Twenty-two houses are for sale in Carterville this morning. Here is every one of them, cheapest first — and then the thing the price tags do not tell you, which is that in this town the two-hundred-thousand-dollar line is not really a price at all. It is a date.
| Address | Asking | Built | Sq ft | $/sq ft | Days listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 308 California St | $112,900 | 1960 | 1,344 | $84 | 81 |
| 616 E Grand Ave | $149,000 | 1940 | 1,092 | $136 | 10 |
| 127 Weisbrook Ln | $170,000 | 1975 | 1,600 | $106 | 178 |
| 412 Elles Ave | $174,000 | 1952 | 1,848 | $94 | 10 |
| 404 Howerton St | $199,000 | 1971 | 1,920 | $104 | 151 |
| 215 E Vermont St | $219,900 | 2026 | 1,545 | $142 | 140 |
| 1401 S Thomas St | $242,000 | 1968 | 2,054 | $118 | 39 |
| 307 Noah Ln | $249,000 | 2015 | 1,710 | $146 | 369 |
| 635 Anderson St | $274,000 | 2026 | 1,650 | $166 | 131 |
| 13256 Cruse Rd | $289,000 | 1985 | 2,240 | $129 | 37 |
| 1108 Main St | $330,000 | 2023 | 2,632 | $125 | 90 |
| 5934 Chandler Dr | $334,900 | 2025 | 1,757 | $191 | 11 |
| 505 Victor Ln | $339,900 | 1976 | 2,180 | $156 | 127 |
| 15247 Laminack Rd | $345,000 | 2005 | 2,500 | $138 | 158 |
| 513 Dogwood Ln | $349,900 | 1970 | 2,886 | $121 | 57 |
| 307 Woodlake Ct | $360,000 | 1997 | 2,263 | $159 | 131 |
| 203 Cora Mae Ct | $450,000 | 2007 | 4,156 | $108 | 93 |
| 1504 Sycamore Rd | $469,500 | 2000 | 2,650 | $177 | 24 |
| 5721 & 5715 Michael Ln | $499,999 | 1972 | 4,200 | $119 | 36 |
| 701 Natalie Ct | $550,000 | 2016 | 2,958 | $186 | 14 |
| 503 Arbor Dr | $550,000 | 1997 | 5,800 | $95 | 109 |
| 907 Laminack Rd | $780,000 | 2020 | 4,678 | $167 | 4 |
Shaded rows are the five houses asking under $200,000. A bold year means the house was built before 1976. “Days listed” is the days-on-market figure published on the current listing — see the note at the foot of this page for what it does and does not measure.
Under $200,000 in Carterville Means a House Built Before 1976
Look at the shaded rows. All five houses asking under $200,000 were built between 1940 and 1975. Not one of them was finished in the last fifty years. The newest of the five went up in 1975; two of them date from the 1940s and 1950s.
Now step up one rung. The most expensive house in that group is 404 Howerton St at $199,000, built 1971. The cheapest house in Carterville built after 1975 is 215 E Vermont St at $219,900 — built 2026, this year. There is nothing for sale in between. The entire distance between “everything available to me was built before I was born” and “brand new” is $20,900.
That is the single most useful sentence we can write about this market today, and it is worth sitting with if you have been shopping the under-$200,000 band and wondering why every listing needs something. It is not bad luck. It is the whole band. Fourteen of the twenty-two houses here were built after 1975 and every one of them is priced at $219,900 or above.
And the Newer Houses Are the Ones Sitting
This is where it gets interesting, because the obvious guess is wrong. Cut the twenty-two houses at 1976 and compare how long each group has been listed:
- Built before 1976 — eight houses. Median 48 days on the market. Two of the eight have been listed longer than ninety days, which is 25%.
- Built 1976 or later — fourteen houses. Median 101 days. Eight of the fourteen past ninety days, which is 57%.
The older half of this market is moving in roughly half the time. The median gap is 48 days against 101, and the share sitting past three months is 25% against 57% — two separate measurements pointing the same way, which is what makes it worth printing. The older houses are also smaller and cheaper per foot: a median of 1,884 square feet at $112 a foot, against 2,381 square feet at $151 a foot.
