Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Lake of Egypt

The Median Fell $30,500 on Our Lake of Egypt Search. Not One Seller Cut a Price.

Our standing Lake of Egypt search ran again this morning, seven days after the last one. Nothing left it, and not one of the 37 listings that carried over changed its asking price. The median asking price fell $30,500 anyway, and the reason is worth more than the number.

37
listings carried over from last week
0
of them changed an asking price
$30,500
the median fell anyway
$0
of that came from repricing

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 10, 2026 · Lake of Egypt

Our standing Lake of Egypt search carried 37 listings a week ago. It carries 38 this morning. Nothing left it, one listing joined it, and every single one of the 37 that carried over is asking exactly what it was asking last week — compared listing by listing, not totalled up and eyeballed.

The median asking price on the search still fell $30,500, from $230,000 to $199,500. Those two facts are not in conflict, and the way they fit together is the most useful thing on this page.

A week in which nobody moved a number

Start with what makes the comparison trustworthy. The 37 carried-over listings were matched one to one on a stable identifier rather than on their address text, and each one’s price was checked against its own figure from last week. Every one of them is unchanged.

The data also confirms its own window. The days-on-market figure advanced by exactly seven days on 36 of the 37 carried-over listings. That is a week measured by the records themselves rather than by our calendar, and it is worth checking: if those figures had drifted, the two readings would not be describing the span this post claims. One listing carries no days-on-market value in either reading, so it is excluded from that count rather than counted as a zero.

The only alteration of any kind on any carried-over listing was a display badge: one of them added an open-house notice. The search does not carry the date or the hour, so no time appears here.

So why did the median fall $30,500?

Because one listing joined, and it is cheaper than most: a $60,000 listing carrying no floor area, which had been on the market two days when we read it. The old median was $230,000. Drop a $60,000 listing onto a list of 37 and the middle of that list moves down, whatever the sellers already on it are doing — which, this week, was nothing at all.

What changedLast weekThis morningDifference
Listings on the search3738+1
Median asking price$230,000$199,500-$30,500
Average asking price$354,246$346,503-$7,743
Carried-over listings that repriced—0$0 of the fall

Both readings are of the same keyword search, seven days apart.

Here is the check that settles it rather than asserting it. Take last week’s 37 asking prices, add the $60,000 newcomer, and you get this morning’s set of 38 exactly — the same numbers, not merely the same median. The repricing contribution to a $30,500 fall is $0. All of it is arithmetic about who is on the list.

The average behaves differently, and the difference is instructive. It fell $7,743 against the median’s $30,500. One cheap addition drags an average a little, because it is one figure among 38; it can shove a median a long way, because a median only cares about which listing sits in the middle. On a list this short, that is a trap worth knowing about before somebody quotes you a number.

A quiet week is not a different market

The tempting next sentence writes itself: the lake is holding firm while the rest of the area cuts. We are not going to write it, because we checked whether the week was unusual at all, and it is not.

Over the same seven days in our four-county listing data, 29 of the 415 listings that appear in both readings changed price — all of them reductions, at a typical $10,100. That is a weekly repricing rate of 7.0%. Applied to a list of 37, it predicts about 2.6 repricings in a week. Seeing exactly zero instead happens roughly one week in 15 through nothing but chance.

So this week is quiet, and quiet weeks are common on a short list. It is not evidence that sellers around the lake are behaving differently from sellers anywhere else in the area. This search would need about 42 carried-over listings before a week of zero repricings would be surprising rather than ordinary. It has 37. That is the resolution of the instrument, and it seems better to print it than to lean on a number it cannot support.

One more honest limit on that comparison: the two sets are not nested. This search picks up listings whose descriptions mention the lake, including some in zip codes outside those four counties, and the four-county data does not pick listings by their wording at all. They overlap and neither sits inside the other. What is identical is the measurement — a price read twice, seven days apart — and that is what the two rates compare.

What this search can and cannot see

It is a keyword search: listings whose own public remarks mention Lake of Egypt. That is the most honest net available without reading every description by hand, and it has a known leak. A listing can enter or leave because somebody edited a sentence, with no house moving. Last week’s edition showed that plainly — two of the listings that joined the search had by then been for sale for 89 and 95 days.

This week the leak did not bite: the one listing that joined had been for sale two days, so it is genuinely new rather than newly worded. Worth noting precisely because it is the opposite of what happened last week, and because it means this week’s arrival really is an arrival.

What the search cannot tell you is which of these listings front the water. The data behind it does not carry that, and the descriptions cannot settle it either — a remark can mention the water in order to say a property is close to it rather than on it. So no listing on this page is described as being on the water, and no distance to anything is given, because nothing here was measured. 23 of the 38 listings carry a floor area at all. What the others are is not something the data states, so this post says only that they do not carry one rather than putting a property type on them.

