There are 24 houses for sale in Carterville this morning, asking a median of $281,500 and running from $68,000 to $550,000. Those are the numbers we usually give you. This week we went after a different question: what are these houses actually made of?
We pulled the full listing record for every one of the 24 — heating, basement, water, sewer, build year, school. Three of those answers describe nearly every house on the list, and the first of them will show up on a heating bill this winter.
21 of the 24 have no gas line at all
21 of the 24 houses list no natural gas of any kind. Only three mention it. 19 are heated on the electric side — tagged Electric, Heat Pump or Baseboard — and 10 of those are running a heat pump.
If you are moving here from somewhere with a gas furnace, that is the single most practical fact on this page. We are not going to tell you electric heat costs more, because we did not measure a single utility bill and we are not going to guess at yours. What we will say is that it behaves differently: a heat pump's output falls off as the outside temperature drops and the backup element picks up the difference, so the shape of a January bill is not the shape you may be used to. Ask the seller for twelve months of actual bills. That is a normal thing to ask for, and most sellers can produce them.
19 of the 24 have no basement
Only five of the 24 houses have a basement, and only three of those are finished or part-finished. Eight of the houses with none have a crawl space, which is useful for pipes and is not a basement.
| The five houses that do have a basement | What the record says | Asking |
|---|---|---|
| 203 Cora Mae Ct | Egress Window(s), Finished, Full, Sump Pump | $450,000 |
| 307 Woodlake Ct | Finished, Partial | $360,000 |
| 513 Dogwood Ln | Partially Finished | $349,900 |
| 404 Howerton St | Partial, Unfinished | $199,000 |
| 603 Pear St | Partial, Unfinished | $68,000 |
The final tag on this field is a plain yes or no. Every other house on the list answers no, including every crawl-space house.
We are stating that as a fact about the housing stock and leaving it there. What a household wants to do about shelter in bad weather is its own decision and not something a listing count settles.
And 15 of the 24 are single-story ranches
Put those three together and the typical Carterville listing comes into focus: a single-story ranch with no basement under it, heated electrically, built around 1980. The oldest on the list went up in 1940 and the newest in 2026, so the range is real — but the middle of this market is a specific kind of house, and it is worth knowing that before you fly in for a weekend of showings.
| What we looked at | Houses | Out of |
|---|---|---|
| No natural gas at all | 21 | 24 |
| Heated on the electric side | 19 | 24 |
| Running a heat pump | 10 | 24 |
| No basement | 19 | 24 |
| No basement, but a crawl space | 8 | 24 |
| Single-story ranch | 15 | 24 |
| On public water | 22 | 24 |
| On public sewer | 21 | 24 |
| Feeding Carterville High School | 23 | 24 |
Heating, basement and water are multi-value fields on the listing record, so each one was read as a list of tags rather than as a single label. A house tagged both Electric and Heat Pump counts once in each of the first two rows.
The town's utilities stop at the town line
22 of the 24 are on public water and 21 on public sewer. Only three sit off the mains.
| Off the town mains | Water and sewer | Asking | High school |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1504 Sycamore Rd | Aerator/Aerobic, Public | $469,500 | Carterville |
| 15247 Laminack Rd | Public, Septic System | $345,000 | Herrin |
| 13256 Cruse Rd | Septic System | $289,000 | Carterville |
Here is the part worth noticing. Those three run from $289,000 to $469,500 with a median of $345,000, against a town median of $281,500. Every one of them is asking more than the typical house in town. Stepping outside the built-up part of Carterville does not buy you a discount here; what it buys you is a septic tank or an aerator to maintain.
One house on that list does not go to Carterville High
23 of the 24 houses feed Carterville High School. One does not. 15247 Laminack Rd, asking $345,000 and built in 2005, feeds Herrin — and it is also one of the three houses on septic.
That is the whole point of the section: a Carterville mailing address is a postal fact, not a school-district fact. One in 24 is enough to matter if you are buying for a district, and it is the kind of thing that is far easier to check before an offer than after. The listing record carries the school; ask for it in writing.
How long these houses have been sitting
The median house on this list has been listed 55 days, and ten of the 24 are past three months. The longest is 307 Noah Ln at 376 days.
That last figure is also a small piece of housekeeping. We reported the same house at 369 days on 9 October. Seven days later it reads 376. The counter has advanced by exactly the number of days that passed, which is the third time this month we have been able to check that on a real listing, and it keeps holding: the clock on a listing runs, and it does not quietly reset.
What we did not do this week
We normally run this town's figures against the previous pull and tell you what arrived, what left and what changed price. We cannot do that this week — the earlier Carterville snapshot was lost, so there is nothing honest to difference against. Rather than reach for a comparison we cannot support, this week is a straight portrait of what is standing there today, and the comparison resumes next week from this pull.
If you want the version of this for a house you are actually looking at — what heats it, what is under it, whose district it is in, and how long it has really been for sale — that is a phone call, and it takes about five minutes.
💬 Greg Holthaus on Electric Heat
“The gas line is the thing people from out of town never think to ask about, and then February happens. It is not that electric is bad — a good heat pump in a tight house is fine, and most of what is for sale here runs one. It is that the bill does not behave the way a gas bill behaves, and the time to find that out is before you own it, not after. Ask for a year of bills. Any seller who has them will hand them over, and the ones who cannot are telling you something too. Same with what is under the house. Only five of these 24 have a basement. That is just what the stock is out here, and it is better to know it going in than to spend weekend after weekend looking for something that is barely on the market.”
🏠 Send Us an Address and We Will Read the Whole Record
Give us a house you are considering in Carterville or anywhere in the four counties, and a broker will come back with what heats it, what is underneath it, whether it is on the town mains, which school district it actually feeds, and how long it has really been listed. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.
📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.
Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About the numbers: Every figure comes from one pull of our own listing feed on the morning of October 16, 2026, filtered to Carterville and to active listings. It returned 35 records, 24 of them houses carrying an asking price, and those 24 are the basis of every count here. Every returned record was checked to carry a Carterville address and every listing number was checked to be distinct. Heating, basement, water source, architectural style, year built, high school and days on market come from the per-listing detail records, pulled for all 35. Heating, basement and water are multi-value tag lists, not single labels, and are counted as tags: a house tagged both Electric and Heat Pump is counted in both of those rows and once in the house total. The basement field ends in a plain yes or no tag and that is what the basement counts use, so a crawl-space house counts as having none. No claim is made that electric heat costs more or less than gas. No utility bill was examined; the only statement about cost is that a buyer should ask the seller for twelve months of actual bills. The remark about heat-pump output falling with outside temperature describes how the equipment works and is not a measurement of any house on this list. The basement figures are a description of the housing stock and nothing more, and no advice about severe weather is offered or implied. Property tax figures are deliberately absent. The field is in these records and this series has leaned on it four times recently; it is resting. Price per square foot is absent for the same reason. There is no week-over-week comparison in this post because the previous Carterville snapshot was lost and nothing honest could be differenced against; today’s pull is retained so that the comparison resumes next week. The one historical figure quoted, 369 days on 9 October for the longest-listed house, is from our own published record of that date. Asking prices are not sale prices, and a standing list over-represents houses that have been on the market a while. With 24 houses, several of these groups are small enough that one sale moves a share noticeably. No agent or brokerage is named anywhere in this post. Nothing here is an appraisal, a loan offer, a rate quote, or a commitment to lend. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.
