Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Carterville

19 Carterville Listings Say The Price Changed. 3 Prices Changed.

Our Carterville reading this morning says something about the labels rather than about the town. 19 listings carry a price-change marker and 3 prices moved in seven days. Both numbers are correct, and they are answers to different questions.

50
active listings in Carterville
19
carry a price-change marker
3
asking prices that moved in seven days
16
marked, but unchanged on both readings

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 20, 2026 · Carterville

Carterville has 50 active listings this morning, up from 48 a week ago: 5 arrived and 3 left. Of the 45 on both readings, 3 changed their asking price, every one of them downward — by $26,000, $15,000 and $10,100.

The data marked every one of them. What it also does is mark 19 listings in total.

19 markers, 3 moves

19 of the 50 active listings carry a price-change marker this morning, each with a previous price attached. 3 of them moved between our two readings. The other 16 carry the identical asking price and the identical previous price on both readings — same figures, same marker, seven days apart. Nothing about them changed.

That is not the data being wrong. It is the marker being a different kind of thing from what a weekly count wants. It records that a listing has changed price, and it never comes off. We can put a number on that last part: across five consecutive pairs of our own Carterville readings, 190 listing-to-listing comparisons, the marker was added 4 times and taken off none. So counting marked listings tells you how many of the 50 have ever moved; it does not tell you how many moved this week, and here the two answers differ by a factor of 6.3×.

Last week’s post in this series found the same field failing from the opposite direction: 15 prices moved and the marker held 3 of them. Undercounting one week and overcounting the next sound like a pair of faults. They are one. A marker that attaches to a record and stays there will miss things that happen and keep things that happened, and the only way to measure a week is to read the data twice and compare it with itself.

ListingPrevious price on the recordAsking nowDifferenceEarliest reading of ours showing these same figures
127 Weisbrook Ln$170,000$160,000-$10,000unchanged since November 13
5934 Chandler Dr$334,900$329,900-$5,000unchanged since November 13
616 E Grand Ave$149,000$139,000-$10,000unchanged since November 13
1504 Sycamore Rd$469,500$449,500-$20,000unchanged since November 6
701 Natalie Ct$550,000$539,900-$10,100unchanged since November 6
0000 Baptist Camp Rd$70,000$65,000-$5,000unchanged since October 16
137 S Division St$189,000$179,900-$9,100unchanged since October 16
1401 S Thomas St$245,000$242,000-$3,000unchanged since October 16
203 Cora Mae Ct$475,000$450,000-$25,000unchanged since October 16
307 Noah Ln$263,000$249,000-$14,000unchanged since October 16
307 Woodlake Ct$374,000$360,000-$14,000unchanged since October 16
404 Howerton St$211,000$199,000-$12,000unchanged since October 16
69 David Livingstone Dr$50,000$45,000-$5,000unchanged since October 16
903 E Grand Ave$44,900$41,500-$3,400unchanged since October 16
505 Victor Ln$339,900$330,000-$9,900unchanged since October 23
412 Elles Ave$174,000$159,000-$15,000unchanged since October 30
1108 Main St$330,000$315,000-$15,000moved this week
5721 & 5715 Michael Ln$475,000$449,000-$26,000moved this week
805 Cottonwood Ln$245,000$234,900-$10,100moved this week

Every Carterville listing carrying a price-change marker this morning. The last column is the oldest reading of our own in which the marker, the previous price and the asking price are all identical to today’s — so it is a floor on how long the marker has been saying the same thing, not a date of change.

There is one check in that table worth pointing at. The listings with no earlier reading of ours showing today’s figures are exactly the 3 that moved this week — not approximately, not mostly. Every other marked listing has an identical earlier reading somewhere in our archive. 9 of them go back to October 16, the oldest Carterville reading we hold, 35 days ago.

What we will not tell you is how old those markers really are

Every record carries a last-updated timestamp, and it would answer the question in one line. We are not using it, and the reason is the rest of this post.

Take the 3 listings whose prices moved this week. Not one of their timestamps moved with the price. 805 Cottonwood Ln is the clearest case: a week ago it carried no previous price and no price-change marker, and this morning it carries both. The label on that record changed. Its last-updated timestamp still reads October 12, 39 days before this morning and well outside the week we compared.

So the field is not a record of when the label was set, and using it to date 16 markers would have produced 16 confident dates with nothing behind them. The 35-day figure above is slower and it is ours: it comes from comparing our own stored readings.