We are not going to tell you why, because we would be guessing and you would have no way to check us. Price is the obvious candidate — the pre-1976 median ask is $186,500 against $342,450 — but “cheaper things sell faster” does not survive the next section, so take the measurement and leave the mechanism alone.
| Band | Houses | Built | Median ask | Median $/sq ft | Median days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| under $200,000 | five | 1940–1975 | $170,000 | $104 | 81 |
| $200,000 to $299,999 | five | 1968–2026 | $249,000 | $142 | 131 |
| $300,000 to $399,999 | six | 1970–2025 | $342,450 | $147 | 108.5 |
| $400,000 to $499,999 | three | 1972–2007 | $469,500 | $119 | 36 |
| $500,000 and up | three | 1997–2020 | $550,000 | $167 | 14 |
Medians on three houses are not worth much and we have shown the count beside every one so you can see which rows to lean on.
And look at what happens if you do lean on them: the top two bands, on three houses each, show the fastest median days of anything on the table. That is the whole reason the count column is there. One four-day-old arrival in a band of three drags its median further than any real change in the market could, which is why the section above cuts the list into halves of eight and fourteen rather than into five thin slices.
A Finding We Published Three Weeks Ago, Which We Are Now Withdrawing
On September 18 we reported the opposite shape, cut by price instead of by age: the cheap end of Carterville was the slow end. Under $200,000 ran a median of 143 days with eight of ten past ninety, against 72 days and nine of the twenty-seven for $200,000 and up. By October 2 that gap had narrowed to 137 days and 81.5 days.
Run the same price cut this morning and it is 81 days under $200,000 against 90 days at $200,000 and up — the two bands are now within nine days of each other, and what little difference is left points the other way.
The honest reason is not that the market turned. It is that the band emptied out. On September 18 there were ten houses under $200,000 in Carterville. This morning there are five — five fewer — and two of those five are past ninety days. A median of five houses is not a market reading, it is an anecdote with a decimal point, and we are not going to defend a three-week-old comparison by pretending otherwise. The September 18 figure cannot be re-tested, so we are withdrawing it rather than updating it.
What can be measured today is the age cut above, because it has eight houses on one side and fourteen on the other. That is the number to carry forward.
Four of the Six Houses With Land Are Not on Public Sewer
Here is something that never makes a listing summary and costs real money to discover late. Four of the twenty-two houses publish a water-and-sewer line that is not simply public on both — two on a septic system and two on an aerator or aerobic system. And they are not scattered at random:
| Address | Asking | Built | Lot | Water and sewer, as published |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13256 Cruse Rd | $289,000 | 1985 | 0.97 acres | Septic System |
| 15247 Laminack Rd | $345,000 | 2005 | 11.469 acres | Public, Septic System |
| 1504 Sycamore Rd | $469,500 | 2000 | 2 acres | Public, Aerator/Aerobic |
| 907 Laminack Rd | $780,000 | 2020 | 17.75 acres | Public, Aerator/Aerobic |
Carterville has six houses for sale sitting on nine-tenths of an acre or more, and all four of the houses in that table are among them — which is to say four of the six houses with real ground are off public sewer, and not one off-sewer house is on a small lot. If you are shopping Carterville specifically because you want a bit of ground, you are shopping the part of the market where a septic inspection, a tank location and a leach-field age are part of the deal rather than a footnote. That is not a reason to avoid them — it is a reason to budget the inspection and ask the age of the system before you are emotionally committed to the kitchen.
Two record-keeping notes while we are in this field, because they get the same treatment. 215 E Vermont St publishes a sewer entry and no water source at all, and 13256 Cruse Rd publishes a septic entry and no water source at all. We have left both cells exactly as the records have them rather than assume public water on either, and if you are serious about either house that is a question for the listing agent and not for a web page.
The House That Has Been for Sale for More Than a Year
307 Noah Ln, asking $249,000, built 2015, in Noah Landing, has been on the market 369 days. The next longest run in Carterville is 178 days, so this one has been listed more than twice as long as anything else in town. It is 1,710 square feet.
Something did change on that listing 131 days ago — the record logs an update then — but the days-on-market clock kept running through it, which is how we know the two numbers are measuring different things. We are not going to tell you the price came down, because the feed does not say that. It says the listing was altered. If you want to know what moved and when, that is a phone call, and it is exactly the phone call worth making on a listing that has been sitting this long.