What this does not tell you

It does not tell you prices around the lake are falling. Not one asking price on this search moved, and an asking price is a number a seller chose in any case — not a sale, not an appraisal and not a value. It does not tell you the lake is stronger than the rest of the area, for the reason set out above. It does not say why the new listing came on, or why nobody else changed anything; the records carry the figures, not the reasons. It does not forecast anything. And it describes two readings seven days apart: a listing can change its price or leave the search this afternoon.

Common questions

Did Lake of Egypt asking prices drop this week?

No. Not one of the 37 listings that was on this search last week changed its asking price — every figure is identical, and the comparison was made listing by listing rather than on the totals. What fell is the median of the search, by $30,500, and it fell because a $60,000 listing joined the search below the old middle. A median is the middle of whatever is on the list, so adding a cheap listing moves it without anybody lowering anything.

Is the lake holding firmer than the rest of the area?

This week cannot tell you that, and it would be easy to pretend otherwise. Over the same seven days in our four-county listing data, 29 of the 415 listings present in both readings changed price — a rate of 7.0% a week. At that rate you would expect about 2.6 repricings on a list of 37, and seeing exactly zero happens about one week in 15 by chance alone. A quiet week on a short list is not evidence of a different market.

How big would this search need to be before a week like this meant something?

About 42 listings. At the regional weekly rate, zero repricings on a list that size would be genuinely unlikely rather than ordinary. This search carries 37 carried-over listings, which is not enough, and that is a limit worth stating rather than working around.

What is this search, exactly?

It is a keyword search: listings whose own public remarks mention Lake of Egypt. That makes it useful and it makes it imperfect. A listing can join or leave because an agent edited a description, with no house changing hands — last week’s edition found two listings that joined after being for sale for 89 and 95 days. So every count here is a count of what is on this search, never of what is on the market around the lake.

Does this tell me which listings are on the water?

No, and this post does not guess. The data behind it does not say which listings front the water, and the wording in a description cannot settle it — a remark can mention the water precisely to say a property is near it rather than on it. No distance to anything is stated anywhere on this page either, because nothing here was measured.

💬 Greg Holthaus on a median that moves by itself

“A week like this one is the best argument I know for not pricing off a median. Every seller on that search held firm, and the middle number still dropped $30,500 because somebody listed a lot. If you are selling, the number that matters is what a buyer at your price is comparing you against, and there are only 38 listings on this whole search — so that comparison is a short, specific list, not a statistic. If you are buying, the useful question about the newcomer is not whether it moved the median. It is whether it is the only one at that price, and that is a question somebody has to go and answer for you.”

Want the actual list rather than the median? Call or text 618.925.8654 and we will walk the current Lake of Egypt listings with you, including the one with the open house.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

Where these numbers come from

Two readings of the same standing search, seven days apart — November 3 and November 10, 37 listings then and 38 now, every one of them an active listing in each reading where it appears. The query was identical both weeks and the builder asserts the search string rather than trusting it, because a difference of question would look exactly like a difference of market.

Listings were matched one to one on a stable record identifier, not on the address text, and the identifier is never printed. Every carried-over listing’s asking price was compared with its own figure from last week, which is how the post can say not one of them moved rather than only that the totals look similar. The days-on-market field gives an independent check on the window: it advanced by exactly seven days on 36 of the 37 carried-over listings, and the one that carries no value for it is left out of that count rather than counted as zero.

The regional comparison is our four-county listing data for Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties, read on November 2 and November 9 — the same seven-day span, and the same measurement, a price compared at two readings. The two sets are not nested: this search reaches zip codes that sit outside those four counties, and the four-county data does not pick listings by what their remarks mention. They overlap, neither contains the other, and the post compares rates rather than treating one as a subset of the other.

About these figures: every number above comes from local MLS listing data read on the morning of November 10, 2026. A reduction is a change in an asking price, not a sale and not a valuation — and this week there were none to report on this search at all. Nothing here is described as sold, pending or contingent, because nothing we read says it is and because nothing left this search this week. No individual listing is named, and no address, seller or record identifier appears anywhere on this page. No distance or drive time is stated, because none was measured, and no listing is described as being on the water, because the data does not say. One carried-over listing added an open-house notice; the search carries no date or time for it, so none is printed here — call and we will tell you what it says. Nothing on this page is a loan offer, a rate quote or any statement about financing: no interest rate, no monthly payment and no lender appears in it, and it makes no claim about what anybody can borrow. It names no broker other than Greg, and no other brokerage. Figures describe active listings on the morning they were read; a listing can change its price or leave the search the same afternoon. Source note: figures on this page include local MLS data as published by Redfin (redfin.com).

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us