Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Market Monday — October 19, 2026

Homes Took 78 Days to Sell in September. Prices Went Up Anyway.

September’s numbers have finally published. The typical house that sold across our ten main towns had been listed 78 days — 16 more than last September, and outside a range that had not moved in four years.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 19, 2026

September’s closed sales have finally published. They had not when we last checked a week ago, which is why no September figure has appeared in this series until today. Here is the one that matters: the typical house that sold in September across our ten main towns had been on the market 78 days.

In each of the four previous Septembers that number sat between 58 and 62 days. This one is 16 days above last year and well outside a range that had not moved in four years.

78
days to sell in September
8 of 10
towns slower than last year
7 of 10
towns where price rose
384
homes sold in September

Five Septembers, same towns, same month

SeptemberMedian days to sellMedian town priceHomes sold
202262$129,175476
202358$111,000396
202458$111,675421
202562$135,850418
202678$139,384384

Each row is the same ten towns in the same month of the year, so the comparison is not a seasonal one. “Median days to sell” is the middle of the ten towns’ own medians, rounded to whole days; “median town price” is the middle of their median sale prices, which is not the same thing as a regional median. Closed sales from local MLS data.

Read that column down and the point is hard to miss. It never leaves the 58-to-62 range for four straight years — and then 78. Whatever is happening, it is not the calendar: every row is a September.

Eight of the ten towns got slower, and it holds where the volume is

A regional median can be dragged around by one town, so the more useful question is how many towns moved the same way. Eight of the ten took longer to sell than they did last September. Two got faster: Herrin and Marion.

The honest worry about a ten-town set is that the small towns are noisy. So here are only the six towns that closed at least 30 sales this September, which between them are most of the region’s activity.

SeptemberMedian days to sell, six busiest townsHomes sold
202455353
202562343
202668327

Carbondale, Carterville, Herrin, Marion, Murphysboro and West Frankfort — every town that closed at least 30 sales this September. The thin towns are excluded from this table on purpose.

Four of those six are slower than last September, and the middle of them has moved 55 to 62 to 68 days over three years. The slowdown is smaller once you drop the thin towns — which is exactly what should happen — but it does not disappear, and that is the part worth taking seriously.

Prices did not fall while that happened

This is the bit that surprises people. Seven of the ten towns closed September at a higher median than last September, and three closed lower: Anna, Carbondale and Herrin. The middle of the ten town medians went from $135,850 to $139,384.

Before anyone builds a plan on that, one caution that applies to every median sale price ever published: it is not the same house twice. It is the middle of whatever happened to close, so it moves when the mix of houses moves, not only when values move. A month with more new construction and fewer starter houses prints a higher median without any house being worth a dollar more.

Where the caution belongs

Johnston City, Anna and Jonesboro each closed fewer than fifteen sales this September. A town median on single-digit sales is not a trend and we are not going to treat one as a finding. That is why the headline above is a count of towns and a median across towns rather than any one town’s percentage.

The biggest single move was Carterville, from 62 days last September to 120 this September — a jump of 58 days, on 33 closings. That is enough sales to be interesting and not enough to be settled. The runner-up, Johnston City at 85 days, rests on 11 sales, so we are reporting it and leaving it there.

Volume: 384 homes sold across the ten towns this September, against 418 last September. Fewer sales, taking longer, at prices that mostly held. We did not measure why, and we are not going to hand you a reason we cannot support.

Two different numbers both called “days on market”

Worth separating, because this series has published both. The figure above is the median for houses that closed in a given month — a look backwards at completed sales. The counter you see on a listing that is still for sale is a different measure: it belongs to the listing record, and we have now confirmed on real listings three times this month that it keeps running, that a price cut does not reset it, and that re-listing a house starts a fresh one. A listing showing a low number can be a re-listing of a house that had been for sale far longer under its previous listing number.

And what is standing on the shelf this morning

Our own feed shows 248 houses for sale across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties, asking a median of $219,950, with 115 of them under $200,000. 202 of those 248 sit in the ten towns in this report.

TownClosed in SeptemberOn this many salesDays to sellFor sale todayMedian asking
Marion$219,9351015971$295,000
Herrin$124,963566521$139,900
Carterville$231,4323312026$281,500
Johnston City$174,94911857$119,000
Carbondale$119,965619421$340,000
Murphysboro$137,360356613$206,900
West Frankfort$141,408417118$134,949
Benton$151,95528663$109,000
Anna$129,962119014$228,450
Jonesboro$127,8377918$152,000

The two price columns are not comparable and we are not going to subtract them. The left one is the middle of what actually closed in September; the right one is the middle of what is standing on the shelf this morning. They are different sets of houses, and a standing list always over-represents whatever has been sitting a while.

If you are selling, the practical read is this: nothing in these figures says you have to cut your price, and plenty of them say you should plan on a longer calendar than you would have a year ago. The first three weeks are still where the real pricing decision gets made, and they arrive whatever the median does.

If you are buying, 115 houses under $200,000 are on the market right now, and the ones that have been sitting are the ones where a conversation is worth having.

💬 Greg Holthaus on a 78-Day Market

“78 days is not a bad market. It is a different market from the one people still have in their heads, which is the one where you listed on Thursday and picked an offer on Monday. That is over for most houses here, and pretending otherwise is how a seller ends up chasing a price down in increments. Price it where it belongs on day one, be available for showings, and expect to be on the market for a couple of months. The houses that are selling in three weeks are still selling in three weeks. They just priced it right the first time.”

🏠 Want This for Your Street, Not the Region?

Send us your address and a broker will put together what actually sold near you this September, what it sold for, and how long each one took — and what your house would compete against if you listed it this month. No cost, and no obligation to work with anybody.

📱 Got a Question About This Market? Text Greg.

Buying? Selling? Not sure where to start? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.

Text Greg · 618.925.8654
Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Closed-sale figures — median sale price, number of homes sold and median days on market — are the published monthly series from local MLS data for ten ZIP-level towns, pulled on October 19, 2026: Marion, Herrin, Carterville and Johnston City (Williamson); Carbondale and Murphysboro (Jackson); West Frankfort and Benton (Franklin); Anna and Jonesboro (Union). Each town’s series carries sixty monthly observations, and September 2026 is the newest published month; it had not published when this series checked on October 12. The three metrics are matched by their published labels rather than by position in the payload, so a reordering upstream would show up as a missing figure rather than as transposed ones. Smaller places in the four counties — Creal Springs, Pittsburg, DeSoto, Cobden, Dongola, Zeigler and Christopher, plus the rural balance — are not in the closed-sale set, which covers 202 of the 248 houses active in the four-county feed today. “Median days to sell” is the middle of the ten towns’ own medians, rounded to whole days, and “median town price” is the middle of their median sale prices — neither is a single regional median. Johnston City, Anna and Jonesboro each closed fewer than fifteen sales this September, and no single town is presented as a trend. A median sale price is the middle of whatever closed and moves with the mix of houses as well as with values. Active-listing figures come from one pull of our own feed on the morning of October 19, 2026, filtered to active listings in the four counties: 435 records against a reported total of the same number, every listing number distinct, cross-checked against our previous pull with 433 listings common to both. Asking prices are not sale prices and the two price columns in the town table are not subtracted anywhere in this post. No cause is assigned to any movement and no forecast is made. Property tax figures and price per square foot are deliberately absent. Nothing here is an appraisal. Southern Illinois Realty Experts is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us