Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Carterville

19 Carterville Listings Carry a Price-Change Badge. One Changed Price This Week.

We ran the identical Carterville query on October 16 and again on October 23 and differenced the two by address. The count did not move: 35 listings both weeks. Underneath it, two listings left, two arrived, and exactly one of the 33 that stayed changed anything at all.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 23, 2026

A week ago we pulled every active listing in Carterville and saved the result. This morning we ran the same query again and compared the two pulls, listing by listing, matching on street address. It is the first time this series has had two snapshots of one town seven days apart, and the first thing it turned up is about the little coloured badges on the listing cards.

35
active listings, both weeks
19
badged “price change”
1
actually changed price
4
listings in or out

The badge says price change. On 18 of the 19, it is pointing at something older than this week

Of the 35 active listings in Carterville this morning, 19 carry a price-change badge. That reads, on a search page, like a town where sellers are moving. Here is the badge group with the date the badge itself carries.

Listing badged “Price Change”Badge datedAsking todayDays on the list
0000 Baptist Camp RdFebruary 5$65,000360 days
69 David Livingstone DrMarch 5$45,000504 days
137 S Division StMarch 24$179,900213 days
127 Weisbrook LnApril 14$170,000192 days
15247 Laminack RdMay 5$345,000172 days
404 Howerton StMay 11$199,000165 days
215 E Vermont StMay 23$219,900154 days
307 Noah LnMay 31$249,000383 days
307 Woodlake CtMay 31$360,000145 days
635 Anderson StMay 31$274,000145 days
505 Victor Ln
the one that actually moved this week
June 4$330,000141 days
203 Cora Mae CtJuly 8$450,000107 days
1108 Main StJuly 11$330,000104 days
903 E Grand AveJuly 14$41,500101 days
1401 S Thomas StAugust 31$242,00053 days
5721 & 5715 Michael LnSeptember 3$475,00050 days
308 California StSeptember 8$112,90095 days
1504 Sycamore RdSeptember 15$469,50038 days
5934 Chandler DrSeptember 28$334,90025 days

The badge dates run from February 5 to September 28 — from 25 days ago at the newest to about eight months at the oldest. Every one of them predates the week we just compared. And the group is exactly the same 19 listings it was last Friday — not one listing joined it or left it in a week.

Of the 33 listings that were on the list both weeks — the only ones two snapshots can be compared on — one changed its asking price: 505 Victor Ln went from $339,900 to $330,000, down $9,900, after 141 days on the market. One, out of 33.

And here is the part worth knowing before you read another listing card. 505 Victor Ln’s own price-change badge still reads June 4 — the same date it read last Friday, before the cut. The badge did not move when the price did. So on this list, the badge is not a notification. It is a flag that a price changed at some point in the listing’s life, and the date beside it is not the date of the most recent change.

We are not going to tell you why it works that way, because we do not know. What we can tell you is what the two pulls show: the badge is not a reason to think a seller just moved, and the absence of one is not a reason to think a seller never has.

One of our own listings has been badged “New” for 53 days

The same thing runs in the other direction, and the clearest example is ours, so we will use ours. 10393 Fleming Rd — a land parcel asking $150,000 — still displays a New badge. Its badge is dated August 31, and the record says it has been on the market 53 days.

Meanwhile two listings lost their New badge during this same week, at nine days and eleven days on the market — both of them far younger than ours. Whatever decides when that badge comes off, it is not being applied the same way to every listing, and we are not going to guess at the rule. If you are filtering a search by what is new, that is the thing to know.

35 listings last Friday, 35 today, and four of them are different

The headline count did not budge. Underneath it, two listings left and two arrived. A reader checking a count week to week would have seen nothing happen.

ListingWhat happenedAskingThe record saidOn the list
13256 Cruse RdLeft the list$289,0003 bd · 2 ba · 2,240 sqft · 0.97 acres · built 198544 days
703 Mulberry St
Our listing
Left the list$152,0003 bd · 3 ba · 1,864 sqft · 0.19 acres · built 19452 days
1104 Samantha DrJoined the list$269,0003 bd · 2 ba · 1,482 sqft · lot size not on the record · built 20116 days
1201 Murraywood Ln
Our listing
Joined the list$695,0005 bd · 3 ba · 6,220 sqft · 9 acres · built 20037 days

All four are houses. Every one of the seven land parcels, three commercial properties and one multi-unit property on the list a week ago is still on it, unchanged. The movement in Carterville this week was entirely in houses.

The two that left have not turned up anywhere else the feed can see

A listing leaving an active list is the moment it is easiest to say something untrue, so here is exactly what we did and exactly what we found. We searched the same Carterville query under every other status this feed exposes — Pending, Active Under Contract, Closed, Canceled, Expired and Withdrawn — and looked for both addresses in each one. Neither one appears under any of them.

So we will say the only thing we actually know: they are no longer in the active list. Not that they sold. Not that they went under contract. Not that anybody withdrew them. A listing can leave an active list for several ordinary reasons and the feed we read does not tell us which one applied here. 703 Mulberry St had been listed 2 days and was ours; 13256 Cruse Rd had been listed 44 days. If you want to know where a particular house ended up, that is a phone call, not a badge.