The timestamp does do something, and we worked out exactly what

It is not noise. Across four of our Carterville readings — October 30, November 6, November 13 and November 20, 182 listing records in all — there is an exact rule with no exceptions in either direction:

A record’s timestamp carries a real time of day if, and only if, the listing is labelled new. Every other record’s timestamp is flattened to midnight.

And we watched it happen. Only 2 listings on both readings changed their timestamp at all this week: 0000 Greenbriar Rd and 502 W Grand Ave. Both went from labelled new to plain active, and both timestamps went from a real time of day to midnight of the same calendar day. Neither price changed. The time of day is discarded when the label goes; the day survives.

Which leaves last week’s question still open

Our post of November 13 described 12 vacant lots on two adjoining streets whose last-updated field had held 12 distinct stamps a few seconds apart on one morning, and a single identical stamp the next time we looked — and that single stamp was dated earlier than the ones it replaced. A timestamp cannot get younger, and we said so.

The rule above explains half of that. Those lots were labelled new when they carried their 12 timed stamps and they are not labelled new now, so the flattening to midnight is exactly what the rule predicts. It does not explain the date. Both of the flattenings we watched this week kept their calendar day; the lots’ went back one day. So we can now account for the shape of what happened to those records and not for when, and we would rather leave that written down as unfinished than tidy it away. The lots themselves have not moved: still 8 at $38,000 and 4 at $36,000, the same as last week.

The label that says a listing is new has the same problem

5 listings carry it this morning. 5 listings arrived since our last reading. They are not the same listings, and the matching counts are a coincidence we nearly published as a finding.

ListingAskingKindWhat the label says, and what we read
610 E Grand Ave$135,000residentiallabelled new, and arrived this week
400 Abby Dr$225,000residentiallabelled new, and arrived this week
205 Tippy Rd$425,000residentiallabelled new, and arrived this week
10393 Fleming Rd$150,000landlabelled new, but on our reading of November 13 too
615 Kramer St$40,000landlabelled new, but on our reading of November 13 too
1300 Shawnee Trl$560,000residentialarrived this week, and not labelled new
308 California St$112,900residentialarrived this week, and not labelled new

The 5 listings labelled new and the 5 that are new to our reading, side by side. 3 listings are in both groups.

10393 Fleming Rd is the one to look at. It has carried that label in six consecutive readings of ours, October 16 through November 20 — 35 days — at an unchanged $150,000. It may well have been carrying it for longer; 35 days is simply how far back our own Carterville readings go. Going the other way, 2 of the listings that arrived this week — 1300 Shawnee Trl and 308 California St — are labelled plain active.

3 listings left, and we do not know what became of them

3 listings dropped out of the active search this week: 211 Dewmaine Rd, 15247 Laminack Rd and 202 S Division St. Rather than guess, each was looked for under every status this data exposes — Pending, Active Under Contract, Closed, Canceled, Expired and Withdrawn — by record identifier first and by address second. None of the 3 departed listings was found under any of them.

That is a measurement and not an empty search: those statuses hold 70 Carterville records between them, and the identical search a week ago did turn up one of that week’s departures with a status attached. This week it turned up nothing, so what became of these 3 listings is unknown and we will not dress it up. A listing leaving a search is not a sale.

The rest of the week

5 listings arrived — at $112,900, $135,000, $225,000, $425,000 and $560,000 — and the town’s 50 active listings now run from $36,000, a vacant lot, to $560,000, with a median of $154,500. By kind: 26 residential, 20 land, 3 commercial sale, 1 residential income.

What this does not tell you

It does not tell you that the data is unreliable. Every figure in it checked out: each of the 3 marked movers carries a previous price exactly equal to what we recorded seven days earlier, and the 19 markers are all genuine reductions. It tells you that two of these fields answer a question about a record and get read as answers about a week.

It does not say why any price moved. It does not say what any of these properties is worth, and an asking price never did. It does not say whose listings these are: the records carry no office field. It does not date any marker beyond the readings of ours it names. And it describes two mornings seven days apart — a price can change again this afternoon, and on this evidence the record may not say when.

Common questions

Did Carterville asking prices move this week?

Of the 45 listings that appear on both our readings, 3 moved, and all 3 came down — by $26,000, $15,000 and $10,100, $51,100 between them. The town has 50 active listings this morning against 48 a week ago, with a median asking price of $154,500.

Then why do 19 listings carry a price-change marker?

Because the marker is not about this week. It sits on a listing that changed its price at some point and it does not come off again — across five consecutive pairs of our own readings we have seen it added 4 times and removed none. 16 of the 19 carry exactly the same asking price and exactly the same previous price on both of our readings, seven days apart — nothing about them changed. So a count of marked listings answers how many of these have ever moved and not how many moved this week. The two answers differ by a factor of 6.3× here.

