Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Brokers of the Week

Half the Houses Here Have Cut Their Price. Land Cuts Four Times Deeper.

Melanie Harp and Pamela Eversgerd are this week’s brokers, and both pages list “Buyers & Sellers”. So this post measures the thing that sits between a buyer and a seller: 200 of the 445 active listings in these four counties have already cut their asking price, and the records say by how much.

200
listings have cut their price
$10,000
the typical cut
55%
of houses have cut
4.5×
deeper on land

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 8, 2026 · Brokers of the Week

This week’s brokers are Melanie Harp and Pamela Eversgerd. Both are brokers with Southern Illinois Realty Experts, both work out of the Marion, Herrin and Carbondale offices and across all of Southern Illinois, and both list the same three specialties: “Residential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment”.

The middle one of those three is “Buyers & Sellers”, and it is the only part of that line this series has not already built a post around. So this week measures the one number that sits between a buyer and a seller and matters to both: how far the asking prices on this market have actually come down.

What their pages say, and what we are not going to add to it

Melanie HarpPamela Eversgerd
TitleBrokerBroker
SpecialtiesResidential | Buyers & Sellers | InvestmentResidential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment
Areas servedMarion · Herrin · Carbondale · All of Southern IllinoisMarion · Herrin · Carbondale · All of Southern Illinois
HoursMon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointmentMon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointment
Credentials✓ Licensed Illinois Real Estate Broker
✓ Southern Illinois Realty Experts — Team Member (Est. 2010)
✓ Backed by SIRE's One-Stop Shop: Mortgage · Title · Property Management
✓ Serving Marion, Herrin & Carbondale Offices — All of Southern Illinois
✓ Licensed Illinois Real Estate Broker
✓ Southern Illinois Realty Experts — Team Member (Est. 2010)
✓ Backed by SIRE's One-Stop Shop: Mortgage · Title · Property Management
✓ Serving Marion, Herrin & Carbondale Offices — All of Southern Illinois

Read from each broker’s own page on November 8, 2026. Their direct lines and email addresses are on those pages and are deliberately not repeated here — use the links above or the form below.

That table is identical down both columns, and that is not an accident of layout. Both pages carry 166 lines of visible text, and once you blank out the name, the direct telephone number and the email address those 166 lines are the same text. They are the same template. This is the fourth pair in this series where that has been true.

So here is what we are not going to do. We are not going to invent a difference between two brokers whose pages do not state one, we are not going to claim a designation, a length of service or a transaction count that neither page carries, and we are not going to describe them as working together: neither page mentions the other broker anywhere, which we checked rather than assumed. The credential line reads “✓ Southern Illinois Realty Experts — Team Member (Est. 2010)”, and that date belongs to the brokerage, not to either of them.

What the pages do give us is the specialty line, and that is enough. The rest of this post is about the market the two of them work in.

200 of the 445 listings here have cut their price

Each listing record carries a tag when its price has changed, and — this is the part that is new — it also carries the price it was asking before. We had been reporting for a fortnight that the tag cannot tell you when a price moved. It turns out the record will tell you what it moved from, which is the more useful half.

Before using it we checked it against itself. The previous-price field is present on exactly the 200 listings that carry the price-change tag, and on no other listing — not one tagged listing is missing it and not one untagged listing has it. Two different fields, the same 200 records.

And then the finding that needs no arithmetic at all: all 200 of those changes are reductions. Not a single listing in these four counties has raised its asking price. That is 45% of everything for sale here sitting below the number it started at.

How far: $10,000, unless you use the average

This series already published how many had cut — on November 1 it was 137 of 260 houses. Nobody has published how far. Here it is, and the two obvious ways of summarising it disagree by $10,330:

All 200 reductionsMinus the five largest
Typical (median) reduction$10,000$10,000
Average (mean) reduction$20,330$15,749
Smallest$100—
Largest$300,000—
As a share of the previous asking price5.9% (median)—

The median does not move at all when the five largest reductions are taken out; the average falls $4,581. That is the whole case for using the median: the average here is describing five listings, and the median is describing 200.

