Every Sunday this series introduces two of the brokers at Southern Illinois Realty Experts. This is week 8, and today it is Tammy Hottes and Kimberly Burchell.
And here is the same thing this series said last Sunday, because it is true again. Their two profile pages are the same page. We compared them line by line this morning: all 166 lines of visible text are identical once you blank out the name, the direct line and the email. Same role, same three specialties, same three towns, same three offices, same hours, same credentials. So there is nothing in those pages to compare, and we are not going to invent a difference to fill a paragraph. We also cannot measure whether either of them is better at anything than anybody else, and their pages claim no such thing either.

🏠 Tammy Hottes — Broker
Specialties: Residential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment
Hours: Mon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointment
Her profile names residential, buyers and sellers, and investment, across Marion, Herrin and Carbondale. Her own direct line and email are on that page.

🏠 Kimberly Burchell — Broker
Specialties: Residential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment
Hours: Mon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointment
The same three specialties, the same three towns, the same three offices and the same hours — and her own direct line and email on her own page, not a switchboard.
Kimberly Burchell’s full profile, with a direct line and email ›
What both pages do name is a territory — Marion, Herrin and Carbondale — and a job: residential, buyers and sellers. The About paragraph on each page puts it as working with people “from first homes to forever homes”. A week ago this series took land, and the Sunday before that income properties. Plain houses have never had an edition. So this morning we counted the houses in those three towns, and the headline number turned out to be mostly an illusion.
Their three towns hold 114 of the 260 houses for sale
Across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties our own feed has 450 active listings this morning, of which 260 are houses; the other 190 are land, commercial, income property and manufactured homes. The listings are spread over 34 towns, 31 of which have at least one house for sale. Marion, Herrin and Carbondale between them hold 208 of the listings of every kind and 114 of the 260 houses. Three towns out of 31, and 44% of the houses.
| Town | Houses for sale | Median asking | Median size | Cheapest | Dearest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marion | 74 | $308,000 | 1,994 sq ft | $30,000 | $1,475,000 |
| Herrin | 20 | $140,000 | 1,483 sq ft | $22,000 | $424,000 |
| Carbondale | 20 | $364,500 | 1,994 sq ft | $28,000 | $612,000 |
All 260 houses on this morning’s list carry an asking price, a bedroom count, a bathroom count and a square footage, so every figure in this table is computed over every house in that town — nothing is missing and nothing is estimated.
Read the median column and the three towns look like three markets that have little to do with each other: $140,000 in Herrin, $308,000 in Marion, $364,500 in Carbondale. That is a $224,500 spread across three towns the same two brokers both cover. Now read the size column.
The three towns are three different shapes, not three different price levels
Here is every house in those three towns, sorted into price bands, with the other 28 towns that have a house for sale alongside for scale.
| Asking price | Marion | Herrin | Carbondale | All three | Other towns |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| under $100,000 | 5 | 4 | 2 | 11 | 29 |
| $100,000 to $199,999 | 14 | 8 | 6 | 28 | 43 |
| $200,000 to $299,999 | 18 | 6 | 1 | 25 | 30 |
| $300,000 to $499,999 | 25 | 2 | 9 | 36 | 28 |
| $500,000 and up | 12 | 0 | 2 | 14 | 16 |
Counts of houses, not percentages. The last column is the other 28 towns in these four counties that have a house for sale, put together.
What that table shows is not that one town is expensive and another is cheap. It is that the three towns are stocked differently. Marion has houses in every band, and of the 25 houses the three towns have in the $200,000s, 18 are in Marion. Herrin has nothing listed above $424,000 at all — that is the dearest of its 20 houses. Carbondale is the opposite: 11 of its 20 houses are above $300,000. In the whole $200,000 to $299,999 band it has one house.
Pooled, the three towns do cover the whole ladder — from $22,000 to $1,475,000, at a median of $272,450 against $229,700 across all 260 houses in the four counties. Taken one at a time they do not. If you are buying in the $200,000s and you have decided on Carbondale, this morning there is one house to look at. That is a real constraint, and it is the sort of thing you want to hear in the first conversation rather than the fifth.
Most of the $224,500 is square footage, not the town
The median house for sale in Herrin is 1,483 square feet. In Carbondale it is 1,994. That is about 500 square feet of difference in what is on the market — and it is doing most of the work in that $224,500 headline.
Narrow it to houses of a comparable size and the gap collapses. Between 1,200 and 1,799 square feet, Herrin has seven houses at a median of $140,000 and Carbondale has six houses at a median of $160,500. $20,500 apart, against $224,500 — 9% of it. Drop the single dearest house in each town as a check and it is $17,050, so it does not hang on one listing.
