Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Lake of Egypt

The Lake’s Median Rose $30,000 and Not One House Got More Expensive

This is the first week this lake series has been able to difference itself. Last week’s list was archived, so today the same search can be compared with the same search seven days later — listing by listing, matched on address.

37
active on this search
1
cut its price
0
raised its price
+30,000
median, in dollars

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 27, 2026 · Lake of Egypt

seven days ago this series pulled every listing whose remarks mention the Lake of Egypt and archived the list. That is the first time it had done that, and it is the only reason today’s edition exists: the same search, run the same way, can now be set against itself listing by listing. 38 listings then, 37 now.

The headline number is the one that is easiest to read backwards. The median asking price on the lake went from $320,000 to $350,000, up $30,000 in a week. Over the same week, not one listing on this search raised its asking price, one cut it, and the sum of every asking price on the lake fell $170,000. Both of those things are true at once, and the gap between them is the whole point of this post.

Not one house got more expensive

36 listings were on this search both weeks. Of those, one came down in price and none went up; the other 35 are asking exactly what they asked seven days ago. The one that moved is 1925 MURPHY RD in Creal Springs, from $155,000 to $135,000 — down $20,000.

October 20October 27Change
Listings on the search3837-1
Median asking price$320,000$350,000+$30,000
Average asking price$369,555$374,948+$5,393
Every asking price added up$14,043,099$13,873,099−$170,000
Listings that raised a price—0—

The median and the average both rose. The total fell. Nothing on the list got more expensive.

The median went up because a cheap listing left

A median is the middle of whatever is on the list today. Change which listings are on the list and the middle moves, even if every single price stays frozen. The listing that left the search was asking $150,000 — below the middle. Take a below-middle listing away and the middle slides up.

Rather than assert that, we recomputed it both ways. Put that one departed listing back and the median returns to $320,000 — exactly the figure we published last week. So the entire $30,000 move is that one listing leaving. Then the other direction: undo the $20,000 price cut and the median does not move at all, because $135,000 and $155,000 sit on the same side of the middle. The only real price change on the lake this week had no effect whatsoever on the number most people would quote.

What we recomputedMedian it producesWhat that tells you
The list as it actually is today$350,000Up $30,000 from last week
With the departed listing put back$320,000Back to last week exactly — the departure is the whole move
With the price cut undone instead$350,000Unchanged — the only real price move is invisible in the median

Of the 37 listings on the search today, 18 ask less than the median.

This is not a trick of this particular week. It is what a median does, and it is why this series publishes the count of listings that moved alongside any median it prints. A median can rise in a week when every price that moved moved down.

The one that left, and what we will not tell you about it

14228 Lake Of Egypt Rd in Marion was on this search seven days ago asking $150,000, with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms and 1,856 square feet. It had been on this search 266 days. Today it is not there.

We do not know why, and we are not going to guess. A listing can leave for reasons that look nothing alike from the outside, and the honest list of possibilities is long: it could have gone under contract, been taken off the market, expired, or had the wording of its own description edited. We are not telling you it sold. We tried to look at the listing record directly and got a page asking us to prove we were not a robot, which we do not work around, so what we have is the before and the absence.

That last possibility deserves its own sentence, because it is a limit of how this post is built. This search finds listings by the words in their descriptions. A listing whose description stops mentioning the lake drops off it without anything happening to the house. So everything on this page is a count of what is on this search, not a count of what is on the market, and the one departure is reported as a departure from the search.

Nothing arrived — and last week’s arithmetic would have said one did

Matched on address, this week shows one arrival and two departures. Matched on the listing record underneath the address, it shows no arrivals and one departure. Those two readings cannot both be describing houses, and the one that is wrong is the first one.

Here is the entire discrepancy:

On October 20On October 27Listing recordAsking price
TBD Friendship Loop RdTBD Friendship LoopUnchanged$99,000

One listing in Goreville restyled its own street line. The record never changed, the price never changed, and its day counter kept running straight through.