The shape behind that: 55 of the reductions are $5,000 or less, and 8 are $100,000 or more. The largest single reduction on the market is $300,000 and the smallest is $100. So the typical seller who has moved has moved by about 5.9% of what they were asking, and a handful have moved by a great deal more.

Land is cut less often, and 4.5× deeper

Split the same 200 reductions by what is being sold and the two biggest categories behave in opposite directions.

HousesLand
Active listings246120
How many have cut135 (55%)33 (28%)
Typical reduction$10,000$3,500
As a share of the previous asking price5.0%22.6%
Deepest reduction in the category46.7%59.2%

Both columns come from the same pull on the same morning. No price per square foot and no price per acre appears anywhere in this post, and nothing here says what any parcel or any house is worth.

In plain terms: a house here is roughly twice as likely to have cut as a parcel of land, and when land does cut it cuts 4.5× as deep as a share of what was being asked — 22.6% against 5.0%. In percentage points, 55% of houses have cut against 28% of parcels, a gap of 27 points.

That is not one unusual parcel doing the work. Take out the three deepest land reductions and the land median is still 17.2%, against 4.9% for houses with their own deepest removed. The pattern survives losing its most extreme records, which is the only reason it is in this post.

Why it happens, we do not know and are not going to guess. A listing record carries no zoning, no utilities, no access and no survey, and the question of how a parcel gets priced in the first place is not one this data can answer.

The houses that have not cut are the cheaper ones

111 of the 246 houses on the market carry no reduction at all — they are still asking what they opened at. Their median asking price is $209,000. The houses that have cut are now asking a median $239,900, down from $249,900.

Read that carefully, because it is easy to read backwards. It does not mean cutting makes a house dearer. It means the houses that have needed to cut are, on this list, the dearer ones — and they are still $30,900 above the ones that have not. That is a fact about which houses are sitting, not about what cutting does, and we are not going to dress it up as the second thing.

By county

CountyHouses for saleHow many have cutTypical reduction
Williamson14376 (53%)$14,450
Jackson3824 (63%)$10,000
Franklin3318 (55%)$9,250
Union3217 (53%)$10,000
All four246135 (55%)$10,000

Houses only. No county is described here as a better or worse place to buy or sell, and the differences below are not large enough to carry one.

Jackson County is the one place where the share stands out: 63% of its houses have cut, against the low fifties everywhere else. The typical reduction is largest in Williamson at $14,450 and smallest in Franklin at $9,250. We are not going to tell you why, because four counties is not enough to tell a reason from a coincidence, and this post prints no county house prices for you to check one against.

What this does and does not tell you

One number has not moved. The typical house reduction is $10,000 today and it was $10,000 when this series last counted, on November 1. A figure standing still across a week is not the same as a week in which nothing happened, and we are not going to tell you what it means, because two readings a week apart is not a trend.

Between yesterday morning’s pull and this one, on a byte-identical query, three listings changed price and all three came down, $45,000 between them, while one listing arrived and four listings left. That is far too small a number to carry any conclusion, and it is here only to show that the cutting is continuous rather than something that happened once.

And the honest limits on all of it. A reduction in a listing record is a change in an asking price, not a sale and not a valuation. Nothing on this page is described as sold, pending or contingent, because nothing we read says it is. We did not open a single individual listing file, so there is no days-on-market figure here and none is implied. And this is one morning’s picture of a list that changes daily.

💬 Greg Holthaus on a reduced asking price

“Here is the number I would want in my head on either side of this. 200 of the 445 things for sale in these four counties are already asking less than they opened at, and not one of them is asking more. If you are selling, that is the room you are competing in, and the typical move in it is $10,000. If you are buying, the number in front of you may already be the second number, not the first, and knowing which changes how you open. What I would not do is read a big reduction as a bargain or a small one as a firm seller — the record tells you what the price used to be and nothing whatsoever about why. That part is a phone call, and Melanie and Pamela both take those.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker

Questions about this week

Who are this week’s Brokers of the Week?

Melanie Harp and Pamela Eversgerd, both brokers with Southern Illinois Realty Experts, working out of the Marion, Herrin and Carbondale offices and across all of Southern Illinois. Both list “Residential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment” as their specialties and both keep the same hours: “Mon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointment”. You can reach either of them through Melanie’s page or Pamela’s page.

