We ran the same search of this lake twice, fourteen days apart — once on September 29 and again this morning. Both times it came back with 33 houses. The median asking price went from $399,000 to $449,000, which is $50,000 higher.
Nothing on that list raised its price. Only two of the thirty listings that appear in both pulls changed at all, and both of those went down. So where did $50,000 come from?
The list moved $50,000. The lakefront moved $2,000.
Two weeks ago eighteen of those houses were actually on the water. Today eighteen of them are. The median asking price of that group went from $492,450 to $494,450 — a difference of $2,000. The whole list moved about 25 times as far as the water did.
That is the entire explanation, and it is worth understanding because it is the single easiest way to be misled about a market this small. The $50,000 is a change in what is on the list, not a change in what anything is worth. Cheap houses left the bottom. Expensive listings arrived at the top. Every individual seller either held their price or cut it.
And the eighteen on the water is a coincidence, not stability: one on-water listing left and one arrived. We are not going to call that a trend either.
What left, and where it actually went
Three houses dropped off the list. All three came out of the cheaper half, and when we looked each one up, two of the three had gone under contract.
| Left the list | Was asking | Days listed on September 29 | Where it actually went |
|---|---|---|---|
| 225 Arrowhead Dr | $75,000 | 248 | Off market |
| 40 Nile Ln | $85,000 | 1 | Pending as of October 12 |
| 530 Marina Cir | $225,000 | not given | Contingent, continue to show |
We looked each one up separately. Dropping off a for-sale list does not say why, and pending and contingent are not the same thing as sold.
The one we would point at is 530 Marina Cir at $225,000, the only one of the three that was on the water. It is now contingent. A buyer who waited two weeks to call about it is calling about a house with an accepted offer on it.
We are deliberately not telling you those houses sold. Pending means an accepted offer heading for a closing; contingent means an accepted offer with conditions still outstanding. Deals in both states fall apart. The honest statement is that two of the three are no longer available to you today, and the third is simply off the market.
What arrived — and only one of the three is a house on this lake
| Arrived since September 29 | Asking | Days listed | What it is |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11153 Southern Hunt Rd Marion · built 1988 | $1,100,000 | 4 | A different lake |
| 13017 Egypt Shores Rd Creal Springs · built 1993 | $489,000 | 5 | On the water |
| 526 Power Plant Rd Marion · built 2020 | $169,000 | 13 | Not really a house |
13017 Egypt Shores Rd at $489,000 is the genuine one: a waterfront house with a private dock, boat and jet-ski slips, on the market five days. If you are shopping this lake, that is the arrival that matters.
The other two are the reason we read every description by hand instead of trusting the search.
11153 Southern Hunt Rd is asking $1,100,000 and it is not on Lake of Egypt. It is the second most expensive listing our search returned this morning. It sits on forty acres south of Marion with its own private six-acre lake, and the only time it mentions our lake is a location bullet saying the property lies between Lake of Egypt and Crab Orchard. None of that is a criticism of the listing. It is simply a different lake.
The third arrival is a three-acre wooded parcel carrying an unfinished short-term-rental project — a pole barn with a finished studio, one finished cabin and two more unfinished — recorded as a one-bedroom house of a few hundred square feet. Its description says it is near the lake, which is accurate. It is a business plan with buildings on it, and whatever it is, it is not a lake house.
So what is really on this list?
| What it actually is | Houses | Median asking | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| On the water | 18 | $494,450 | $315,000 – $1,299,999 |
| Not at the lake | 9 | $150,000 | $74,900 – $699,900 |
| Lake community, off the water | 3 | $49,000 | $45,000 – $385,000 |
| Not really a house | 2 | $134,500 | $100,000 – $169,000 |
| On a different lake | 1 | $1,100,000 | only one listing |
Every listing in this table was placed by reading its own description, not by matching a keyword. The shaded row is the only one that is actually on Lake of Egypt.
