Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Marion

The $38 Tax Bill on a $434,000 House

Fourteen houses arrived in Marion in fourteen days, and four of them filled the band that was empty two weeks ago. Then we looked at the tax line on the new builds.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 7, 2026

14 housesarrived in fourteen days
Four of themin the band that was empty
$38 a yeartax on a $434,000 house

Two weeks ago this column counted fifteen new Marion listings and found an $84,900 hole in the middle of them — one house at $185,000, the next at $269,900, and nothing in between. We said at the time that fifteen houses over two weeks is a window and not a trend, and that one listing the following Tuesday would close it.

Four listings closed it. Fourteen houses have arrived in the fourteen days since, and four of them landed inside that exact band.

AddressAskingBd/BaSq ftBuiltDays
listed
Annual tax
as recorded
4 Victory Ln$100,0002/170020129none given
705 W College St$120,0002/11,09319002$1,912
1300 S Mechanic St$140,0003/11,28819005$1,137
526 Power Plant Rd$169,0001/157620208$732
3748 Stewart Ln$175,0003/11,500201513$1,736
11694 Elizabeth Dr$225,0003/32,22819757$3,052
902 Cedar Ln$245,0004/21,88419652$2,843
805 E Marshall St$254,9003/21,650199213$3,657
418 Charlotte Rd$265,0004/22,180195012$3,647
16365 Caplinger Pond Rd$295,0004/42,15119832$4,039
1504 Cardinal Dr$340,0003/21,956201613$5,738
15687 Jadin Rd$365,0004/32,570201312$5,968
15252 Cochran Rd$375,0003/21,64420268$5,144
12901 Leslie Ct$619,0004/33,000202612$3,422

Every house in our own Marion feed with a day count of fourteen or fewer, read on the morning of October 7, 2026. Fourteen days is deliberate: it is the same window our September 23 Marion post used, so the two are comparable. It also means the three houses that post wrote about are correctly excluded here — they are still listed, but they are not new. Shaded rows are the four that landed in the $185,000 to $269,900 band. The tax column is the figure carried on the listing record, which is the current assessment on the property as it stands today.

So the thin spot in Marion’s middle was a fortnight of supply, not a feature of the market. If you are the buyer we described on September 23 — working with something around $200,000 in the town where that budget is scarcest — there are now four houses to look at that were not there when we wrote it: 11694 Elizabeth Dr at $225,000, 902 Cedar Ln at $245,000, 805 E Marshall St at $254,900, 418 Charlotte Rd at $265,000.

And the gap has not disappeared. It has moved to the top. Nothing new arrived between $375,000 and $619,000 this fortnight — a $244,000 step, nearly three times the hole we found in the middle two weeks ago.

But that is a statement about new supply and not about what is available, and the distinction matters as much today as it did then: 23 houses are already sitting in that range, from $379,000 to $599,999. Nobody shopping at $400,000 is short of choices. What has stopped is the restocking, and those 23 have been listed a median of 67 days.

On Most of the New Builds, the Tax Line Describes a Vacant Lot

Here is what we actually went looking for and did not expect to find. Every listing in our feed carries the property’s annual tax figure. Yesterday’s post used it on vacant land at the lake and closed with an aside: a lot is assessed as vacant ground today, which is not what it will be assessed as once something is standing on it.

That aside is sitting in the Marion listings right now, on houses that are already built.

AddressBuiltAskingDays
listed
Annual tax
as recorded
Share of
asking
12901 Leslie Ct2026$619,00012$3,4220.55%
1106 Horizon Dr2025$434,000360$380.01%
7180 Canyon Ct2026$405,00090$6600.16%
202 S Monroe St2026$398,00061none given—
15252 Cochran Rd2026$375,0008$5,1441.37%
107 Brase St2026$295,00054$1460.05%
1400 E Parham St2026$226,000140$2810.12%
1101 E Boyton St2026$219,00081$1,6970.77%

Eight Marion houses on the market were built in 2024 or later. Their median recorded tax is 0.16% of what they are asking. For every other house in town that publishes both figures, the median is 1.56% — about ten times as much.

It is not all eight, and that matters. Seven publish a tax figure, and of those, four sit under a fifth of one percent — those are plainly still carrying the pre-construction number. One, 15252 Cochran Rd, is at 1.37%, which is inside the ordinary range for the town and looks like a property the county has already been out to. The other two fall in between. So this is a pattern across the group rather than a rule about every new house, and the only way to know which one you are looking at is to check.

The clearest case is 1106 Horizon Dr. It is asking $434,000, it was built in 2025, and the tax figure on the listing is $38 a year. Not a typo and not a rounding: thirty-eight dollars. Three more are under seven hundred dollars a year: 107 Brase St at $146 on a $295,000 house, 1400 E Parham St at $281 on a $226,000 house, 7180 Canyon Ct at $660 on a $405,000 house.

⚠️ What This Means If You Are Buying New

A tax figure that low is not a bargain — it is the assessment from before the house existed, carried forward on the record because the county has not caught up with the construction yet. The house gets reassessed, and the figure that replaces it is not in any listing you can read today.

Here is the arithmetic, and it is arithmetic rather than a prediction. At 1.56% — the median rate the rest of Marion’s listings actually carry — a $434,000 house would run about $6,770 a year, roughly $564 a month. The listing shows $3 a month. That is on the order of $561 a month that is not on the page, and if you built your payment around the number you were shown, that is where it lands.

We are not telling you what the assessor will do. Assessments are set parcel by parcel and we do not forecast them. What we are telling you is that the figure on the listing describes a vacant lot and your payment will not.

