Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Market Monday

23 Price Cuts in a Week, and Not One Increase

The closed-sale series has not published a new month since we reported September a week ago, so here is the side that did move: every listing in the four counties, differenced against the same query seven days ago.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 26, 2026

The closed-sale figures have not moved. September is still the newest closed month published for all ten towns we track, exactly as it was when this series reported it a week ago, and we are not going to dress the same month up twice. So this morning we did something else: we ran the identical four-county listing query we ran seven days ago and differenced the two, listing by listing.

23
cut their asking price
0
raised it
$10,000
median cut
$412,890
taken off asking prices

23 cuts, no increases

416 listings were on the market both weeks. Of those, 23 came down in price and none went up — 5.5% of the standing list moving one direction and nothing moving the other. The cuts ran from $2,500 to $150,000, median $10,000, and they add up to $412,890 taken off asking prices in seven days.

Most of that is houses: 19 of the 23, with two income properties, one piece of land and one commercial listing making up the rest. We are not going to tell you why, because we did not measure a cause and a week is a week. What we will say is that a standing list where nothing at all is going up is a list where sellers are doing the adjusting.

One house came down $30,100 and its listing says nothing about it

On October 15 this series published the two open houses happening in these four counties that weekend. Both were in Marion. One of them has since been re-listed, and the other has not moved at all — and the pair of them together shows something about how to read a listing.

  • 418 Charlotte Rd was asking $265,000 a week ago, under listing record PA1270512, and that record carried a price-change flag.
  • It is now asking $234,900 — $30,100 less — under a different record, PA1271226, and that record shows as a plain active listing with no price-change flag at all.
  • 11888 Trolley Line Rd, the other one, is still asking $220,000 under the same record it had a week ago, PA1270961.

Read that again, because it is the whole lesson of the last fortnight in one driveway. The house is $30,100 cheaper than it was seven days ago, and the listing a buyer sees today carries no sign of it. The price-change flag belonged to the old record. The days-on-market counter belonged to the old record too, so that has started again from nothing. Neither of those figures is a fact about the house. They are facts about a piece of paperwork, and when the paperwork is replaced they reset while the house stays exactly where it is.

This series measured the first half of that directly three days ago, across 33 Carterville listings over exactly seven days: every one of them advanced its day counter by exactly seven, including the one that cut its price. A price cut does not touch the clock. A new record resets it. Here is a house that just did the second one.

What came on, what came off

25 properties came onto the list and 12 came off, a net gain of 13 — 435 listings a week ago against 448 today.

What is for saleOctober 19October 26Change
Houses248257+9
Land106110+4
Commercial for sale6968-1
Income property89+1
Manufactured, in park22no change
Commercial for lease22no change

Both columns are the same query run seven days apart, and the two query forms were checked against each other the same morning before any of this was differenced.

The turnover is not price-neutral. The 18 houses that arrived ask a median of $249,500; the 9 that left were asking a median of $169,000. Dearer houses joined, cheaper ones went. That alone lifts a median without a single seller changing a price, which is why the house median moved only from $220,000 to $222,500 in a week when 23 listings cut. A median is composition plus price, and this week the two pulled against each other.

Six addresses are on this list twice

Address carrying two separate listing recordsTownAsking
000 N Carbon StMarion$122,500
0000 Halfway RdMarion$2,000,000
1921 Grange Hall RdMarion$1,500,000
2107 W Main StMarion$299,900
2571 S Illinois AveCarbondale$120,000
803 W Hendrickson StMarion$64,000

The same six addresses, two records each, in both pulls. We are not going to guess why; the 10/22 edition found a Marion acreage whose own listing page stated it had more than one record, which is the only explanation we have ever seen stated at source.

They are not double-counted out of the figures above, because they are two real listing records and this post counts records where it says records and properties where it says properties. But if you are counting listings to judge how much is for sale, six of them are one property each.