Cheapest and Dearest by the Foot
Price per square foot in Carterville runs from $84 at 308 California St, a 1960 house of 1,344 square feet asking $112,900, to $191 at 5934 Chandler Dr, built 2025, 1,757 square feet at $334,900. No two listings tie once the figure is rounded to the dollar, so that range is a genuine spread rather than an artefact.
Note what the two ends are: the cheapest per foot is the third-oldest house on the list, and the dearest per foot was finished last year — though it is not even the newest here, because two of these houses went up this year. In this town you are not paying by the square foot, you are paying by the decade — which is the same thing the $200,000 line was telling us at the top of this page, arriving from a different direction.
For whatever it is worth as a reality check on all of these asking prices: the median house that actually closed in ZIP 62918 in August went for $247,750. Six of the eight pre-1976 houses on this list are asking less than that figure. We have not done any arithmetic between the two numbers, and you should not either — that ZIP takes in rural ground well outside the town limits, so it is not the same geography as the twenty-two houses above. It is a sanity check, nothing more.
🔮 What Greg Would Do in This Market
If your ceiling is $200,000 in Carterville, stop waiting for a newer house to appear in your range, because the whole band is pre-1976 and it has been shrinking, not growing. Budget for a roof, a furnace and a service panel, get an inspector you trust, and treat the age as the price you are paying for the location rather than as a problem with the listing. If you can reach $219,900, you are suddenly choosing from houses built this decade, and that $20,900 buys you more than any cosmetic upgrade will. And if you want ground, ask about the septic system on the first call — four of the six houses with real acreage here are on one.

💰 Walking In Without a Pre-Qual Is a Browse, Not an Offer
If one of these turns out to be the one, the seller’s agent will ask what you are approved for before they take you seriously. Free, no-pressure pre-qualification with Jarod Sanders, SIRE’s in-house lender.Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228
🔑 Want the Actual Numbers on One of These?
Twenty-two houses is the whole list, and a page cannot tell you which ones have had work done or what the inspection is going to find. A SIRE broker can walk you through any of them and pull the real history before you make an offer. Tell us what you are after.
📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.
Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About these numbers: Active listing counts, asking prices, square footage, bedroom and bathroom counts and lot sizes come from local MLS listing data for Carterville, pulled on October 9, 2026. Year built, days on market, subdivision and water-and-sewer source come from the same listing records’ detail pages. The list was pulled two independent ways and both returned the same 33 listings — once by a Carterville town search and once by pulling all 249 active Williamson County listings and filtering to Carterville addresses — so the set is not an artefact of one query. Of the 33, 22 are houses; the other eleven are seven land listings, three commercial listings and one residential income property, and they are excluded from every figure in this post. Geography: all 22 houses carry a Carterville address in ZIP 62918. One of the excluded land listings carries a Carterville address in ZIP 62959, which is a reminder that a town name and a ZIP code are not the same boundary — ZIP 62918 also takes in rural ground outside the town limits, which is why the one closed-sale figure quoted here is labelled as a ZIP figure and is not compared arithmetically to the asking prices. What “days listed” measures, and what it does not: it is the days-on-market figure published on the current listing. It is not a measure of how long a property has been for sale across earlier listings, and we never compare it against a day count from a different source. We checked whether it resets when a listing changes: on 18 of the 22 houses it equals the days since the listing’s last recorded change, because for those the last change was the listing itself, and on four it is longer — so the clock is cumulative and keeps running through a change. Where a record logs a change we have not said what changed. The feed records that a listing was updated and carries a “price change” flag on 17 of the 22, but it does not date the price move, so no price change in this post is dated and none is described as a reduction. Medians are taken from the raw figures and rounded once. Counts are shown beside every median so a reader can see which rows rest on three houses and which rest on fourteen. Price per square foot is the asking price divided by the published square footage, rounded to the nearest dollar. Square footage, lot size, year built and the water-and-sewer line are as published on the listing record and we have not independently verified them — a septic or aerobic entry here is a prompt to inspect, not a survey. A finding from our September 18 Carterville post is withdrawn in this one rather than updated, because the price band it described has gone from ten houses to five and a median of five houses will not carry the claim. The closed-sale figure is the median sale price for ZIP 62918 in August 2026, the most recent month published as of today; September had not posted when we checked. Listings are represented by various brokerages and most of these are not ours. Nothing here is an appraisal, a loan offer, or a rate quote. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.