Two Notes On the Table Above, Because the Flag and the Year Agree Here and Elsewhere They Do Not

Our feed has a separate “new construction” flag, and on October 2 in Carterville we found it was narrower than the build year — two houses flagged against five built since 2020. In Marion today the two agree exactly: eight houses carry the flag, eight were built in 2024 or later, and they are the same eight. Worth saying, because it means it does not matter which one you count here, and it did matter two towns over.

And one of the eight, 202 S Monroe St, publishes no tax figure at all. That is the honest version of the same problem: a blank is at least not a misleading number.

What the Rest of the Market Looks Like Underneath

Beyond the arrivals: 74 houses are for sale in our Marion feed, asking a median of $295,500 and running from $39,900 to $1,500,000. The median has been listed 49 days, and the median build year is 1990. One house publishes no day count and is left out of that median.

The age table above is the one worth a second look for reasons that have nothing to do with new construction. Houses built before 1960 ask a median of $125,950 and carry a median tax of $1,932. Houses from 1990 to 2009 ask $453,950 and carry $8,071. As a share of price those two are almost the same — 1.57% and 1.60% — which is the point: the tax tracks the value, not the vintage. The dollar gap is what the houses cost, not what the age does.

If You Are Shopping Marion This Week

  • The middle is stocked again. Four houses between $185,000 and $269,900 arrived in a fortnight, after a fortnight with none. If you looked two weeks ago and left empty-handed, look again.
  • Ask for the tax bill, not the tax line — on anything built in the last two years, and honestly on anything at all. The listing figure is a record, not a quote.
  • At the top of the market, the choice is the standing inventory. 23 houses between $375,000 and $619,000, a median of 67 days listed, and nothing new joining them this fortnight. That is a position to negotiate from.
  • 4 Victory Ln at $100,000 is the cheapest thing that arrived, and it is 700 square feet. Cheap and small are the same sentence here, not two different ones.
When it was builtHouses
for sale
Median
asking
Median annual
tax recorded
Tax as a share
of asking
Built 2024–20268$386,500$6600.16%
2010–20237$296,000$5,4131.66%
1990–200924$453,950$8,0711.60%
1960–198921$295,000$3,9001.30%
Before 196014$125,950$1,9321.57%

The share column is the figure to read; the dollar columns are there to show what is in each group. 5 of the 74 houses publish no tax figure at all and are left out of the tax columns only — one of them is a new build. Read the dollar medians against the asking medians beside them rather than against each other: the 1990–2009 group pays the most tax in dollars because it is the dearest group, not because of its age.

Jarod Sanders, SIRE in-house lender

💰 The Tax Line Goes Into Your Payment. On a New Build It May Not Be the Right One.

Escrow is built on taxes and insurance, so a tax figure that still describes a vacant lot produces a monthly payment that is not the payment. Four of the eight new builds on the market in Marion are carrying one. On one house on the market right now the gap is on the order of $561 a month. Get the real figure into the estimate before you decide what you can afford, not after. Free, no-pressure conversation with Jarod Sanders, SIRE’s in-house lender.Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228. Not a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility. Payment and escrow figures are illustrative.

Talk to Jarod →

💬 Greg Holthaus on the Tax Line

“I have sat at closing tables where the buyer found out about the taxes that week, and it is not a conversation anybody enjoys. On a new build it is almost guaranteed, because the county has not been out there yet. Thirty-eight dollars on a four-hundred-and-thirty-thousand-dollar house is not a deal, it is a placeholder. The fix is boring and it takes one phone call: get the parcel number, look at what the houses around it pay, and put that number in your budget instead. And on the arrivals — two weeks ago I would have told you there was nothing to show somebody at two and a quarter. This week there are four. That is how fast a small market changes, and it is why I do not like reading much into any one fortnight, including a good one.”

🏠 Want the Actual Tax Bill On a House Before You Make an Offer?

Parcel number, current assessment, what comparable houses on the same street actually pay — those are public records and pulling them is twenty minutes of our time, not yours. Tell us which house, or just the price range you are working in, and a SIRE broker will bring the real numbers. No cost, and no obligation to list or buy with anybody.

About Marion

📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.

Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.

Text Greg · 618.925.8654
Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Every figure here comes from our own listing feed for Marion, read on the morning of October 7, 2026. The pull returned 136 active listings, of which 74 are single-family houses and the rest are land, commercial and other types; all house figures below are the 74. There are no duplicate addresses or duplicate MLS numbers in the set. “Arrived” means a day count of fourteen or fewer. Fourteen days is used deliberately because our September 23 Marion post used the same window, which makes the two comparable; the three houses that post featured are still listed and are correctly excluded here, because they are not new. A day count describes the current listing, not the property’s whole history, and a relisted house shows the newer count. We have not differenced any day count against a figure from an earlier post, because the two come from different sources counting from different listing dates. Tax figures are the annual amount recorded on each listing — the current assessment on the property as the county has it today. They are not forecasts and we do not predict reassessments. On a recently built house the recorded figure generally describes the parcel before construction, which is the subject of the middle section of this post. The payment arithmetic in this post applies the median tax-to-asking ratio of Marion listings that are NOT new construction (1.56%, on 62 houses) to one specific asking price. It is an order of magnitude to budget against, not a prediction of any assessment, and a real escrow payment also includes insurance and depends on the lender. Only the county can tell you a property’s assessment and only a lender can tell you a payment. 5 of the 74 houses publish no tax figure and are excluded from the tax columns and tax medians only; one of those is a new build. One house publishes no day count and is excluded from the days-on-market median and from the arrivals set. Our feed’s “new construction” flag and a build year of 2024 or later identify the same 8 houses in Marion today; that is not true in every town — in Carterville on October 2 the flag was narrower than the build year — so the two are not interchangeable in general. Asking prices are not sale prices, and a house that leaves the active list has not necessarily sold. Nothing here is an appraisal, a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a legal or tax opinion. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us