Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Market Monday

Marion Has 3.5 Times as Many Houses as Herrin. Under $200,000, It Has Four More.

244 active houses across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties, read this morning. Where your choices actually are once you put a budget on the search — and why the $200,000 to $300,000 middle is the thinnest band in this market.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 12, 2026

Every Monday we read our own listing feed across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties and report what is actually standing on the market. This morning it held 244 houses. One comparison in that pile is worth more to a buyer than any average we could print.

244
houses for sale
112
under $200,000
42
$200K to $300K
90
$300,000 and up

Marion has 3.5 times as many houses as Herrin. Under $200,000 it has four more

Marion is carrying 70 houses this morning. Herrin is carrying twenty. On inventory alone that is not close, and if you are shopping on nothing but selection, Marion is the obvious place to start looking.

Then you put a budget on it. Under $200,000, Marion has eighteen houses and Herrin has fourteen — a difference of four. The entire inventory advantage, all 70 listings against twenty, comes down to four houses once you cap the price, because only 26% of Marion's listings sit under $200,000 against 70% of Herrin's. The median asking price tells the same story from the other end: $321,500 in Marion, $139,950 in Herrin.

This is not an argument that one town is better than the other. They are different inventories aimed at different budgets, and a buyer shopping well above that cap should read these two numbers in exactly the opposite direction. It is an argument that "which town has the most houses" is the wrong question unless you ask it inside your own price range.

The thin part of this market is the middle

Sort all 244 houses by asking price and the shape is not a hump. It is a barbell. 112 houses are under $200,000, which is 46% of everything for sale. 90 are at $300,000 or more, another 37%. The band in between — $200,000 to $300,000 — holds 42 houses, just 17%.

Asking priceHouses 
Under $100,00039
$100,000 – $150,00043
$150,000 – $200,00030
$200,000 – $300,00042
$300,000 – $500,00061
$500,000 and up29

That middle band is where a lot of people shop: the family that has outgrown a starter house and is not buying acreage. Across four counties this morning there are 42 houses in it. That is a real constraint on a move-up buyer, and it is the figure we would want to know before starting a search.

Where the houses are, town by town

Every town in our four-county feed with at least five houses listed, with how many of them fall under $200,000.

TownCountyHouses for saleUnder $200,000Share
MarionWilliamson701826%
CartervilleWilliamson22523%
Carbondale †Jackson22941%
HerrinWilliamson201470%
West Frankfort †Franklin181267%
AnnaUnion16850%
MurphysboroJackson15853%
JonesboroUnion8675%
Johnston CityWilliamson7571%
DeSoto †Jackson6467%
CambriaWilliamson5480%
Creal SpringsWilliamson5120%

† Mailing addresses in this town fall under more than one county. The count is the whole town; the county column shows where most of its listings sit. Towns with fewer than five houses listed are not shown.

Two patterns run through that table. The two towns carrying the most listings, Marion and Carterville, hold two of the lowest shares under $200,000 — Carterville has five under the cap out of 22. The highest shares belong to the smallest towns: Cambria tops the table at 80% and Jonesboro has six of its eight houses under the cap. The one town with a lower share than Carterville is Creal Springs at 20%, and it is carrying five houses, so it is a small sample rather than a pattern. If your budget is modest, the towns with the longest lists are not where your choices are.

Widening the search by a few towns, not a few dollars

Here is the same budget, searched three ways, this morning.

  • Marion only: eighteen houses under $200,000.
  • Marion, Herrin, Johnston City, Carterville and Cambria — all five in Williamson County: 46 houses, or 2.6 times as many.
  • All four counties: 112 houses, 6.2 times as many.

We are not claiming those towns are a short drive from each other, because we did not measure that and you know your own commute better than we do. What we can say is that all five sit inside one county, and that moving the pin on the map does far more for a buyer under $200,000 than moving the budget does.

What these numbers do not say

Four things, because a number without its limits is worth less than no number.

  • These are asking prices on houses still for sale, not sale prices. A house that listed and sold quickly has already left this feed, so standing inventory over-represents listings that have been sitting. Asking prices here should not be compared against median sale prices, which measure a different and generally cheaper set of houses.
  • Nothing here says how long anything has sat. We did not pull days on market for this week's post, so no figure above depends on it, and we are not going to imply a pace we did not measure.
  • Small towns move on one listing. Several towns in that table are carrying five or six houses. One sale or one new listing swings their share by more than ten points, so read the small rows as rough.
  • Towns are counted by mailing address, and some cross a county line. Carbondale is the clearest case: twenty-two houses in all, sixteen on the Jackson County side and six on the Williamson County side, with a combined median of $312,500. Counting only one side would have understated both the count and the price.

