviews back at you is not evidence of anything. And neither page mentions the other broker, so this post says nothing about any relationship between them; where a broker’s own page does state a relationship we use that page’s words, and where it does not we say nothing. The closings figure is ours, not an audit. Amy’s page records 17 homes sold in the last twelve months. That is Southern Illinois Realty Experts’ own record of its own broker and it is presented as such. Listing figures come from a same-day pull of active local MLS listing data carried in our own brokerage feed across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties: 430 active records, of which 245 are houses, 104 land, 72 commercial and the remainder multifamily and other types. The county comparison covers the 168 houses in Williamson and Franklin counties, assigned by the town on each listing; land, commercial and multifamily are excluded from it. Year built comes from each listing record’s own detail page and all 168 published one, with no implausible values to exclude this week. Medians are taken from the raw figures and rounded once, and counts are shown beside them so you can see that the Franklin row rests on 31 houses and the Williamson row on 137. Square footage, lot size and year built are as published on the listing record; we have not independently verified them and we have not inspected any of these properties. Commercial figures count listings, not transactions. A note on what we did not claim. We have not said that either broker performs better than any other, here or anywhere else, because we cannot measure it. What the numbers above describe is the market their stated specialties sit in, not their skill. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage. Nothing here is an appraisal, a loan offer, or a rate quote.