Two things went wrong with our own method, and both are worth telling you about

This series matches two pulls on the address rather than on the listing id, because a re-listing changes the id and would otherwise read as one house leaving and a different one arriving. The check that the two ways of counting reconcile is what makes that safe. This week it failed, twice, and each failure was a real thing about the data.

  • The street line is not unique. Six addresses carry two records each, so an address cannot be assumed to mean one listing. Adding the town does not fix it, because the duplicates are in the same town.
  • A record can keep its id and change its address. Exactly one did: 705 & 707 Monroe St in Marion is now listed as Tbd S Monroe St under the same record. To a diff that matches on address, that looks like one property leaving and another arriving, while nothing moved at all.

So the reconciliation this series has been using — arrivals by id should equal arrivals by address plus re-listings — is wrong, and it was wrong the last time we used it. It happened to hold on the Carterville comparison three days ago because that town had no doubly-listed addresses and no edited ones. The version that actually holds subtracts the edits, and it now reconciles on both sides: 26 arrivals by record = 26 by address, minus 1 edit, plus 1 re-listing. Same arithmetic on the departures. The two corrections happen to cancel in the record count, which is why it is the property count that moves, and why the old version looked right for as long as it did.

We publish that because it changes a number we gave you. 25 properties arrived, not 26, and the difference is one address that was rewritten rather than one house that came on the market.

And one test we ran before trusting any of it

The two pulls were not taken the same way. Last week’s asked for all four counties in one request; this morning’s asked county by county. A difference of question is not a difference of market, so before differencing anything we ran both forms this morning and compared them. They returned the identical 448 listings — same records, none in one form and missing from the other. That is the only reason the week-over-week figures on this page exist. Had they disagreed, there would be no comparison to publish and we would have said so instead.

One thing we cannot give you as a result: a county-by-county breakdown of the change. Last week’s pull came back as one combined list and does not say which county each record sat in, and we are not going to assign a county to a record from its postal town when the whole point of doing it properly is that those disagree. The totals are four-county; the movement is four-county.

If you are watching one house

Ask what its record history actually says, not what the card shows. A price-change flag is absent from a house that just came down $30,100 this week, somewhere in Marion, and the only way you would know is if somebody looked. That is a five-minute phone call: 618.925.8654.

💬 Greg Holthaus on reading the list

“23 down and none up in a week is the clearest read on a market you are going to get, and it is the kind of thing you only see if you keep last week’s list. The one I would want a buyer to understand is the re-listed house. Same house, $30,100 cheaper, and the listing looks brand new with no history on it. Nobody is hiding anything — that is just what a new record does. But it means the question to ask is never ‘how long has this been up’. It is ‘how long has this house been for sale’. Those are different questions and only one of them is on the screen.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Closed-sale figures come from the published monthly closed-sale series for ten Southern Illinois towns, re-pulled on October 26, 2026, 60 monthly observations per town of three metrics read by label and not by position; all ten returned all three labels with none missing. September 2026 remains the newest closed month in every one of them, so no new closed-sale figure is published here and none is re-presented as news. Listing figures come from two pulls of our own local MLS listing feed, October 19 and October 26, seven days apart, active listings in Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties: 435 records then, 448 now, each pull’s returned rows equal to its own reported total so neither was truncated, all ids distinct. The two pulls were taken with different query forms, so both forms were re-run this morning and returned the identical 448 records before anything was differenced. Matched on street line plus town, not on listing id, and reconciled against the id-level counts in the corrected form that subtracts address edits: 26 = 26 − 1 + 1, and the same on departures. Six addresses carry two listing records each in both pulls and are reported rather than merged. No county breakdown of the week-over-week change is given, because the earlier pull carries no per-record county and we will not infer one from a postal town. Asking prices are not sale prices, and a median is composition as well as price. No cause is offered for any price move and nothing here is a forecast. No property-tax figure, no price per square foot, no interest rate and no payment figure appears on this page. Listings change daily; confirm anything you intend to rely on.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us