How many houses for sale here have cut their asking price?

135 of 246 houses across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties carry a reduction in the listing record — 55% of them. The typical reduction is $10,000, which is 5.0% of what was being asked before. Across all 445 active listings of every kind the count is 200, and every single one is a reduction — not one listing in these four counties has raised its price.

Is a bigger reduction a better deal?

We cannot tell you that and this page does not try. A reduction tells you what the asking price used to be, not what the house is worth, and a listing that opened high and came down twice can still be asking more than one that opened sensibly. The useful thing a reduction tells you is that the seller has already moved once. What that is worth in a particular negotiation is a conversation with a broker who has seen the house.

Why is land cut so much harder than houses?

We do not know, and we are not going to invent a reason. What we measured is that land is cut less often — 28% of parcels against 55% of houses — and that when it is cut the reduction is 22.6% of the asking price against 5.0% for houses. That is 4.5× deeper, and it survives removing the three deepest land cuts, so it is not one unusual parcel. Why it happens is a question about how parcels get priced in the first place, which the listing records do not answer.

Where do these numbers come from?

From two pulls of local MLS listing data, taken one day apart across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties, with status set to active on both. The reduction figures come from a field in each listing’s own record that carries the previous asking price. It is present on exactly the 200 listings tagged as having changed price and on no others, which is the cross-check that made it safe to use. No individual listing is named anywhere on this page.

📞 Buying or Selling in Marion, Herrin or Carbondale?

Tell us which of the three towns you are looking in and whether you are buying or selling, and we will have Melanie or Pamela get back to you. If you are selling, the first useful question is what else is listed at your size, not just in your town. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.

Find a Broker

Want to know whether the price in front of you has already moved? Send an address and a broker will tell you what the record says, whoever holds the listing. Find your broker › or text 618.925.8654.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About these figures: Melanie Harp and Pamela Eversgerd are described only as their own pages describe them, read from the live site on November 8, 2026: title, specialties, areas served, hours and the four credential lines. The 166 lines of visible text on the two pages are identical once the name, the direct line and the email address are blanked, which was checked before any angle was chosen. No designation, length of service, transaction count or testimonial appears, because neither page carries one; no tenure is read into the credential line’s “Est. 2010”, which is the brokerage’s date and not either broker’s; and no relationship between the two is stated or implied, because neither page mentions the other anywhere. Their direct lines and email addresses are on their own pages and are not repeated in this post. The social preview image is the neutral company image rather than either headshot. The listing figures come from two pulls of local MLS listing data taken one day apart — November 7 and November 8 — one county at a time across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union with status set to active on both: 259 in Williamson, 67 in Jackson, 71 in Franklin, 48 in Union, 445 in all. Each county’s returned count equals its own reported total, every identifier is distinct, none appears in more than one county, and both pulls echo byte-identical queries; the queries were loaded out of a stored response rather than retyped. Exactly 2 listings carry no price and both are commercial leases, so the other 443 all carry one. The reduction figures come from a previous-asking-price field in each listing’s own record, and it is present on exactly the 200 listings carrying a price-change tag and on no others — a set equality, checked both ways, which is what made the field safe to use. All 200 are reductions and none is an increase. Medians are used throughout rather than averages, and the reason is printed above: the median reduction does not move when the five largest are removed while the average falls $4,581. The land-against-houses finding is reported only because it survives removing the three deepest land reductions. No reason is given for why land is cut harder, because a listing record carries no zoning, utilities, access or survey. A reduction is a change in an asking price, not a sale and not a valuation; nothing on this page is described as sold, pending or contingent. No individual listing file was opened, so no days-on-market figure appears, and no individual listing is named anywhere. No property-tax figure, no price per square foot and no price per acre appears. No county is ranked as a place to buy or sell, and neither broker is compared with anybody. Nothing on this page is a loan offer, a rate quote or any statement about financing — no interest rate, no monthly payment and no lender appears in it, which is deliberate for every edition of this series except the Saturday financing post. This is one morning’s picture of an active list that changes daily.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us