Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Market Monday

The Number of Houses for Sale Did Not Move. The Median Rose $7,500 Anyway.

A flat count is the least informative thing we can tell you about a week. Here is what the same four-county list actually did between October 26 and November 2.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 2, 2026

Every Monday we pull the same question twice, a week apart, and report what changed. First, the thing that did not: September is still the newest closed month in all ten towns we track — three Mondays running now with nothing new published. So there is no new closed-sale figure in this post, and we are not going to dress September up as news for a third week.

What did move is the active list. And the headline number on it is a trap.

257
houses for sale, both Mondays
$7,500
the median asking price rose anyway
$82,500
between what came on and what came off
23
of the 24 price moves were cuts

257 houses both Mondays, and a median $7,500 higher

On October 26 our own four-county feed held 257 houses. This morning it holds 257. Not close to the same — the same. And the median asking price went from $222,500 to $230,000, a rise of $7,500. The mean went up as well, from $279,589 to $284,097, a rise of $4,508, which is the only reason we are willing to call it a rise at all: one statistic moving is a result, two moving the same way is a finding.

It is not the same 257 houses. 24 houses came on the list and 24 came off — the same number each way, which is exactly how a count stays flat while the thing it counts turns over.

HousesMedian askingMean askingMedian size
Came on the list24$230,000$256,0001,678 sq ft
Came off the list24$147,500$204,0211,570 sq ft
Difference—$82,500$51,979108 sq ft

Both the median and the mean say the same thing, which is why we are willing to say it. Coming off the list does not mean sold — a listing can go under contract, expire, be withdrawn or be cancelled, and this query asks only for active listings.

There is the whole of it. The houses that arrived ask a median $82,500 more than the houses that left. The mean says the same thing by $51,979. A list that swaps 24 houses at $147,500 for 24 houses at $230,000 will show a higher median next week without one seller changing one number.

And it is not size. The arriving houses have a median of 1,678 square feet against 1,570 for the ones that left — about 7% more house, against 56% more money. Size does not account for a gap that size, and we are not going to tell you what does, because the record does not say and we are not in the business of inventing a reason that reads well.

Where the seven houses went, band by band

Asking priceOctober 26November 2Change
under $100,0004239−3
$100,000 to $199,9997571−4
$200,000 to $299,9995154+3
$300,000 to $499,9996064+4
$500,000 and up2929—

Houses only, and the same query both Mondays. The column totals are 257 and 257 — identical — so every figure in the last column is a house moving between bands or being replaced by a different one, not the list growing or shrinking.

Read the last column. The cheap end lost houses and the middle and upper-middle gained them, seven houses worth, with the top band unchanged. That is the same fact as the table above it, shown a second way: nothing about the list got more expensive, the composition of it changed.

If you are selling at the cheap end, that matters in a practical way. There are 110 houses asking under $200,000 on this list. That is seven houses fewer than last Monday, and the median of the whole list drifting upward does not put a dollar on yours.

23 of the 24 price moves were cuts, and the one that was not is the same listing we saw yesterday

Of the 416 listing records on the board both Mondays, 24 changed asking price. 23 came down and 1 went up. The median reduction is $9,000, running from $2,500 to $50,900. They are not all houses: 15 are, 6 are commercial listings, and the other 3 are a piece of land, an income property and a manufactured home.

The one that went up is 21105 Lori Ln in Pittsburg, from $1,300,000 to $1,325,000. Worth being precise about that, because yesterday’s post reported the same single increase — the seven days to yesterday and the seven days to today overlap by six, so that is one price move seen through two windows, not two increases. Counting the same event twice is the easiest way to invent a trend out of nothing.

Across the whole list, 134 of the 257 houses carry a reduction on the record, 52% of them, at a median of $10,000. We checked the direction of every one against the previous price the record holds. There is not a single increase among them.

The price-change tag catches a first cut and misses a second

This one is worth knowing if you ever read a listing tag as news. 21 of the 416 records on the board both weeks changed their tag. 10 of them newly took the price-change tag, and all 10 really did move in price — so when the tag appears, it means something. The other 11 went from new to active, and not one of those involved a price move at all; that transition is a listing getting older, not a listing changing.

Here is the part that matters. 14 of the 24 price moves happened with no tag change whatsoever, and all 14 of those records were already carrying the price-change tag from an earlier reduction. So the tag marks a first cut and says nothing about a second. If you counted this week by tags you would have found 10 price moves. There were 24.

And three things that make counting this list harder than it looks

We publish the reconciliation rather than a round number, because the round number is wrong in at least three ways.

