Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Lake of Egypt

Four Listings Joined This Search This Week. Two Have Been for Sale for Three Months.

A weekly read of every listing whose own remarks mention the lake — and this week, a plain demonstration of what that instrument can and cannot tell you.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 3, 2026

Every week we read the lake the same way: every active listing whose own remarks mention the Lake of Egypt, pulled with the identical search both weeks so that a difference in the list is a difference in the listings and not in the question. This morning it holds 37 listings. A week ago it held 37.

And that flat count is hiding the most useful thing this search has shown us yet.

37
listings on the search, both weeks
4
joined it, and 4 left
95
days on market, the oldest arrival
1
of the 33 on both lists changed price

Four listings joined the search, and two of them are not new

Here are the four rows that appear this week and did not appear last week.

AddressMailing townAskingDays on marketFloor area
Lot 33 Bluebird LnGoreville$169,0006—
1043 Wargo LnMarion$230,00071,440 sq ft
350 Sugar Creek Rd ●Goreville$379,90089621 sq ft
13481 S Egypt Shores Dr ●Creal Springs$474,900951,674 sq ft

The two rows marked ● are the ones that were already for sale. A floor area is shown where the record carries one — 23 of the 37 rows do, and the rest are described by what they lack rather than by a type code we have not verified.

Two of them are genuinely new listings: 6 and 7 days on market. The other two carry 89 and 95 days — about three months apiece. They did not come on the market this week. They joined this search this week.

We have been saying in every one of these posts that membership in this search depends on the words in a listing’s own remarks, and that a row can join or leave with no house moving. That has been a caveat. This week it is a measurement: half of what looks like new supply at the lake is not new supply at all. Anyone watching a saved search and counting what appears in it is counting something other than what they think they are counting.

And four rows left, two of them with Carbondale addresses

AddressMailing townAskingDays on marketFloor area
5465 Grassy RdCarbondale$655,000633,800 sq ft
175 Oak CirGoreville$499,900412,726 sq ft
448 Clifty Heights DrMarion$499,900832,120 sq ft
3768 Route 148 RteCarbondale$350,000631,872 sq ft

None of these is described as sold. A row can leave this search because it went under contract, because it was withdrawn or expired, or because somebody edited the remarks it was matching on. We hold two snapshots seven days apart and cannot tell those apart, so we do not.

The same instrument, read the other way. Carbondale went from two rows on this search to none, and this week’s rows carry six mailing towns between them.

Mailing townOctober 27November 3
Marion1616
Goreville1112
Creal Springs56
Creal Springs Precinct11
New Burnside11
Southern Precinct11
Carbondale20

Mailing towns as the records give them, not counties and not locations. A town leaving this table entirely is what a keyword search does when the listings that matched it leave.

We are not going to tell you where any of those sits in relation to the water, because we have not measured it and the record does not say. What the table shows is a fact about mailing towns on a keyword search, and that is all we are claiming from it.

The median fell $120,000. The average fell $20,703. One listing changed price.

October 27November 3Move
Median asking price$350,000$230,000−$120,000
Average asking price$374,949$354,246−$20,703
Lower quarter$86,000$86,000—
Upper quarter$585,000$489,000−$96,000
Cheapest row$17,000$17,000—
Dearest row$1,500,000$1,500,000—

Both statistics are computed over every row on the search in that week, 37 and 37. The cheapest row, the dearest row and the lower quarter did not move at all.

Read those three rows together. The median fell $120,000; the average fell $20,703, which is the same direction at 5.8 times the size; and the cheapest row, the dearest row and the lower quarter did not move at all.

Now the number that settles what any of it means. Of the 33 listings on the search both weeks, exactly one listing changed price — 12335 Bermuda Dr in Marion, down $15,000 from $385,000 to $370,000. Nothing else on this search moved a dollar in either direction.

So neither statistic is telling you anything about what property at the lake is worth. Both are telling you which rows left and which joined. On a list of 37 the median is one row’s position in the queue, and four rows turning over shunts it a long way; the average, spread across every row, barely noticed. The gap between the two figures is the finding, not either figure. We are not going to give you a reason for the one cut, because the record does not carry one.

