A search for Lake of Egypt this morning returns 38 listings. 25 are houses, 12 are pieces of ground, and one is neither. The houses ask a median of $399,900 and run from $45,000 to $1,100,000.
That is the snapshot. Here is the thing underneath it that nobody tells you, and we had not published either: 14 of those 38 listings are not in the county you probably think they are in.
| What the search returns | Listings | Median asking | Low to high |
|---|---|---|---|
| Houses | 25 | $399,900 | $45,000 to $1,100,000 |
| Land | 12 | $82,450 | $17,000 to $1,500,000 |
One further listing is neither, which is why the two rows do not add to 38. Asking prices, not sale prices. No price per square foot appears anywhere in this post — at this lake it is meaningless, because the thing being paid for is water access and not floor area.
The lake sits on a county line
We read the county off every one of the 38 listings individually, from each listing's own record. The result: 24 in Williamson County and 14 in Johnson County.
This matters more than it sounds. A buyer who searches the lake by name gets one list, looks at houses on both shores, and may never notice that the county changes partway down it — and the county is who assesses the property and sends the tax bill. We are not publishing a tax figure for either side, because we did not measure one. We are telling you to ask which county a house is in before you get attached to it.
There is a second check behind that split, and it is worth stating because it is the kind of thing a reader can repeat. Our own four-county feed — Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union, the four this blog reports every week — returns 132 listings in Marion and 7 in Creal Springs, and zero in Goreville and zero in New Burnside. Those two towns are simply outside the counties we normally cover, which is the same fact arriving from the other direction.
And a mailing address is not a county
We nearly got this wrong in a way worth confessing. The quick version of this analysis is to take the town in each address and look up its county — Goreville is Johnson, Marion is Williamson, and so on. Done that way the answer comes out 26 and 12.
The right way is to read each listing's own county, and done that way it is 24 and 14. Two listings with a Creal Springs mailing address sit in Johnson County: 2955 Egyptian Hills Dr and 45 Donetta Ln. A post office does not follow a county boundary, and around a lake that straddles one, the shortcut is wrong often enough to matter.
| Houses, by county | Listings | Median asking | Median days listed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Williamson | 16 | $469,000 | 46 |
| Johnson | 9 | $399,000 | 46 |
County read off each listing’s own record, one listing at a time — not guessed from the town in the address, which would have got two of them wrong.
The Williamson houses ask more at the median — $469,000 against $399,000 — on 16 listings against 9. What is identical across the line is how long they take: the median on each side is the same number of days. Different counties, different tax bills, the same patience required.
The top, the middle and the way in
| Where it sits on the list | Address | Town | County | Asking | Days listed | Built | Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The top of the whole search | 1921 Grange Hall Rd | Marion | Williamson | $1,500,000 | 252 | — | land |
| The dearest house | 11153 Southern Hunt Rd | Marion | Williamson | $1,100,000 | 11 | 1988 | 3,618 sq ft |
| The middle house | 565 N Lakeshore Dr | Goreville | Johnson | $399,900 | 54 | 1999 | 1,351 sq ft |
| The way in | 2955 Egyptian Hills Dr | Creal Springs | Johnson | $45,000 | 24 | 1865 | 288 sq ft |
| The next step up | 54 North St | New Burnside | Johnson | $74,900 | 28 | 1936 | 1,120 sq ft |
Every figure is from this morning’s pull of local MLS data. Nothing here says any of these is on the water: see the section below.
The most expensive listing in the entire search is not a house. 1921 Grange Hall Rd is land, asking $1,500,000, and it has been listed 252 days. The second-dearest piece of ground, 0000 Lake Of Egypt Rd at $899,900, has been listed 130 days. At the top of this market, what is actually for sale is the ground.
The dearest house, 11153 Southern Hunt Rd in Marion, asks $1,100,000 for 3,618 square feet built in 1988, and it has been listed 11 days. The middle of the house list, 565 N Lakeshore Dr, asks $399,900 — 1,351 square feet, built 1999, and sitting in Johnson County, not Williamson. The median lake house is on the far side of the line.
And the way in is where the honest footnote belongs. 2955 Egyptian Hills Dr asks $45,000, which sounds like the cheapest lake property in Southern Illinois until you read the record: 288 square feet, built in 1865. Whatever that is, it is not a house in the ordinary sense, and nobody should go looking at it expecting one. The first thing on the list that is a house in the ordinary sense is 54 North St at $74,900 — 1,120 square feet, built 1936, in New Burnside.
How long things have been sitting
The median house in this search has been listed 46 days. Three are past 90 days and one is past six months — 14228 Lake Of Egypt Rd, at 266 days, asking $150,000. At the other end, 9 of the 25 houses arrived in the last 30 days, which is a real rate of turnover for a market this size.
What this post is not telling you
Two things, both deliberate.
Nothing here says which of these is on the water. Our own analysis three weeks ago found that a search for this lake returns a great many houses that are not on it, and that sorting them requires reading every listing's own description one at a time — because an automated reader gets it wrong. One listing turned up in a waterfront search on the strength of its own sentence about being close to the water without the waterfront taxes: the word was there and the meaning was the opposite. We did not read the descriptions this week, so we are not splitting them this week. Assume nothing on this page is waterfront until somebody has looked.
And we are not comparing this week's count with last week's. Our October 13 edition reported 33 houses off this same search and today it returns 25. We are not calling that a market move, because we cannot show it is one: the earlier list of addresses is gone, and a keyword search can gain or lose members when a description gets edited or a house is re-listed with different wording, entirely without anything selling. Today's list is saved, so next week this comparison can be done properly instead of guessed at.
💬 Greg Holthaus on the County Line
“The county line at the lake catches people out, and it is not their fault — the water does not have a sign in it. What I would do before falling in love with a place out there is ask two questions: which county is this actually in, and what does the tax bill look like on this exact parcel, not on the one next door. Get the parcel number and have somebody pull it. It takes a morning and it tells you more about what you are signing up for than anything in the listing.”
🏠 Thinking About the Lake?
Send us an address and a broker will tell you what is actually going on with it — which county and which district it sits in, how long it has really been listed, what the sellers have already done on price, and whether it touches the water. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.
📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.
Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About the numbers: Every figure comes from one pull of the lake’s standing search of local MLS data on the morning of October 20, 2026 — the same remark-based search this series has used since August — which returned 38 listings, all of them active, with no duplicate addresses. The county on every listing was read from that listing’s own record, one at a time, rather than inferred from the town in its address; doing it by town would have returned 26 Williamson and 12 Johnson instead of the correct 24 and 14, because two listings with a Creal Springs mailing address are in Johnson County. The county identifiers on those records match the ones this series verified independently on October 15. As a second check, our own four-county feed from October 19 returns 132 listings in Marion and 7 in Creal Springs and none at all in Goreville or New Burnside, confirming those towns lie outside Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union. No claim is made anywhere in this post about which listings are on the water: that split requires reading every listing description individually, which was done on September 29 and was not done this week. No price per square foot is published, because at this lake the measure is meaningless. No property-tax figure, assessment or rate appears for either county, and nothing is asserted about school districts. The difference between the 33 houses our October 13 edition reported and the 25 today is not presented as a market movement; the earlier address list is no longer available to difference against, and a keyword search can change membership when a description is edited or a listing is replaced. Asking prices are not sale prices, days listed belong to the listing record rather than to the house, and a standing list over-represents whatever has been sitting a while. Nothing here is an appraisal. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.
