Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Carterville

Carterville’s Median Fell $62,550 This Week. Or Rose $2,450.

12 of the 14 listings that arrived this week are different lots at the same $34,000, on two streets. They move the town’s median asking price by $65,000 on their own, which is more than everything else that happened put together.

48
active listings
12
of them one price
$62,550
median fall, as counted
$2,450
median rise, lots aside

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 6, 2026 · Carterville

There are 48 active listings in Carterville this morning, against 36 when we pulled the same query seven days ago. That is 33% more listings in a week, which in a town this size is a large number and would normally be the story.

It is not the story. 12 of the 14 listings that arrived are land parcels on two streets, every one asking $34,000, every one carrying the same tag date and the same number of photographs. 12 listings arrived at one price on one day, and the town’s headline numbers now report that as though 12 separate things had happened.

Here is what that does. The median asking price across all 48 listings fell $62,550, from $247,000 to $184,450 — a drop of 25.3%. Set those 12 lots aside and the median of what is left rose $2,450, to $249,450. Same town, same morning, same query. The two figures point in opposite directions and the gap between them is the finding.

The week, by property type

TypeOctober 30November 6Change
Houses2424None
Land719+12
Commercial44None
Income property11None
Total3648+12

Every category except land is the same size it was seven days ago. The house count did not move, the commercial count did not move, and the income-property count did not move. Counts are not the same as the listings inside them — houses changed hands on the list, as below.

So the week’s growth is entirely land: 7 land listings last week and 19 today, a rise of 12. 12 of those 19 land listings are the lots described below, and the other 7 are the ones that were already there.

12 lots, one price, one day

The 12 arrivals that matter are 8 lots on Pendleton Ct and 4 on Elliott Ct. What makes them one event rather than 12 is how completely they match:

What we can readWhat it says across all 12
Asking price$34,000 — identical on every one
Property typeLand on every one
Tag on the recordNew on every one
Tag dateNovember 3 — the same date on every one
Photographs19 on every one
Lot sizeBetween 0.5 and 0.69 acres each; 6.69 acres in all
New construction flagNot set on any of them
StreetsPendleton Ct (8) and Elliott Ct (4)

Read straight off the listing records, nothing inferred. No seller, builder, developer or brokerage is named here, because the listing data we read does not say who they are.

One observation and no explanation for it. The lot numbers on this list run from 101 to 116, and four numbers in between are not on it — 105, 106, 107 and 108. We do not know why and we are not going to invent a reason. They may never have been listed, they may be spoken for, they may be something else entirely.

$62,550 down, or $2,450 up

A median is the middle number in a sorted list. Add 12 listings at $34,000 to a list of 36 and the middle of that list moves a long way down, whatever anybody is asking for anything. That is arithmetic, not a market.

All 48 listingsThe 36 without the lotsOctober 30
Median asking$184,450$249,450$247,000
Move against October 30down $62,550up $2,450—
Mean asking$201,775$257,700$252,256
Cheapest$34,000$39,900$39,900
Dearest$539,900$539,900$550,000
Listings counted483636

The middle column is the same morning’s data with 12 records removed and nothing else changed. No price per square foot and no property-tax figure appears in this table; neither is needed to show what a median does.

The land set makes the point exactly. Land’s median asking price fell from $65,000 to $34,000. Take the 12 lots out and the land median is $65,000 and the land mean is $160,186 — both of them the figure they were last week, to the dollar. Not close to it. The same number. Every piece of land that was on the market seven days ago is still on it at the same asking price.

The houses: the count stood still, the list did not

If you are shopping for a house rather than a building lot, none of the above is about you, so here is the part that is. Carterville had 24 houses for sale last week and has 24 today — and they are not the same 24 houses. Two houses arrived and two left, which balances by coincidence rather than by any law.

DirectionListingAsking
On1205 Dylan Ln$429,000
On2355 Dr Springs Rd$150,000
Off1508 Hawkeye Ct$239,999
Off308 California St$112,900

Asking prices, not sale prices. Nothing here is described as sold, pending or contingent, and the two that came off are discussed below.

