There are 36 active listings in Carterville this morning, and 20 of them wear a price-change tag — 55.6% of the list. Scrolling that, you would reasonably conclude the town is repricing itself.
We kept last week’s list. Of the 33 listings on the market both weeks, exactly one changed price. One. 32 are asking precisely what they asked seven days ago, and none went up.
The week, measured rather than inferred
| October 23 | October 30 | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Active listings | 35 | 36 | +1 |
| Median asking price | $249,900 | $247,000 | −$2,900 |
| Every asking price added up | $9,431,200 | $9,081,199 | −$350,001 |
| Listings wearing a price-change tag | 19 | 20 | +1 |
| Prices that actually moved | — | 1 | — |
Movement is measured only across the 33 listings present in both pulls. The denominator of a comparison is what the two lists share, not everything either holds.
The one that moved is 412 Elles Ave: $174,000 on October 23, $159,000 today, down $15,000. Same listing record in both pulls — not a re-listing. It is 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, 1,848 square feet, built in 1952. It is not one of ours.
The tag is right. The date on it is not.
Here is the part worth your time. 412 Elles Ave was labelled Active a week ago and is labelled Price Change today, which is correct — the price really did come down in that week. But the date the record keeps alongside that label did not move at all. It reads September 29 in both pulls, 31 days before the cut we measured.
That is not a one-off. All 20 listings wearing the tag today carry exactly the same date they carried a week ago. Not one moved — including the one whose label demonstrably changed. So the date cannot be used to tell you when a price changed, and we are not going to guess what the field is meant to represent. We are telling you what it did, which is nothing.
Which leaves the tags themselves undated, and they are old:
| Tag age | Listing | Asking |
|---|---|---|
| 267 days | 0000 Baptist Camp Rd | $65,000 |
| 239 days | 69 David Livingstone Dr | $45,000 |
| 220 days | 137 S Division St | $179,900 |
| 31 days (the youngest) | 412 Elles Ave | $159,000 |
Dates taken from each record’s own label timestamp. Across all 20 tags they run from 31 days to 267 days, median 150 days. Not one is dated inside the seven days we measured — not even the listing that actually changed price inside it.
On October 26 this series showed a house whose price-change flag had vanished entirely because the listing was re-entered under a new record. This is the same lesson from a third direction: the tag belongs to the paperwork and the price history belongs to the house, and the paperwork is not keeping time.
The practical version, if you are shopping: a price-change tag tells you a price moved at some point, and nothing more. 20 listings in a town of 36 wearing one is not a town repricing; it is a town where most listings have been on the market long enough to have changed price once. The only way to know what moved this week is to have last week’s list.
What came off the list, and what we will not say about it
Two listings left the active list. We looked for both of them under every status this feed exposes before writing a word.
1104 Samantha Dr, which was asking $269,000, now appears as pending. Pending is not sold. A pending sale is a deal under contract that has not closed and can still fall apart, and we are not going to report it as a sale until the feed says it closed.
1201 Murraywood Ln, which was asking $695,000, appears under none of them — not pending, not closed, not cancelled, not expired, not withdrawn. The feed does not account for it, and that is the whole of what we know. It has not sold as far as anything we can see is concerned, and it has not been marked as anything else either.
One honest limit on that sweep, because it matters. Two of those status queries came back with listings and four came back empty. Pending returned 2 and closed returned 70 for Carterville, so the status filter is plainly being honoured. But for the four that returned nothing at all, we cannot tell the difference between “Carterville has none” and “this feed does not fill that status in”. So “it appears under none of them” is honest about where we looked, not a guarantee about where it is.
What came on
| Listing | Asking | Tag today | What the record says |
|---|---|---|---|
| 122 S Division St | $120,000 | New | 3,346 sq ft and no bedroom count |
| 1508 Hawkeye Ct | $239,999 | New | 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,408 sq ft |
| 5673 Arctic Fox Dr | $269,000 | Active | 4 bed, 2 bath, 2,046 sq ft |
Three listings from $120,000 to $269,000. None of them is ours.
One of those needs a note. 122 S Division St carries a floor area of 3,346 square feet and no bedroom count at all. We are not going to tell you what kind of building that is, because the record does not say and a square-footage figure on its own does not decide it. A missing bedroom count is a missing bedroom count — not a zero, and not a licence to guess a property type.