How long have those markers been sitting there?

We can only answer that from our own readings, and we deliberately do not answer it from the data’s own last-updated field, for a reason this post explains. 9 of the 19 carry an identical marker, an identical previous price and an identical asking price in every one of our six readings going back to October 16 — 35 days in which the marker recorded nothing new. 16 of them are identical in some earlier reading of ours. How much older than that they are, we cannot say, and we would rather say that than guess.

Does the same problem affect the label that says a listing is new?

Yes, in the same shape. 5 listings carry that label this morning and 5 listings appeared since our last reading — and they are not the same listings. 3 listings are in both groups. 2 listings labelled new were already here a week ago, and one of them, 10393 Fleming Rd, has carried that label in six consecutive readings of ours across 35 days at an unchanged $150,000. Meanwhile 2 of the listings that arrived this week are not labelled new at all.

What happened to the listings that disappeared from the search?

3 listings left the active list and we do not know what became of them. Each was looked for under every status this data exposes — Pending, Active Under Contract, Closed, Canceled, Expired and Withdrawn — by record first and by address second, and none of the 3 departed listings turned up under any of them. That is a real result rather than an empty search: those statuses returned 70 Carterville records in all, and the same search a week ago did find one of that week’s departures. A listing leaving a search is not a sale, and nothing on this page is described as sold.

So should I trust a price-cut list at all?

Trust it to be what it is. A list built from this marker is a list of listings carrying the marker, which is a real and useful thing — it is simply not a list of what moved last week, and in Carterville this morning the difference between those is 19 against 3. The only way we know of to get the second list is to keep your own readings and compare each listing with its own earlier figure, which is what this post does.

💬 Greg Holthaus on the difference between a label and a measurement

“Both of this morning’s numbers are right, and that is the part worth sitting with. 19 listings carry a price-change marker and 3 prices moved, and if you put either one in a headline without the other you have said something true and misleading. A label on a record is somebody’s note about that record. It is not a measurement of a week, and it was never built to be. Reading the data twice and comparing it against itself is slower, and it is the only version where I know what the number means. If we ever hand you a list of price cuts, ask us which of those two we counted.”

Want the current asking price on something specific in Carterville? Call or text 618.925.8654 and we will read it off this morning’s data rather than last week’s.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

Where these numbers come from

Two readings of local MLS listing data for Carterville, seven days apart — November 13 and November 20, 48 and 50 active listings. The search was not retyped between the two: it is loaded from the earlier reading’s own record of what it asked and sent back unchanged, and the new reading is checked to have echoed it exactly. That check exists because a retyped search once came back with zero results and no error at all. A second, cosmetically different form of the same search was run again this morning and returned the identical 50 records.

Listings were matched one to one on a stable record identifier, never on the address text, and each listing’s asking price was compared with its own figure from a week ago. That is the whole method behind this post: it does not ask the data what changed, it compares the data with itself. The marker counts above are what you get from asking the data what changed, and the 3 moved listings are what you get from comparing it with itself.

Marker age is measured against six readings of our own, taken on October 16, October 23, October 30, November 6, November 13 and November 20 for this series. It is deliberately not measured from the data’s own last-updated field, because that field is the one this post shows does not move when a label changes.

About these figures: everything above is local MLS listing data read on the mornings of November 13 and November 20, 2026. A change in an asking price is not a sale and not a valuation, and nothing on this page is described as sold — the 3 listings that left the search were searched for under every status this data carries and found under none, so their fate is unknown and is written here as unknown. This page makes no claim about why any price moved, and none about when any marker was set beyond the readings of ours it names. It makes no claim about who owns or lists any of these properties — the records we read carry no office field, so that cannot be read from them in either direction. No days-on-market figure appears because this data does not carry one and obtaining one would mean opening a detail record per listing, each full of agent contact fields we do not read. No individual listing is named except the 19 carrying a price-change marker, the 5 that arrived, the 2 still labelled new from a week ago, the 2 whose timestamp we watched change and the 3 that left the search — 31 listings in all, every one of them because this post is about what its record says, and no agent, no brokerage and no photograph from the data appears anywhere. Nothing on this page is a loan offer, a rate quote or any statement about financing: no interest rate, no monthly payment and no lender appears in it. It names no broker other than Greg, and no other brokerage. Figures describe the records as they stood on the mornings they were read; a listing can change its price or leave the market the same afternoon.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Buying? Start HereFind Your BrokerContact Us