Those four changes moved the house median up: $271,500 to $284,500, a rise of $13,000, with the mean up $8,167 as well, from $286,921 to $295,088. And here is how little of that is about houses getting dearer. The cheapest house on last week’s list, at $112,900, is one of the two that came off. Put it back and leave everything else exactly as it is, and the median would be $274,000 — so $10,500 of a $13,000 rise is one house leaving the list.

We are printing that because a $13,000 rise in a median across 24 houses is the kind of figure that gets repeated as “house prices up in Carterville”, and it is mostly one cheap listing going away. Not one house on the list raised its price this week.

Two price cuts, and a tag that still cannot tell you when

Of the 34 listings on the market in both pulls, two prices moved, and both were cuts — $30,100 between them:

ListingOctober 30November 6CutTag now
1504 Sycamore Rd$469,500$449,500$20,000Price Change
701 Natalie Ct$550,000$539,900$10,100Price Change

Same record in both pulls, matched on the listing’s own identifier, so these are cuts on one property and not two different properties being compared.

Now the part this series keeps measuring, because it keeps coming out the same way. 701 Natalie Ct carried an Active tag last week and carries a Price Change tag today, on the back of a cut we measured ourselves between the two pulls. The date stamped on its tag did not move: it reads September 25 in both pulls, which is weeks before the cut we just watched happen.

That is not one record misbehaving. Across all 34 listings present in both pulls, that tag date moved on none of them — including the one whose tag demonstrably changed. Last week’s edition of this post found the same thing. So a tag date on one of these listings cannot tell you when the price changed, and we are not going to tell you what the field is for, because we do not know. We know only what it does not do.

One more thing the counts hide. The number of listings wearing a price-change tag is 20 this week and was 20 last week, which looks like a quiet week. It was not: 308 California St left the list wearing one and 701 Natalie Ct newly earned one. Two events, one unchanged number. A count standing still is not the same as nothing happening, which is most of the reason this series compares records rather than totals.

What came off the list, and what we will not say about it

Two listings left the active list this week: 1508 Hawkeye Ct, which was asking $239,999, and 308 California St, which was asking $112,900.

We do not know what happened to either of them. We looked for both under every status this feed will show us — Pending, Active Under Contract, Closed, Canceled, Expired and Withdrawn — searching first on the listing’s own identifier and then on its address line. Neither turned up anywhere.

The sweep was not empty, which is the only reason that absence is worth reporting: those same queries returned 70 other rows across Closed and Pending. The questions worked; these two records simply are not in the answers. A listing coming off a search is not a sale — it can be withdrawn, expired, relisted under a new identifier, or gone somewhere this feed does not follow. Nothing on this page says either of them sold, because nothing we read says so.

We checked the question before we trusted the answer

Every figure above is a difference between two pulls, which means anything only if both pulls asked the same thing. Both responses echo a byte-identical query, and the query was not retyped from memory: it was read straight out of last week’s stored response and sent back as it came.

That is a new habit and it was earned. Earlier this week a retyped query of this kind came back with an empty result, a success code and no error at all — nothing to tell us the question had been rejected rather than answered. A zero is not an answer until the question is proved to be the question, and nor is any other number.

Then the headline count was taken a second, genuinely different way. A Williamson County query returned 260 listings, 48 of which carry a Carterville address line — and that is the identical set of 48 records the town query returns. Not the same count by luck; the same records, one for one.

Two honest limits on all of it. There is no days-on-market figure anywhere in this post, because the listing records we pulled do not carry one and getting it would mean opening 48 individual listing files that hold contact details we will not read. And this post says nothing about whose listings these are, in either direction, because the records we read do not name an office. We would rather tell you what we did not look at than let you assume we looked.

💬 Greg Holthaus on 12 lots and a moving median

“This is the thing I would want somebody to explain to me before I believed a number about my own town. 12 lots come on at $34,000 and suddenly the median asking price in Carterville is down $62,550. Nobody dropped a price by $62,550. Two prices did come down this week and you can see both of them above, and neither cut is anywhere near that. The list got longer at the bottom, and the middle of a longer list sits somewhere else. If you are selling a house here, the number that matters to you is the 24 houses, and that count has not moved in seven days. If you are buying a lot, 12 of them just showed up at one price, and that is worth a look.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker

Questions we get about Carterville

How many houses are for sale in Carterville right now?