A street line lost the word “Rd”. Matching on the text of an address, that is a house vanishing and a different house appearing in the same town at the same price in the same week. Matching on the record, it is one listing that has been sitting there the whole time — its day count went from 47 to 54, straight through the rename, and its asking price never moved off $99,000.

So the count that means anything is the one taken on the records: no properties arrived at the lake this week and one left — not the one arrival and two departures the addresses alone would have given you.

On October 26 this series published that the reconciliation it had been using — arrivals by record should equal arrivals by address plus re-listings — is wrong, because it never subtracted the addresses that were simply rewritten. That week the two corrections happened to cancel and the broken form still produced the right total, which is exactly why it had survived so long. This week it does not cancel. The broken form would have printed 1 arrival at the lake. The correct form, the one that subtracts edits, gives 0 = (1 − 1) + 0, and the same arithmetic on the departures: 1 = (2 − 1) + 0.

We are spelling this out because a reader has no way to check it and because the correction has a cost: it means a number in a post we published last week was wrong, and it means this post would have told you a house came onto the lake when none did.

$20,000 cheaper, and the listing does not say so

1925 MURPHY RD asked $155,000 on October 20 and asks $135,000 today. It is the same listing record in both pulls — it was not taken down and put back up — and its day counter ran from 26 to 33, advancing by exactly the seven days between our two looks. In neither pull does it carry a price-change flag.

That is worth being careful about, so here is exactly what we can and cannot say. We hold two snapshots, seven days apart. We cannot tell you a flag never appeared between them — it could have shown up and dropped off inside that week, and these flags do come and go: three other kinds of badge appear on this very search, and one listing that was flagged as new last week is not flagged today. What we can tell you is that there is nothing to see on it now. A buyer opening it today sees an asking price and a day count and no indication that the price used to be $20,000 higher.

On October 26 this series showed a house whose price-change flag vanished because the listing was taken down and re-entered as a new record, which resets both the flag and the day counter. This is the same blind spot reached from the other direction: no new record, no reset day count, the flag simply absent. The lesson is not about re-listings. It is that the flag is a fact about the paperwork and the price history is a fact about the house, and only one of those is on the screen.

The day counter is the one number that behaved

Across the 36 listings on the search both weeks, 35 advanced their day count by exactly 7 and one carries no day count at all. None advanced by any other amount. That is what should happen when a record survives untouched for a week, and it is the check that lets us say the restyled address and the price cut both kept their original records rather than being re-entered.

The missing one is not a zero and it is not averaged into anything. It is one row the calculation is smaller by, and 35 + 1 = 36.

Across the whole search today, day counts run from 8 to 259 days, with a middle of 54. On a lake where the cheapest thing on the list is $17,000 and the dearest is $1,500,000, that spread is doing more work than the median is.

The lake is still in two counties

Every one of today’s 37 listings was already on last week’s list, which means every one of them already had its county read out of its own listing record when we fetched all 38 of those records individually. 23 are in Williamson County and 14 are in Johnson County. Last week it was 24 and 14; the one listing that left was a Williamson one.

And the reason we go to the trouble shows up again this week: Creal Springs addresses sit on both sides of the county line. Some of the listings with that mailing town are in Williamson County and some are in Johnson County. A mailing address is not a county. Anyone who groups this lake by postal town and calls the result a county split will publish a wrong number, which is what a town-level shortcut did when we tested it last week.

CountyListings on the searchLast week
Williamson2324
Johnson1414
Total3738

County read per listing record, not inferred from the mailing town.

What is on the lake right now

37 active listings, from $17,000 to $1,500,000. 24 of them carry a square-footage figure and 13 do not — which is most of what separates the bottom of this list from the top, and we are describing it that way because that is what the data says rather than attaching a label to it we have not checked.

The dearest threeAskingThe cheapest threeAsking
1921 Grange Hall Rd, Marion$1,500,000Lot 287 Parrish Ridge Ln, Goreville$17,000
11153 Southern Hunt Rd, Marion$1,100,000Lot 42 N Egypt Shores Dr, Creal Springs Precinct$25,000
0000 Lake Of Egypt Rd, Marion$899,900TBD Otis St, Marion$29,000

A range this wide is why the middle of the list moves when one listing leaves it.

