Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Brokers of the Week

Price Cuts Around Here Cluster on Round Numbers. Twice as Often as the Prices Do.

97 of the 206 price reductions on this market are an exact $5,000 step. Rebuild those reductions out of real asking prices 4,000 times and you get about 47, never 97. Brokers of the Week: Rob Underwood and Bryar Eaton.

206
listings carry a price reduction
$10,000
the commonest single size
97
are an exact $5,000 step
47
what this market produces on its own

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 15, 2026 · Brokers of the Week

This week’s brokers are Rob Underwood and Bryar Eaton. Both are brokers with Southern Illinois Realty Experts, both work out of the Marion, Herrin and Carbondale offices and across all of Southern Illinois, and both list the same three specialties: “Residential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment”.

Their two pages are the same template. We are not going to pretend otherwise and we are not going to invent a difference between them, so this post is about the market the two of them work in — and specifically about something in the data we had not looked at before: not how many prices have come down, but what size a price cut actually is.

What their pages say, and what we are not adding to it

Rob UnderwoodBryar Eaton
TitleBrokerBroker
SpecialtiesResidential | Buyers & Sellers | InvestmentResidential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment
Areas servedMarion · Herrin · Carbondale · All of Southern IllinoisMarion · Herrin · Carbondale · All of Southern Illinois
HoursMon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointmentMon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointment
Credentials· Licensed Illinois Real Estate Broker
· Southern Illinois Realty Experts — Team Member (Est. 2010)
· Backed by SIRE's One-Stop Shop: Mortgage · Title · Property Management
· Serving Marion, Herrin & Carbondale Offices — All of Southern Illinois
· Licensed Illinois Real Estate Broker
· Southern Illinois Realty Experts — Team Member (Est. 2010)
· Backed by SIRE's One-Stop Shop: Mortgage · Title · Property Management
· Serving Marion, Herrin & Carbondale Offices — All of Southern Illinois

Read off each broker’s own page this morning. Their direct lines and email addresses are published on those pages and are deliberately not repeated here — use the links above or the form at the foot of this post.

That table is identical down both columns, and it is not a layout accident. Both pages carry 197 lines of visible text, and once you blank out the name, the direct telephone number and the email address, those 197 lines are the same text. They are the same template, and this is the fifth pair in this series for which that has been true.

So, plainly: we are not claiming a designation, a length of service or a transaction count that neither page carries, and we are not describing the two of them as working together, because neither page mentions the other broker anywhere — which we checked rather than assumed. The credential line that reads “Southern Illinois Realty Experts — Team Member (Est. 2010)” is about the brokerage and not about either of them.

206 of the 454 listings carry a reduction

Every active listing record carries a label when its price has changed, and the ones that do also carry the price that was being asked before. Those two go together exactly: 206 records carry the label, the same 206 carry a previous price, and no record has one without the other. We check that every time rather than assume it, because the whole of this post is the subtraction between those two numbers.

Every one of the 206 is a reduction. Not one is an increase. They run from $100 to $300,000, they come to $4,264,054 added together, and the typical one is $10,000.

These are not this week’s reductions, and it matters that we say so. The records carrying them were last touched across 121 different days, the oldest in 2025. This is the standing stock of listings that have come down at some point, not a week of news. And we are not using those dates as dates: on November 13 this series watched twelve records in this same feed move backwards in time. They are good for establishing that the 206 are spread over more than a year, and for nothing else.

The sizes are not arbitrary numbers

Here is what we had not looked at. $10,000 appears 39 times among those 206 reductions — not approximately, exactly. After it: $5,000 17 times, $20,000 11 times, $25,000 9 times. Those four sizes alone account for 76 of the reductions.

Widen it out and the pattern holds. 97 of the 206 reductions are an exact multiple of $5,000, and 62 of those 97 are a multiple of $10,000 as well. That is short of half — 109 of them are not a $5,000 multiple at all — so this is a strong tendency and not a rule, and we are not going to write it as one.

And “because prices are round” does not explain it

That is the obvious objection and it is a good one. A reduction is the difference between two prices. Asking prices around here are already round — plenty of them end in three zeros — so a round difference comes partly for free, and counting round reductions without allowing for that would prove nothing at all.