One: counting by listing record and counting by property give different answers. By record, 29 arrived and 32 departed. By address, 28 arrived and 31 departed. The difference is one property that changed listing record without going anywhere — 907 W White St in Marion, same address, new record. To a record-level count that is a departure and an arrival; on the ground it is a house that never left. The identity that has to hold is record arrivals equals address arrivals, minus any address rewritten in place, plus relistings, and it holds this week at 29 = (28 − 0) + 1, and the same way round on departures.

Two: not one address string was rewritten this week, and that is why a simpler sum also works. Last Monday exactly one record kept its id while its address was rewritten, which broke the shorter form of that identity and is why we changed it. This week there were none, so the shorter form happens to give the right answer — and we are saying so rather than letting a quiet week look like a vindication. A rule that only shows up when it is violated still has to be checked when it is not.

Three: six addresses on this list carry two separate listing records each.

AddressTownListing records
000 N Carbon StMariontwo
0000 Halfway RdMariontwo
1921 Grange Hall RdMariontwo
2107 W Main StMariontwo
2571 S Illinois AveCarbondaletwo
803 W Hendrickson StMariontwo

The same six addresses in both pulls, each pair at the same asking price in the same town. We read these as one property filed twice, which is why this post counts properties by address and reconciles against the record count rather than quoting one of them.

What this post is not saying

Worth being explicit. Nothing here says anything sold. All 445 of these listings are active, a listing coming off this list can have gone under contract or expired or been withdrawn, and an asking price is not a sale price. Nothing here is a forecast — a median that rose on turnover tells you what is listed, not what is coming. Nothing here gives a cause for any price move, including the seven houses that shifted bands. Nothing here involves the age of a house, because this feed carries no year built at all. There is no price per square foot and no property-tax figure anywhere on this page, and no interest rate or payment figure either. And no closed-sale figure is updated, because none has published.

If you are listing in the next few weeks

Two things from this week are worth carrying into that conversation. The first is that the median on the whole list is a description of what is for sale, and it moved this week without any seller doing anything — so it is a poor place to start pricing. The second is that more than half the houses on the board are already asking less than they first did, and the tag that tells you so undercounts it. The list of houses competing with yours at your size and in your band is the number that matters, and it is a number somebody has to go and build for you. The number is 618.925.8654, or ask any of our brokers.

💬 Greg Holthaus on a flat count

“257 houses one week and 257 the next looks like nothing happened. 24 houses came on and the same number came off. The ones that came on ask a median $82,500 more than the ones that left, and that is the whole of why the median moved — nobody raised a price, and 23 of the 24 moves on the board were cuts. What I would take from it is narrow: the median of a list is not a number about your house. The number about your house is what else a buyer can see at your size in your band this week, and that one is worth building properly rather than reading off a headline.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Closed-sale figures come from the published monthly series for ten towns in these four counties, re-pulled on the morning of November 2, 2026: 60 monthly observations per town of three metrics, read by metric label rather than by position so a reordering upstream shows up as a missing figure instead of a transposed one. All ten towns returned all three labels. September 2026 is the newest closed month in every one of them, so no closed-sale figure in this post is new and none is quoted as such. Active-listing figures come from two pulls of our own local MLS listing feed, October 26 and November 2, seven days apart: one request per county for Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union, active listings only, 448 records then 445, each county’s returned row count equal to its own reported total so neither was truncated, all ids distinct, every address in Illinois. Before anything was compared, the query the feed echoed back was checked for equality county by county across the two pulls — same chip, same filters, same limit — because a difference of question is not a difference of market. The week-over-week figures are computed over the 416 records present in both pulls, not over either pull as a whole. Arrivals and departures are matched on street line plus town, not on listing record, and the two counts are reconciled against each other and published above. Six addresses carry two listing records each, the same six addresses in both pulls, and are named above. One property changed listing record while staying on the list, and no address string was rewritten in place this week. Of the 257 houses, all 257 carry an asking price, a bedroom count, a bathroom count and a floor area, so no house figure here has a missing-data hole in it. The direction of every comparison in this post was checked against a second statistic — the median and the mean both rise on the list and both rise on the arrivals, and nothing is published where they disagree. A listing leaving this query is not a sale; it can have gone under contract, expired, been withdrawn or been cancelled, and nothing here is described as sold. This feed carries no year-built field, so no claim about the age of anything is made; no price per square foot is computed anywhere, no property-tax figure appears, and there is no interest rate or payment figure on this page. Asking prices are not sale prices, no cause is given for any price move, and nothing here forecasts whether prices will rise or fall. Listings change daily; confirm anything you intend to rely on.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us