Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Market Monday

The Town Does Not Tell You Who Has Cut Their Price. The Price Tag Does.

201 of the 447 active listings in Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties are asking less today than they were asking before. This post takes the obvious next question — which towns, and which price ranges — and finds that only one of those two questions has an answer.

201
listings asking less than they were
56%
of houses have cut their price
0.2
points between the biggest towns and the rest
4.2×
bigger cuts on the dearest houses

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 9, 2026 · Market Monday

Of the 447 active listings in Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties this morning, 201 are asking less than they were asking at some point before. Among houses specifically, 136 of 244 have come down. The typical reduction on a house is $10,000, which is the same typical reduction this series reported a week ago and the week before that; it has not moved, and that is the last this post will say about it.

What has not been published is where the cutting is, and whether it depends on what a house costs. Both questions were put to the same 244 houses. Only one of them came back with an answer.

The cutting is not somewhere in particular. It is everywhere.

Sort the 29 towns with a house for sale into the 8 that have 8 or more houses and the 21 that have fewer. The big 8 hold 190 houses between them, and 55.8% of those have cut. The remaining 21 towns hold 54 houses, and 55.6% of those have cut. The difference between the two is 0.2 of a percentage point.

That is a smaller difference than a single listing can make. With only 54 houses on the smaller side, one of them changing its mind moves that figure by 1.9 points, which is itself far wider than the gap between the two sides. Moving the dividing line does not help either: the same comparison run at town-size cutoffs of 5, 10, 12 and 15 houses produces gaps of 2.7, 0.2, 0.2 and 1.9 points. The widest answer any version of the question gives is 2.7 points.

This is the third time the series has run that test and the third time it has come back flat. Whatever is making sellers lower their asking prices is not a local condition. It is not the big towns dragging an average around, and it is not a handful of soft spots. It is the whole four-county market doing roughly the same thing at roughly the same rate.

What the price tag changes is how big the cut is

The other question does have an answer. Line the 244 houses up by what they are asking today and split them into the six groups in the table below — forty-odd houses each, with the boundaries taken from the prices themselves rather than from round numbers. The typical cut in dollars rises at every single step.

Asking priceHousesHave cutTypical cutAs share of asking
$8,000 — $99,0004124 (59%)$6,0008.3%
$99,999 — $149,9004224 (57%)$6,8505.9%
$150,000 — $230,0004220 (48%)$10,0004.6%
$234,900 — $330,0004323 (53%)$11,5004.1%
$334,900 — $465,0004224 (57%)$14,4503.2%
$469,900 — $1,776,5003421 (62%)$25,0004.3%

Groups of roughly equal size, boundaries read from the prices themselves. Houses asking the same price are never split between the two groups either side of a boundary.

From $6,000 in the cheapest group to $25,000 in the dearest is a factor of 4.2×. As a share of what is being asked, though, the direction reverses for most of the range: 8.3% at the bottom falling to 3.2% in the second-dearest group. The cheapest houses cut the fewest dollars and the largest share; the dear ones cut the most dollars and a smaller share.

It does not run all the way, and the exception is worth naming rather than smoothing over. The dearest group ticks back up to 4.3% of asking, so the share does not simply fall with price — it falls across five of the six groups and then turns. The dollars do rise all the way, and the two ends of the table are 4.2× apart in money and 1.9× apart in share. Both of those survive losing their largest single reduction. Take the biggest cut out of the dearest group and its typical cut does not budge at all — still $25,000, because a median does not care how large the biggest figure in the set is. Take the biggest out of the cheapest group and it still gives up 8.0% of its asking price.

Which column a seller should care about depends on which side of the table they are on. A reduction of $6,000 on a house in the cheapest group is a bigger concession than $25,000 on a house in the dearest one, even though it is far less money.

Two rankings this post is not going to give you

The first is by price band, and it was discarded after being tested. An earlier cut of this analysis used round bands — under $100,000, the $100,000s, the $150,000s and so on — and found that houses in the $150,000s were much the least likely to have cut, 38.5% against 59.5% among the cheapest houses. That looked like something. Then the whole grid was slid up by $20,000, which left the same houses in differently-labelled boxes, and the same band read 52.0%. Across five positions of the grid it ran from 35.5% to 52.0% — a spread of 16.5 points produced by nothing but where the lines were drawn. A finding that moves that much when you move the boundaries is a fact about the boundaries. It is not in this post, and that is why the table above uses groups of equal size instead.

The second is by town, and it is worth being more specific about, because a table of towns ranked by price cuts is the single easiest thing to publish about a local market and it is almost always meaningless. Here are the 8 towns with enough houses on the market to say anything at all about.

TownHouses for saleHave cutTypical cutAs share of askingTypical asking price
Marion7134 (48%)$12,5004.0%$279,900
Carterville2215 (68%)$14,0004.3%$312,500
Carbondale2014 (70%)$10,0004.3%$314,950
West Frankfort1811 (61%)$10,0006.7%$105,000
Herrin1711 (65%)$10,0008.0%$140,000
Anna178 (47%)$9,1005.1%$235,000
Murphysboro139 (69%)$9,0004.3%$206,900
Johnston City124 (33%)too few to say—$129,950
All other 21 towns5430 (56%)———

Towns with at least eight houses for sale. A typical cut is held back where a town has fewer than eight reductions to average, which is the case in one of these rows.

Read down the third column and there is a 36.7-point spread, from 33% to 70%. It is tempting, and it would be wrong. Most of these towns have between 12 and 22 houses on the market, and at those counts a spread like that is what randomness looks like.