There are 48 active listings of every kind in Carterville this morning, and 24 of them are houses. The rest are 19 land listings, 4 commercial listings and 1 income property. The house count is exactly what it was seven days ago — 24 then and 24 now — and the whole of this week’s growth is land.

Did prices in Carterville drop this week?

Two asking prices were cut, by $20,000 and $10,100. The median fell a great deal further than that, and for a different reason entirely. The median asking price across all 48 listings fell $62,550, from $247,000 to $184,450. But 12 identical $34,000 lots arrived on one day, and with those 12 set aside the median of the remaining 36 listings is $249,450 — $2,450 higher than last week. Nobody cut a price by $62,550. The middle of the list moved because the list changed shape.

What are the 12 lots?

12 land listings, 8 lots on Pendleton Ct and 4 on Elliott Ct, all asking $34,000 and all between 0.5 and 0.69 acres — 6.69 acres between them. Every one carries the same tag date and the same photograph count. We are not naming a seller, a builder or a brokerage, because the listing data we read does not say and we are not going to guess.

What happened to the two listings that came off the list?

We do not know, and we are not going to imply it. 1508 Hawkeye Ct and 308 California St were on the active list seven days ago and are not on it today. We looked for both under every status this feed exposes — Pending, Active Under Contract, Closed, Canceled, Expired and Withdrawn — and found neither. Those queries were working: they returned 70 other rows between them. A listing leaving a search is not a sale, and nothing on this page says either of these sold.

How do you know the two weeks are comparable?

Because the question was tested before the answer was trusted. Both pulls echo a byte-identical query, and the chip was loaded out of last week’s own archived response rather than retyped — a retyped one came back with an empty result and no error on another edition this week. Then the count was taken a second, different way: a Williamson County query returning 260 rows, filtered down to Carterville by each row’s own town line, gives the identical 48 listings — not the same number, the same records.

Looking at Carterville seriously? A broker who works this town can tell you which of the 48 are worth your time and which are not, whoever holds the listing. Find your broker › or text 618.925.8654.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About these figures: Built from two pulls of local MLS listing data, seven days apart — October 30 and November 6, 36 active listings then and 48 now — using the same Carterville town query, with status set to active on both. Each response’s row count equals its own reported total, every row carries a Carterville address line, and both responses echo a byte-identical query; the query was loaded out of the stored October 30 response rather than retyped, because a retyped one returned an empty result with no error earlier this week. The headline count was then taken a second way: a Williamson County query of 260 listings filtered on each row’s own town line yields the identical 48 records, not merely the same number. Arrivals and departures are matched on street line plus town, and same-record comparisons on the listing’s own identifier; the two reconcile exactly, with no address edits and no relistings this week. The 12 lots are reported from their own records only — price, type, tag, tag date, photograph count, lot size and street — and no seller, builder, developer, brokerage or listing agent is named anywhere on this page, because the records we read do not name one. This post makes no claim about whose listings any of the 48 are, in either direction. None of this is published here, although it sits in the records we read: private remarks, showing instructions, and agents’ names, email addresses and telephone numbers. None of this is published either: office names and telephone numbers, lock-box details, listing expiry dates and internal MLS identifiers. No individual listing file was opened at all, so there is no days-on-market figure in this post and none is implied. Prices are asking prices, not sale prices, and nothing on this page is described as sold, pending or contingent; the two listings that left the active list were searched for under Pending, Active Under Contract, Closed, Canceled, Expired and Withdrawn, by identifier and by address, and found under none of them, while those same queries returned 70 other rows, so the absence is reported as an absence and not as an outcome. No property-tax figure, no price per square foot, no interest rate and no payment figure appears anywhere in this post, and nothing here is a loan offer, a rate quote or a statement about what anyone can borrow. No distance or drive time appears, because none was measured. This is one morning’s picture of an active list that changes daily.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us