On September's closed sales

We would normally pair this with last month's closings. September has still not published for any of the ZIP codes we track, twelve days into October. That is a real absence and not a gap in our reading: each ZIP returned a complete 59-month history ending in August, so the month is missing at the source rather than missing from our query.

What August did record is consistent with the asking prices above. The median closed sale was $230,000 in the Marion ZIP against $106,450 in the Herrin ZIP. That is a gap of $123,550, pointing the same way as the gap in asking prices, though not as far: what is being asked today is $181,550 apart. Closings and asking prices measure different sets of houses, so the direction is the part worth reading, not the distance. We will report September here the week it lands.

If you are the buyer in that middle band

The honest advice this week is unglamorous. If you are shopping between $200,000 and $300,000 across these four counties, you are choosing from 42 houses. We did not measure how fast anything in that band moves, so we are not going to tell you to hurry. What we can say is that the set is small, which means hearing about a new listing the day it appears is worth more here than in a band with 112 houses in it, and that is the part a broker can actually do for you.

If your budget is under $200,000, the opposite problem applies: there are 112 houses and they are spread across a dozen towns, which is a lot of driving unless somebody narrows it first.

💬 Greg Holthaus on the Middle

“The number that stops me is 42 houses between $200,000 and $300,000 across four counties. That is the band I think about most — people who bought a starter house, had a second kid, and want one more bedroom without taking on land. There is not much there, and that is the whole problem. The other half of it is the part buyers talk themselves out of: if you are under $200,000 and you have decided on one town, you have cut your own list down to eighteen houses when there are 112 in the feed. I am not telling anybody where to live. I am saying pick the town for the reasons you actually care about, and know what that choice costs you in selection before you make it.”

🏦 Know Your Number Before You Shop a Thin Band

In a band this thin, the buyer who already has a pre-qualification letter is the one who gets the showing. Jarod Sanders at CrossCountry Mortgage can tell you what you actually qualify for before you start driving.

🏡 Tell Us Your Budget and Your Towns. We Will Send You the List.

There are 112 houses under $200,000 across these four counties and 42 between $200,000 and $300,000, spread over a dozen towns. Tell us the number and the towns you would actually live in, and one of our brokers will send back what fits — no cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.

Find a Broker

📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.

Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.

Text Greg · 618.925.8654
Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Inventory figures come from our own four-county listing feed covering Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties, read in a single pass on the morning of October 12, 2026. It returned 429 active listings under four county filters, every one a distinct property with no listing appearing twice; 244 of them are single-family houses carrying an asking price, and those 244 are the basis of every count above. This is a snapshot of what is standing on the market, not a record of what has sold — houses that listed and sold quickly have already left the feed, so standing inventory over-represents listings that have been on the market a while, and asking prices here should not be compared with median sale prices. Days on market and year built were not pulled for this post and no figure above depends on either; nothing here describes how long any house has been listed. Towns are counted by the city in the mailing address and summed across county filters, because some towns straddle a county line: Carbondale, West Frankfort and DeSoto each returned listings under two filters. The county column in the town table shows where the majority of a town’s listings sit, not a claim about any one property. Towns with fewer than five houses listed are omitted from the table; among those shown, several carry five or six listings, where a single sale moves the share by more than ten points. Price bands are exclusive of the upper bound, so a house asking exactly $200,000 is counted in the $200,000 band and not under it. Closed-sale medians are from local MLS closed-sale data for the ZIP codes covering Marion and Herrin and are shown for August 2026, the most recent published month. September had not published for any ZIP we track when this was written. Each ZIP returned a complete 59-month history, so the absent month reflects the source and not an empty query. Closed-sale figures are revised as late sales record, so recent months may shift. A ZIP code is not a town boundary, and the closed-sale and asking-price figures describe different sets of houses; they are shown together as corroboration of direction only, not as a like-for-like comparison. Nothing here is an appraisal. Mortgage pre-qualification is offered by Jarod Sanders, CrossCountry Mortgage, NMLS #2337228. This is not a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us