We measured whether a price cut resets the days-on-market clock. It does not

This series has said four times in the last fortnight that a days-on-market figure belongs to the listing record rather than to the house — that a price cut does not reset it and a brand-new record does. Until this morning that was reasoning from single cases. With two pulls of one town exactly seven days apart, it is measurable.

33 listings were in both pulls. Every single one of them advanced its days-on-market figure by exactly seven days. Not one exception, not one that stood still, not one that jumped.

  • 505 Victor Ln cut its price by $9,900 in between the two pulls, and its counter went from 134 to 141 — exactly seven days, the same as the 32 listings that did not touch their price.
  • Nothing else changed on any of the 33. We compared asking price, bedrooms, bathrooms, square footage, lot size, property type, status, year built, listing id, property sub-type, basement and heating on every one. Across 33 listings and seven days, one field moved: that one price.
  • There were no re-listings this week, which is why the two ways of counting agree. Matching on listing id gives two arrivals; matching on address gives two arrivals and no re-listings at all. Those two counts have to reconcile or the comparison is wrong, and this week they do.

Why it matters to somebody standing in a driveway: the number on a listing is a fact about a piece of paperwork, not about a house. A house that has been for sale for a year under three different records can show you a small number. A house that cut its price last week carries the same number it would have carried if it had not. 505 Victor Ln is the proof: $9,900 off, and the clock did not notice.

The dearest house in Carterville arrived this week, and it is ours

1201 Murraywood Ln joined the list at $695,000 — 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 6,220 square feet on 9 acres, built 2003. It is the highest-priced and the largest house on the Carterville list, it is our own listing, and it is listed by Amy Smith, who covers Carterville out of our Herrin office.

The other arrival, 1104 Samantha Dr at $269,000, is 3 bedrooms and 1,482 square feet, built 2011.

Put those against what left and you can see what a flat count hides. A $695,000 house arrived; a $152,000 house left. To the count, those are the same event. The top of the Carterville market got a house this week and the bottom of it lost one, and “35 listings, same as last week” is a true sentence that tells you none of it.

What else is sitting on the list

The 35 listings are 24 houses, 7 land parcels, 3 commercial properties and 1 multi-unit property. That is the same house count the October 16 edition worked from when it looked at how a Carterville house is heated.

  • The houses ask $68,000 to $695,000, median $295,000.
  • They have been listed between 6 days and 383 days, median 71 days. Only 2 of the 24 have been listed longer than 180 days, and one longer than a year.
  • Year built runs 1940 to 2026, and three of the houses are 2025 builds or newer.
  • The longest-listed thing in town is not a house at all: 69 David Livingstone Dr, 0.5 acres of land asking $45,000, at 504 days. The longest-listed house, 307 Noah Ln at $249,000, has been there 383 days.

One figure we are not going to give you is anything about lot size across the houses. Only 12 of the 24 house records carry a lot size at all. Last week’s Carterville edition cut a sentence about land because the figure had not been pulled; this week it has been, for half of them, which is not enough to describe a town with. An average over 12 records is not an average over 24, and a blank is not a zero.

What this method cannot see, and we would rather say so

Two pulls seven days apart have a resolution of seven days. Anything that came onto the Carterville list and left again inside the week is invisible to this comparison, and we would have no way of knowing it happened. The two arrivals are six days and seven days old, which puts them starting on or just after the morning of the first pull — right at the edge of what this window can resolve.

What it does see, it sees exactly: the same query, the same town, the same 35 records differenced address by address, with the id-level counts reconciled against the address-level ones as a check on the match itself. Next Friday there will be three pulls, and the week after that, four.

Want to know which of these has actually moved?

That is the whole point of reading a record instead of a badge. If you are watching a particular Carterville house and want to know what its history actually says — when the price moved, whether the record is the original one, what has changed since it listed — that is a phone call, and it takes about five minutes: 618.925.8654.

💬 Greg Holthaus on reading a listing badge

“19 badges saying price change and one price that actually changed — that is not anybody doing anything wrong, it is a flag doing a different job than the one a buyer thinks it is doing. Same with the New badge on our own land parcel at 53 days. I would rather point at ours than somebody else’s. The lesson is the same one every week: the badge and the day count are facts about the paperwork. If you want to know what a house has actually been through, ask somebody to pull the record and read it to you.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Two pulls of our own local MLS listing feed for Carterville, Illinois, taken on October 16 and October 23, 2026, seven days apart, using the identical query both times — the two filter sets are compared field for field before anything is differenced, because a difference of question is not a difference of market. The two sets are matched on street address, not on listing id: a re-listing changes the id and would read as one departure plus one arrival, so the id-level counts are computed separately and reconciled against the address-level ones. Days on market is a figure about the listing record, not about the house. Only 12 of the 24 house records carry a lot size, so no lot-size figure is generalised and the denominator is published instead. No listing is described as sold, pending or withdrawn; the two addresses that left the active list were searched for under six other statuses and appear under none of them, and that is all this post claims about them. No property-tax figure and no price per square foot appears on this page. Listing agents’ contact details, showing instructions and private remarks are dropped before the data is read and nothing from them reaches this post. Asking prices and listing status change daily; confirm before you act.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us