So we tested it. We rebuilt all 206 reductions 4,000 times over. Each time, every listing keeps the price it was asking before, and the new price is replaced by another real asking price from this same market — a genuine figure somebody is asking for a genuine property, drawn from the 452 prices in these four counties today. If the roundness were inherited from the prices, those rebuilt reductions would be just as round as the real ones.

Reductions that are an exact multiple ofWhat we observeWhat this market produces on its ownThe roundest of 4,000 rebuilds
$5,000974770
$10,000622643

The middle column is the average across 4,000 rebuilds; the right-hand column is the single roundest rebuild of all 4,000. Not one rebuild reached either observed figure, and the roundest came 27 short at $5,000.

So the roundness is not inherited. It is in the decision. When a price comes down around here it comes down a step — and more than twice as often as the prices themselves would account for.

What that does not tell you is who decided, or why, or whether a round reduction is a good one. The records carry no reason and no name, and a round cut is not evidence of a careless seller any more than an odd one is evidence of a careful one. This is a finding about the shape of numbers.

Why that matters if you have a number in mind

If a reduction normally arrives as a step, then the useful question about a listing above your number is not whether it will come down. It is how many steps above you it sits. A gap of one step and a gap of four steps are different situations, and the table below is the only thing on this page that bears on either.

Your numberHouses above itWithin one $5,000 stepWithin twoWithin threeWithin four
$200,00014014711
$250,000110nonenone35

Houses only — 249 of them, median asking price $230,000. Neither number is a recommendation and neither row is a forecast: these are asking prices today, and nothing here says any of these houses will move.

Take the $200,000 row. Of the 140 houses sitting above that line, 1 is within a single $5,000 step of it, 4 are within two steps and 11 within four. That is a list of 11 houses out of 140 — short enough that somebody can watch it for you, and far too specific to find by refreshing a search page once a week.

That is the honest version of what the two brokers above are for. Not a prediction, and not a promise that any of those houses moves. A short list, and somebody who notices.

Where this sits beside the last two posts

This series has now looked at the same field from three directions in three days, and the answers fit together rather than fighting.

On Friday a Carterville post showed that the label is a record of reductions rather than of price changes — it caught every cut in that town and missed every increase. Yesterday’s post showed that reductions barely move the number of houses under a given ceiling; what moves that count is which houses arrive and leave. Today adds the third piece: when a reduction does happen, it is a round step. A record of round steps that misses increases is a narrower instrument than it looks, and it is worth knowing its shape before leaning on it.

And the day itself, which was almost still

Between yesterday morning’s reading and this one, three asking prices changed, one listing arrived and two listings left across all four counties. Three moves in a day is what a Saturday to a Sunday should look like, and we are not going to make a trend out of it. All three were reductions: $26,000, $35,000, $100,999.

What this does not tell you

It does not tell you when any of these 206 reductions happened. The only date in the record is one we have watched run backwards.

It does not tell you why any price came down, or who chose the figure. The records carry no reason, no office field and no agent field.

It does not tell you that anything sold. A reduction is a change in an asking price, not a sale — every figure here is an asking price, and nothing on this page is described as sold, pending or contingent.

It does not tell you what any house is worth, and it does not tell you that a house one step above your number will come down to it. No forecast appears on this page.

And it does not tell you anything about Rob or Bryar beyond what their own pages say, which is deliberate. Their pages are a template; the market is not.

💬 Greg Holthaus on how a price actually comes down

“Nobody sits down with a spreadsheet and works out the exact figure. A price comes down in steps, because that is how the conversation goes — you take $5,000 off, or you take $10,000 off. Of the 206 reductions in these four counties, 39 are exactly $10,000. What that means for a buyer is that the listings worth watching are the ones sitting one or two steps over your number, and that is a short list — at $200,000 this morning it was eleven houses. That is a phone call, not a search. Ask Rob or Bryar which ones those are this week.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker

Questions about this week

Who are this week’s Brokers of the Week?

Rob Underwood and Bryar Eaton, both brokers with Southern Illinois Realty Experts, working out of the Marion, Herrin and Carbondale offices and across all of Southern Illinois. Both list the same three specialties — “Residential | Buyers & Sellers | Investment” — and both keep the same hours, “Mon–Sat 8am–6pm · Sun by appointment”. You can reach either of them through Rob’s page or Bryar’s page, where their direct lines are published.

How many listings around here have cut their asking price?