Fifteen of the 33 houses the search returned are not on Lake of Egypt. That is not the search misbehaving — it is doing exactly what it was asked, which is to find the words rather than the water. It is why a list of 33 and a median of $449,000 tells you almost nothing on its own, and why the only number on this page we would hang a decision on is the $494,450.
How long these houses have been sitting
Running the same query twice gave us something a single snapshot cannot: a controlled check on the clock. Of the thirty listings present both times, twenty-nine advanced their days-on-market counter by exactly fourteen days and the thirtieth advanced by thirteen. The counter is simply running, on every listing, every day.
Including on the two that cut their price. 410 Mark Dr came down from $709,000 to $698,000, a cut of $11,000, and 45 Donetta Ln came down from $109,000 to $99,900, a cut of $9,100. Both counters advanced the full fourteen days along with everybody else.
That matters more than it sounds. A seller cutting the price does not get a fresh start on paper: the house still shows every day it has been listed. The median on this list is now 58 days, up from 44. Nine of the thirty carried-over houses are past three months, and four are past six.
What we would tell you if you called
If you are buying at this lake, the list you can pull up yourself overstates the market and understates your urgency at the same time. It overstates it because fifteen of the 33 houses on it are somewhere else. It understates the urgency because the only genuine on-water arrival in fourteen days went on the market five days ago, and the one on-water house that left is already under contract.
If you are selling here, the clock is the thing to understand. It does not reset, a price cut does not hide it, and four houses on this list have been visible to every buyer for more than six months.
💬 Greg Holthaus on the Two Numbers
“A list going up $50,000 in two weeks is the kind of thing that gets repeated at the boat ramp until everybody believes the lake went up. It did not. Three cheap places left and a $1,100,000 estate on somebody else’s lake showed up, and that is the whole move. The number I actually watch out here is the waterfront median, and it moved $2,000. The part I would want a seller to hear is the clock. I have watched people cut twice and wonder why nothing changed, and it is because the house still reads as having been for sale since spring. The first number is the one that does the work.”
💰 A Lake House Is Not a Standard Loan Conversation
Second homes, cabins, manufactured homes and short-term-rental income all change what a lender will do, and the answer for a $494,450 waterfront house is nothing like the answer for a cabin on a few acres. Worth sorting out before you fall for one. Free pre-qualification with Jarod Sanders, CrossCountry Mortgage.Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228
🌊 Want the List With the Wrong Houses Taken Out?
Give us a price range, or an address you are curious about, and a broker who sells at this lake will tell you straight which listings are on the water, which are in a lake subdivision, and which are simply using the words. We will also tell you how long each one has really been sitting. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.
📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.
Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About the numbers: Every figure comes from two pulls of the same query against local MLS listing data, taken 14 days apart — September 29 and October 13, 2026. The query is a listing-remarks search for this lake across the three ZIP codes that touch it, covering Marion, Goreville and Creal Springs, deduplicated on address and asking price. Both pulls returned 33 records typed as houses. These are search results, not a census of the lake — the search finds the words in a description, which is exactly why 15 of the 33 are not on this lake. Every listing was placed into its category by reading its own description; the 30 carried over keep the classification published here on September 29, and the 3 arrivals were read fresh from their full descriptions, because the search returns only the first few hundred characters and the decisive sentence is often past the cut. The 3 departures were each looked up individually and their status is given as the source states it today. Dropping off a for-sale search does not say why, and pending and contingent are not sold — nothing here says any house sold. Days on market is the counter the source carries for the current listing; this post measured it rather than assuming it, and 29 of the 30 carried-over listings advanced by exactly 14 days. Asking prices are not sale prices, and a standing list over-represents houses that have been on the market a while, because anything that listed and sold quickly is already gone from it. Price per square foot is deliberately absent: this series established on 22 September that it spans roughly seven to one inside this one small market, because buyers here are paying for water access and not floor area. Several categories in the table hold only a handful of listings, where one sale moves a median a long way. Nothing here is an appraisal. Mortgage pre-qualification is offered by Jarod Sanders, CrossCountry Mortgage, NMLS #2337228. This is not a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.