Here is the test. Take the 136 houses that have cut and the 108 that have not, shuffle which is which at random across all 244 houses while keeping each town’s number of houses exactly as it is, and measure the spread between the highest and lowest town. Do it 20,000 times. The typical shuffle produces a spread of 32.8 points, and more than a third of them reach or exceed the 36.7 points in the real table. A pattern that pure chance reproduces a third of the time is not a pattern. The town at the top of that column is not cutting harder than the town at the bottom in any sense that would survive next week’s listings.

The arithmetic underneath that is ordinary. Johnston City has twelve houses for sale, so each one is worth 8.3 points of that percentage. If two of them change their minds, the row swings by more than 16.7 points. The table is here because the counts are worth knowing and because somebody should publish the honest version. The order is not worth knowing.

One line on closed sales

The published monthly closed-sale series for the ten towns this blog tracks has not moved again: September is still the newest closed month published for every one of them, which makes this the fourth Monday in a row with nothing new to report there. Nothing above is a closed-sale figure. Everything above is an asking price.

What this does not tell you

It does not tell you prices are falling. A reduction in an asking price is a seller changing a number they chose; whether houses here are worth more or less than they were is a question about sales, and this is not sales data. It does not say why anybody cut — the records carry the old price and the new one, not the reason, and the difference between a correction and a strategy is not in there. It does not forecast anything. And it describes one morning: a listing can change its price or come off the market this afternoon.

Common questions

Are price cuts concentrated in certain Southern Illinois towns?

Not in any way this morning’s listings can show. The 8 towns with 8 or more houses for sale hold 190 of the 244 houses, and 55.8% of them have cut. The other 21 towns hold 54 houses, and 55.6% of those have cut. That is a gap of 0.2 of a percentage point, and a single listing on the smaller side is worth 1.9 points, so the two numbers are the same number.

Which price range has cut the most?

In dollars, the dearest houses, consistently. Splitting the 244 houses into the six groups above, each of roughly equal size, the typical cut climbs at every step, from $6,000 in the cheapest group to $25,000 in the dearest. Measured as a share of what is being asked it runs the other way for most of the range, from 8.3% down to 3.2%, before ticking back up to 4.3% at the very top.

Does this mean house prices in Southern Illinois are falling?

No, and nothing here can show that. Every figure on this page is an asking price, and a cut to an asking price is a decision somebody made about a listing. It is not a sale, not an appraisal and not a value. The numbers describe how sellers are pricing, not what buyers are paying.

Why does this post refuse to rank the towns?

Because the ranking was tested and did not survive. The 8 named towns run from 33% to 70%, a spread of 36.7 points. Shuffling which houses had cut at random across all 244 of them, 20,000 times over and keeping each town’s count of houses fixed, produces a typical spread of 32.8 points, and more than a third of those shuffles reach the 36.7 points actually observed. A table that chance reproduces is not a finding about towns.

How many houses does a town need before you will name it?

Eight. Below that a single listing moves the percentage too far to mean anything, and even at the gate it moves it a long way: the smallest town named here has twelve houses for sale, so one of them changing its price moves that row by 8.3 points. A median cut is held back entirely below eight cuts, which is why one row in the table above has no figure in that column.

💬 Greg Holthaus on reading a table like this

“The number that matters to a seller is not whether other people are cutting. It is what their own house is competing with at their own price. The six groups in that first table are closer to a useful question than the town list is, because a buyer with a budget shops a price range, not a town line. If a house sits in a group where the typical reduction is $25,000 and it has not moved, that is worth knowing before the next showing, not after. And if somebody tells you your town is the one that is cutting, ask them how many houses they counted.”

Want to know what your own price range looks like? Call or text 618.925.8654 and ask for the listings at your size and price, not just in your town.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

Where these numbers come from

Everything above was read this morning, November 9, 2026, from our own live listing data for Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties — 447 active listings, of which 244 are houses. Each county’s returned listings were checked against that county’s own reported total, so no county came back truncated, and every listing was checked to be counted once and in one county only.

The reductions come from a field on each listing’s own record that carries the previous asking price. It is present on exactly the 201 listings tagged as having changed price and on no others, and every one of them is a reduction — no listing in these four counties raised its price. That cross-check is what makes the field safe to count. No individual listing, address or seller is named anywhere on this page.

The price groups are of roughly equal size, with their boundaries taken from the prices themselves rather than from round numbers, and houses asking the same price are never split across the two groups either side of a boundary. The reason for that is in the body of the post: round-number bands gave an answer that moved when the round numbers moved.

The closed-sale figures referred to in passing are from the published monthly closed-sale series for ten local towns, re-read this morning, 60 monthly readings for each town, with each measure identified by its own label rather than by its position in the file. September is still the newest closed month published for all ten towns, so no closed-sale figure is reported here as news.

About these figures: every number above comes from local MLS listing data read on the morning of November 9, 2026. A reduction is a change in an asking price, not a sale and not a valuation — a cut tells you what a seller is asking today, and a change in an asking price, not a sale, is the whole of what this page measures. Nothing here is described as sold, pending or contingent, because nothing we read says it is. No individual listing is named, and no address, seller or record identifier appears anywhere on this page. Nothing on this page is a loan offer, a rate quote or any statement about financing: no interest rate, no monthly payment and no lender appears in it, and it makes no claim about what anybody can borrow. It names no broker other than Greg, and no other brokerage. Figures describe active listings on the morning they were read; a listing can change its price or leave the market the same afternoon. Source note: figures on this page include local MLS data as published by Redfin (redfin.com).

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us