We are not telling you which of these are on the water. That split cannot be done from this data and we established why a month ago: it needs every listing description read by hand, because a description that says “close to the water, without those waterfront taxes” contains the word and means the opposite. The descriptions are not in what we pulled. So this post makes no claim about any listing being on the water.

💬 Greg Holthaus on reading the lake

“The median went up and nothing got more expensive. That is not a contradiction, it is just what happens when the cheap end of the list gets shorter, and it is the single easiest way to be told the market did something it did not do. When somebody quotes you a median, the question is not what the number is. It is what left the list. The other one I would want a buyer to sit with is the house that is $20,000 cheaper than it was last week with nothing on the listing to say so. Same record, same day count ticking along, $20,000 off the price. If you want to know what a house has done, somebody has to have kept last week’s list.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker

Questions we get about the lake

Are prices falling at the Lake of Egypt?

Asking prices are not rising, at least over this week. Of the 36 listings on this search both on October 20 and on October 27, one cut its asking price by $20,000, none raised one, and 35 did not change at all. The total of every asking price on the search fell $170,000. Those are asking prices on listings that have not sold, which is a different thing from what houses are closing for.

Why did the median go up if no price went up?

Because a median describes which listings are on the list, not only what they cost. The listing that left was asking $150,000, below the middle of the list. Take a below-middle listing away and the middle moves up without any house changing price. We checked it the direct way: put that one listing back and the median returns to $320,000, exactly where it was. Undo the one price cut instead and the median does not budge from $350,000.

How many places are for sale at the lake right now?

37 on this search as of October 27, every one of them active, from $17,000 to $1,500,000. 24 carry a square-footage figure and 13 do not. A week earlier the same search returned 38.

Is the Lake of Egypt in Williamson County or Johnson County?

Both. Of the 37 listings on this search, 23 sit in Williamson County and 14 in Johnson County, each one read from its own listing record rather than guessed from its mailing town. Creal Springs addresses appear on both sides of the county line, which is why a mailing town cannot be used as a county here.

If a house drops its price, will the listing say so?

Not necessarily. 1925 MURPHY RD is $20,000 cheaper than it was seven days ago, under the same listing record it had then, and in neither of the two snapshots we hold does it carry a price-change flag. We hold two days a week apart, so we cannot tell you a flag never appeared between them — only that there is none to see now.

Thinking about the lake? Send an address and a broker will pull its full listing history — every price it has asked and every record it has been listed under, not just the one on the screen today. Find your broker › or text 618.925.8654.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Two pulls of the same standing search for listings whose descriptions mention the Lake of Egypt, October 20 and October 27, seven days apart, run with the identical query both weeks: 38 listings then, 37 now, every row active in both. This is a keyword search on listing descriptions, not a listing of the market — a listing can join or leave it because wording changed, so every count here is a count on this search. Matched on street line plus town, not on listing record, after checking that no street line changed its town between the two pulls; no address appears twice in either pull. Reconciled against the record-level counts in the corrected form that subtracts address edits: 0 = (1 − 1) + 0, and the same on departures; the older form that omitted the edits would have reported 1 arrival instead of 0. County resolved per listing record, not from a mailing town, carried forward from the October 20 edition in which all 38 records were fetched individually; every one of today’s 37 records was present in that pull, so none is inferred. The median figures were recomputed under two counterfactuals rather than explained. Why the one departed listing left is not published, because we could not verify it and will not guess; it is not described as sold. On the price-change flag: absent in both snapshots we hold, which is not the same as never having appeared between them. Asking prices are not sale prices, and a median is composition as well as price. No cause is offered for any price move and nothing here is a forecast. No on-water or waterfront claim is made about any listing, because the descriptions needed to do it honestly are not in this data. No property-type label is attached to any listing, because the source carries a numeric code we have not verified. No property-tax figure, no price per square foot, no interest rate and no payment figure appears on this page. Listings change daily; confirm anything you intend to rely on. Source note: figures on this page include local MLS data as published by Redfin (redfin.com).

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us