206 of the 454 active listings across four counties carry a price-change record, and every single one of them is a reduction — not one is an increase. The reductions run from $100 to $300,000 with a typical size of $10,000. They are not this week’s reductions: the records that carry them were last touched across 121 different days going back to 2025, so this is the standing stock of listings that have come down at some point, not a week’s worth of news.

What is the most common size of a price cut?

$10,000, and it is not close — 39 of the 206 reductions are exactly that. After it come $5,000 (17), $20,000 (11), $25,000 (9). 97 of the 206 are an exact multiple of $5,000, and 62 of those 97 are a multiple of $10,000 as well. That is short of half, and it is still far more roundness than this market produces by itself.

Could that just be because asking prices are round to begin with?

That is the right objection, and it is the one we tested. A reduction is the difference between two prices, so if both prices are round the difference is round for free. So we rebuilt the 206 reductions 4,000 times over, keeping each listing’s old price and replacing the new one with another real asking price from this same market. A multiple of $5,000 came up about 47 times that way, against the 97 we actually see; a multiple of $10,000 about 26 times against 62. Not one of the 4,000 rebuilds reached either figure. The roundness is in the decision, not in the prices.

Does that tell me anything useful if I have a number in mind?

It tells you the shape of the question. If a reduction is normally a round step, then what matters is how far a listing sits above your number in those steps. At $200,000 there are 140 houses above the line, and only 1 of them is within one $5,000 step of it, 4 within two and 11 within four. That is a short enough list for somebody to watch on your behalf, which is the honest version of what a broker does here. It is not a prediction that any of them will come down, and this post makes none.

Does a round price cut mean the seller is not serious?

No, and nothing here supports that reading. We measured the size of reductions, not the reasons for them, and the records carry no reason, no date we trust and nothing about who decided. A round reduction is not evidence of a casual seller any more than an odd one is evidence of a careful one. The only claim this post makes is about the shape of the numbers.

📞 Buying or Selling in Marion, Herrin or Carbondale?

Tell us which of the three towns you are looking in and roughly what you are working with, and we will have Rob or Bryar get back to you. If you have a number in mind, the useful question is which listings sit one step above it — and that is a short list somebody can actually watch for you. Or text 618.925.8654 and ask which ones they are this week. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.

Find a Broker
Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About these figures: The listing counts come from two readings of local MLS listing data — November 14 and November 15 — taken one county at a time across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union with status set to active on both: 269 in Williamson, 64 in Jackson, 74 in Franklin, 47 in Union, 454 in all. Each county’s returned count equals its own reported total, all 454 identifiers are distinct and none appears in more than one county, and both readings echo byte-identical queries; the queries were loaded out of the stored November 14 responses rather than retyped, because a retyped query once came back with zero results and no error at all. This morning’s reading was run two times and returned the identical set of listings both times. The 206 reductions are the records that carry both a price-change label and a previous price, and those two are on exactly the same records — checked this morning, not inherited. Each reduction is the subtraction of the two figures in its own record; no reduction is attributed to a date, because the only date those records carry is one this series watched move backwards on November 13. The rebuilt comparison draws from the 452 asking prices in today’s reading, keeps each listing’s own previous price, and replaces only the new one, 4,000 times with a fixed seed so the figures can be reproduced exactly. The two broker pages were read from our own site files on November 15, 2026, and every fact in the table above — title, specialties, areas, hours, credentials — is selected out of them rather than typed. Both pages were checked for the office-number contradiction this series has been tracking — 9 of the 26 broker pages on the site display an older pair of office numbers that the rest contradict — and both of these two display the current pair; nothing further about it appears above. No designation, length of service, transaction count, award or testimonial appears for either broker, because neither page carries any. Neither page mentions the other broker, so no working relationship is described. Nothing on this page is a loan offer, a rate quote or any statement about financing: no interest rate, no monthly payment, no lender and no pre-qualification figure appears in it, and no percentage appears anywhere above — every figure is a count or an amount of money. No days-on-market figure, no property-tax figure and no price per square foot appears: the records this post reads carry none of those, and no office field and no agent field either. No individual listing is named and no address appears. Prices are asking prices, not sale prices, and nothing here is described as sold, pending or contingent. A reduction is a change in an asking price, not a sale and not a valuation. No county is ranked as a place to buy or sell, and neither broker is compared with the other or with anybody else. No broker other than Rob Underwood, Bryar Eaton and Greg Holthaus is named, and no other brokerage is named. No forecast appears: nothing above says any price will move.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us