How we know the window is seven days wide

Worth showing, because every week-over-week figure above depends on it. The days-on-market count on each row is its own check: on the 33 rows present in both pulls it advanced by exactly seven days on 31 of them. The field counts what it says it counts, and the two pulls are seven days apart.

Two rows are exceptions, and they are published rather than smoothed. 10570 Steele Acres Ln in Marion advanced from 44 days to 59 — 15 days across a 7-day gap — with no price change and the same badges in both snapshots. And Lot 42 N Egypt Shores Dr in Creal Springs Precinct carries no days-on-market figure in either pull. We do not know why either behaves that way, and a missing figure is not a zero — it is a smaller denominator, which is why every days-on-market count on this page is over 36 rows and not 37, and every floor area over 23.

What this post is not saying

Nothing here says anything sold. Every row in both pulls is active, and the four rows that left are not described as sold, pending, withdrawn or expired, because we cannot see which. Nothing here says which listings are on the water. That needs every remark read by hand — a listing can say it is close to the water without those waterfront taxes, which contains the word and means the opposite — and remarks are not in this data. Nothing here is a distance or a drive time, to the lake or between anywhere; nothing on this page was measured, so nothing is stated. Nothing here translates a property-type code: the records carry four numeric codes and we describe rows by whether they carry a floor area instead. There is no price per square foot and no property-tax figure anywhere on this page, and no interest rate or payment figure either. And nothing here is a forecast.

If you are watching the lake

The practical lesson is the one the arrivals table makes for us. A saved search will tell you what is new to the search, and this week half of that was months old. If you are waiting for something specific at the lake, the useful thing is a list built on what you actually want rather than on whether a listing happens to use the lake’s name in its write-up, and somebody has to build that for you and keep it current. The number is 618.925.8654, or ask any of our brokers.

💬 Greg Holthaus on a saved search

“Four listings showed up on our lake search this week and two of them had been for sale for three months. That is not the market changing, that is a search changing, and the two get confused constantly — by buyers watching a saved search and sometimes by people who should know better. The other half of it is that the median on this list fell $120,000 while exactly one listing changed price. If you want to know what a place at the lake is worth, the number you need is not a median of whatever is on a list this week. Ask somebody to build it from the handful of properties that are actually like yours.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: This post reads two pulls of one standing search of our local MLS listing data, October 27 and November 3, seven days apart: every active listing whose own remarks mention the Lake of Egypt, 37 rows then 37, every row active in both. Both pulls used the identical search, by construction, so there is no difference of question to rule out and none is claimed. The instrument is a keyword search and that is a published limit, not a footnote: membership depends on the words in a listing’s remarks, so a row can join or leave with no house moving, and every count here is a count of rows on this search rather than of houses at the lake. This week two of the four arrivals carried 89 and 95 days on market, which is that limit measured rather than asserted. Arrivals and departures are matched on street line plus mailing town and reconciled against each record’s own stable id, which gave the same answer both ways this week: 4 = (4 − 0) + 0, and the same on departures. No address was rewritten in place and no listing was relisted under a new record this week, and no address carries two rows. The week-over-week price figures are computed over the 33 rows present in both pulls, not over either pull as a whole; the medians and averages are computed over every row in their own week. The days-on-market field advanced by exactly seven days on 31 of those 33 rows, which is an independent check on the window; the two exceptions are named above rather than smoothed, and a missing figure is treated as a smaller denominator and never as a zero — days-on-market figures are over 36 rows, floor areas over 23, of 37. No listing is described as sold, and no reason is given for any departure or for the one price cut, because the data carries none. No on-water or waterfront claim appears, because that needs every remark read by hand and remarks are not in this payload. No distance and no drive time appears, because none was measured. No property-type code is translated into a label. No price per square foot is computed anywhere and no property-tax figure appears. Asking prices are not sale prices, and nothing here forecasts whether prices will rise or fall. Listings change daily; confirm anything you intend to rely on. Source note: figures on this page include local MLS data as published by Redfin (redfin.com).

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us