That is 13 houses between the two towns, and we are not going to dress it up as more than it is. It is the only size band where both towns have enough houses to put a median on at all, which is exactly why it is the only one we are quoting. What we are not telling you is the price per square foot — that figure is not in this post anywhere, and comparing medians inside a size band is a different operation with different limits.
The practical version, for a seller: the house across town at a very different price is probably a very different house, and the list that matters is what else is for sale at your size, not what else is for sale in your town. For a buyer, the same fact read backwards — a town’s median tells you what is listed there, not what a house costs there.
And on the seller’s side, every price change on the board is a cut
137 of the 260 houses on this morning’s list carry a price change on the record — 53% of them. We checked the direction of all 137 against the previous price the record carries, and there is not a single increase among them. The median reduction is $10,000; they run from $600 to $125,000.
And this is not a story about those three towns in particular. In them the share that has cut is 52%; in the other 28 towns it is 53%. The three towns carry a higher median ask and the same rate of price cutting as everywhere else. If you have been telling yourself your town is behaving differently, on this measure it is not.
We can also say what moved in exactly one week, because last Sunday’s pull asked the feed the identical question — same four counties, same filters, same wording, which we checked before comparing anything. 238 houses appear on both lists. Among those, 15 asking prices changed in the week: 14 of them came down and 1 went up. The median reduction over that week was $5,727 and the largest was $20,001.
What this post is not saying
Worth being explicit, because a page full of medians invites conclusions it cannot carry. Nothing here says anything sold. All 450 of these listings are active, and an asking price is not a sale price. Nothing here is a forecast — that more than half the board has reduced tells you where asking prices have been, not where they are going. Nothing here involves the age of a house, because this feed carries no year built at all and we are not going to estimate one. There is no price per square foot and no property-tax figure anywhere on this page. And nothing here ranks Tammy against Kimberly, or either of them against anybody else, because we have no way to measure that and their pages do not claim it.
If you are buying or selling in one of the three towns
Start with the size band rather than the town. Ask what else is listed at your square footage across all three towns, ask how many of those have already reduced, and then talk about price. Tammy and Kimberly both cover all three towns, and so do the rest of our brokers. The number is 618.925.8654, or use the form below and we will have one of them call you.
📞 Buying or Selling in Marion, Herrin or Carbondale?
Tell us which of the three towns you are looking in and whether you are buying or selling, and we will have Tammy or Kimberly get back to you. If you are selling, the first useful question is what else is listed at your size, not just in your town. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.
💬 Greg Holthaus on reading a town median
“A town median is a description of what is for sale, not a price tag on your house. When one town reads $224,500 above another and the gap mostly comes back as square footage, that is the median doing what medians do, and a seller who prices off it is pricing off somebody else’s inventory. The number I would want in front of me is narrower and duller: what else is listed at my size, in all three towns, and how many of those have already come down. On the two brokers — their pages read the same because they are the same template, and I would rather tell you that than pretend I can rank my own people. Call either one.”
— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts
About the numbers: Each broker’s role, hours, specialties, areas and credentials come from their own profile page on this site, read on the morning of November 1, 2026; their direct lines and emails are on those pages and are not repeated here. The two pages were compared line by line and all 166 lines of visible text are identical once name, direct line and email are blanked out. Neither page mentions the other broker anywhere in it, and no relationship between them is stated or implied here. Neither page carries a designation, a tenure, a transaction count or a testimonial, so none appears in this post — nothing about either broker is taken from anywhere but her own page, and the “Est. 2010” on both pages refers to the brokerage, not to either broker. We make no claim that either is better than anyone else. Local figures come from one pull per county of our own local MLS listing feed on the morning of November 1, 2026, active listings in Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties: 450 records, each county’s returned row count equal to its own reported total so none was truncated, all ids distinct, every address in Illinois. 260 of those are houses, and every house figure here is computed over exactly those; all 260 carry an asking price, a bedroom count, a bathroom count and a square footage, so no house figure on this page has a missing-data hole in it. Lot size is on only 148 of them and is not used anywhere. The week-over-week comparison was made only after confirming that both pulls sent the feed byte-identical queries, and it is computed over the 238 houses present in both lists rather than over either list as a whole. The size-band comparison is quoted for one band only, the one where both towns have enough houses to support a median, and the count in that band is printed alongside it; a comparison in a band with three houses in it is not reported. No price per square foot is computed anywhere, no property-tax figure appears, and this feed carries no year-built field so no claim about the age of anything is made. No individual listing is named anywhere in this post. Asking prices are not sale prices, every listing here is active and none of them is described as sold, and nothing on this page forecasts whether prices will rise or fall. Listings change daily; confirm anything you intend to rely on.