We checked the question before we trusted the answer
Every number above is a difference between two pulls, which only means anything if both pulls asked the same thing. They very nearly did not. The query form this series recorded on October 23 and the one it sent this morning are not byte-identical — they name the same place by the same identifier, but the surrounding text of the request differs.
So before differencing anything we re-ran both forms this morning and compared what came back. They returned the identical 36 listings — the same records, none in one and missing from the other. The difference in the request is cosmetic, the difference in the market is real, and a difference of question is not a difference of market. Had they disagreed, there would be no comparison on this page and we would have said so instead.
💬 Greg Holthaus on price-change tags
“The gap between 20 tags and one actual price change is what I would want a buyer to see. The tag is not lying to you, it is just answering a different question than the one you are asking. You want to know what moved lately. The tag knows that something moved, sometime. When somebody tells me a town is full of price cuts, the first thing I ask is what they are comparing it to, and usually the answer is nothing — they are reading badges. If you want to know what a house has done, somebody has to have written down what it was doing before.”
— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker
Questions we get about Carterville
Are Carterville home prices dropping?
Measured against last week’s list rather than guessed from a badge: of the 33 listings on this query both on October 23 and on October 30, one cut its asking price, none raised one, and 32 did not move at all. The one that moved was 412 Elles Ave, down $15,000. Those are asking prices on listings that have not sold, which is a different thing from what houses are closing for.
What does a price-change tag on a listing actually mean?
That the price changed at some point. It does not tell you when, and the date the record keeps alongside the tag does not either. Of the 20 Carterville listings wearing the tag today, the dates on them run from 31 days to 267 days old, median 150 days, and not one is dated inside the week we actually measured. 412 Elles Ave genuinely cut its price in that week, and its tag is still dated September 29.
How many homes are for sale in Carterville?
36 active listings on October 30, from $39,900 to $550,000, median $247,000. A week earlier the same query returned 35 at a median of $249,900. Three listings came on and two came off.
Did the two houses that disappeared from the list sell?
We are not telling you either of them sold. We looked for both under every status this feed exposes. 1104 Samantha Dr now appears as pending, which is not the same as sold and can still fall through. 1201 Murraywood Ln appears under none of them, so the feed does not account for it and neither will we.
Can you tell whether a price changed this week without last week’s list?
No, and that is the point of this post. The tag does not carry a usable date, so the only way to know what moved in a given week is to have kept the previous week’s list and compared the two, listing by listing. We keep ours. That is also why we re-ran the query both ways this morning before publishing any difference — if the question had changed, the answer would have looked like news.
Looking in Carterville? Send an address and a broker will pull its full price history — every figure it has asked and when, not just the tag on the card. Find your broker › or text 618.925.8654.
About the numbers: Two pulls of our own local MLS listing feed for Carterville, October 23 and October 30, seven days apart, same town identifier, active listings only: 35 records then, 36 now, each pull’s returned rows equal to its own reported total so neither was truncated, every row active in both. The two request forms were NOT byte-identical, so both were re-run this morning and returned the identical 36 records before anything was differenced; the drift was in the request text, not the place. Matched on street line, normalised and asserted to collide nothing in either pull, and reconciled against the record-level counts in the corrected form that subtracts address edits: 3 = (3 − 0) + 0; both correction terms are zero this week, so the older form agrees and the post claims no more than that. Price movement is measured across the 33 listings in both pulls, never inferred from a tag. Tag dates are each record’s own label timestamp; all 20 are unchanged from a week ago, including on the one listing whose label changed, and no claim is made about what that field is for. Per-listing details were loaded with a reader that detects the payload shape per record rather than assuming it — the two archives are stored differently and a loader that assumes either returns nothing for the other, which once produced a false finding — and every flatten is asserted non-empty. Departures were looked for under every status this feed exposes; one is pending, which is not sold, and one appears under none, which is reported as exactly that. Four of those status queries returned nothing at all, and an empty status cannot be distinguished from one this feed does not populate. Private remarks, showing instructions, agents’ contact details, office names, listing agreements, parcel numbers and internal identifiers are dropped at load and asserted absent. Office name is read only to decide whether a listing is ours, and none of the listings named on this page is ours. No property type is named for the record that carries floor area and no bedroom count. Asking prices are not sale prices. No cause is offered for any price move and nothing here is a forecast. No property-tax figure, no price per square foot, no interest rate and no payment figure appears. Listings change daily; confirm anything you intend to rely on.
