Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Market Monday

Seventy-Six Reductions, One Increase, Twenty-Three Days. And Twelve the Count Cannot See.

Eleven readings, 23 days, every listing matched to itself: 76 reductions against one increase. The interesting part is what that method cannot count, and we can show you exactly what it missed.

76
price reductions in 23 days
1
increase in the same period
12
increases this count cannot see
452
active listings this morning

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 16, 2026 · Market Monday

We keep every reading of our own listing data. There are now eleven of them covering Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union counties, from 10/24 to this morning — 23 days. Lining each one up against the reading before it, matching every listing to itself by its record identifier rather than by address, gives a tally nobody in this series has put in one place before.

76 price reductions. One increase. That is the whole of it, across ten consecutive comparisons.

That figure is striking, and the rest of this post is about why it is not a statement about this market — because we can show you twelve increases from our own pages that it does not contain.

Every reading against the one before it

FromToListings in bothPrices that movedReductionsIncreases
10/2410/2544711none
10/2510/3142422211
10/3111/0144822none
11/0111/02442nonenonenone
11/0211/074202121none
11/0711/0844433none
11/0811/0944355none
11/0911/144301818none
11/1411/1545333none
11/1511/1644922none
Total77761

Each row compares two readings of the same four county queries. A listing is only counted where it appears in both, which is the limitation this post is about. The gaps between readings are uneven because these are the readings this series happened to take, not a schedule.

The one increase is a single listing moving from $1,300,000 to $1,325,000, somewhere in these four counties, between the 10/25 and 10/31 readings. We are not naming it or its town. One listing at that price in a small place is identifiable from those two figures alone, and what one listing did with one number is not what this post is about.

What the count cannot see, and we can prove it

On November 13 this series published a Carterville post about twelve vacant lots on two streets. The Carterville town query had all twelve of them at $34,000 each on November 6, and the same twelve record identifiers at $36,000 and $38,000 a week later. Twelve genuine increases, measured the same way as everything else in this series: a listing compared with itself.

Not one of them appears in the tally above. Here is exactly why, and it is a fact about our readings rather than a theory:

ReadingCarterville rows it holdsOf those, the 12 lots
November 2 county reading37none
November 7 county reading4712, already at the higher prices
November 6 Carterville town query1212, all at $34,000

The county reading on November 2 returns 37 Carterville listings and not one of them is one of these lots. By November 7 all twelve are there and already carry the higher figures.

So in the four-county series the twelve are arrivals, and an arrival has no previous price to be compared with. The increase happened in the gap between two readings of a query that did not yet contain them. The method did not get it wrong. The method cannot see it.

And here is the part we cannot settle. There is no November 6 county reading. The town query saw the twelve at $34,000 that day; the county query had not returned them four days earlier. Whether they were listed in between, or whether the county query simply did not hand them over on November 2, we do not know, and we are not going to pick whichever answer reads better.

Which makes a correction to two of our own posts

Two editions of this series, drafted on 11/08 and 11/09, said that every price move in these four counties was a reduction and that no listing had raised its price. Read as a statement about the field in the data, that was accurate. Read as a statement about the market, it was not.

The honest version is the one this post has just measured: among listings present in consecutive readings, 76 reductions to one increase — and at least twelve real increases in the same period that this method does not contain. Neither of those two editions is published, and both will carry the narrower wording. We are writing it down here because the next person to use a tally like the one above should know what it counts.

And the week, which was all one direction again

Between the November 9 reading and this one, 23 asking prices changed and every one came down — $5,000 at the smallest, $125,000 at the largest, a median of $10,000 and $543,099 in all. They are spread across 10 towns, not bunched in one, which is worth saying because a figure like that can easily be one development repricing itself.

The list itself barely changed size. 28 listings arrived and 23 listings left, and 424 were on both readings. The departures come to the same figure as the reductions, and it is a different 23: a listing that left cannot also have moved, because a move needs the listing in both readings. What arrived asks more than what left: a median of $195,000 against $169,900, a gap of $25,100. We are not saying what became of the 23 that left — a listing leaving an active search is not a sale, and we did not look up their statuses.

Of the 452 active listings this morning, 249 are houses, and the middle one asks $230,000 against $228,450 a week ago. 207 listings of every kind carry a price-change record, and every one of those is a reduction too.

What this does not tell you

It does not tell you that asking prices in Southern Illinois only go down. It tells you that the listings we can follow from one reading to the next almost always go down, and the twelve lots are the proof that those are not the same statement.

It does not tell you when any reduction happened, beyond the gap between two readings. The record carries a date and this series has watched twelve records in this feed run their own dates backwards, so we do not use them.

It does not tell you why any price moved. No record we read carries a reason, an office field or an agent field.

It does not tell you that anything sold. Every figure here is an asking price, and nothing on this page is described as sold, pending or contingent.

It does not tell you what any property is worth, and no forecast appears on this page: nothing above says any price will move.

And 23 days is 23 days. It is not a season and it is not a trend.

💬 Greg Holthaus on counting what you can follow

“The number in the headline is real and I want people to see the second half of it too. There were 76 reductions and one increase, across four counties and 23 days — and then twelve lots that went up where the count could not reach them. If you only ever count what stayed still long enough to be counted, you will think the market only moves one way. That is the part most price-reduction lists never tell you, including the ones built from our own data. Ask us what the number counts before you lean on it.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker

Common questions

Are asking prices around here going down?

The listings we can follow are. Across 11 readings of our own listing data over 23 days, matching every listing to itself, there were 76 price reductions and one increase. But that is a statement about listings that sat still long enough to be compared. In the same period twelve lots in Carterville went up, from $34,000 to $36,000 and $38,000, and the count above does not contain any of them.

Why does the count miss those twelve increases?

Because a price move can only be counted where the same listing appears in two readings. The November 2 county reading holds 37 Carterville listings and not one of them is one of these lots; the November 7 reading holds all twelve of them, already at the higher prices. So in this series they are arrivals, and an arrival has no previous price. The increase fell into the gap between two readings of a query that did not yet return them.

Did the lots really go up, or is that a data error?

They went up, and it was measured twice. The Carterville town query returned the same twelve record identifiers on November 6 at $34,000 each and on November 13 at $36,000 and $38,000. The November 13 post went further and found the same figures in three other readings taken for other posts. What nobody can tell you from these records is why they moved, and that post did not claim to.

How many prices changed this week?

23, and every one of them came down — between $5,000 and $125,000, a median reduction of $10,000, $543,099 in all. They are spread across 10 towns rather than bunched in one. Separately, 28 listings arrived and 23 left, so the list is 452 this morning against 447 a week ago.

Is an asking price the same as what a house is worth?

No. An asking price is not a sale, not an appraisal and not a value — it is what somebody is asking today, and every figure on this page is one of those. Nothing here can show you what a property would sell for, and nothing here tries to.

Does a price reduction mean the house was overpriced?

This post does not say so and the records do not either. We measure that a number changed, not why it changed — there is no reason field, no office field and no agent field in anything we read. A reduction can follow a quiet fortnight, a survey, a change of plan, or a seller who simply decided differently. None of that is in the data.

Should I wait for a price to come down?

Nothing on this page answers that, deliberately. No forecast appears above: not one sentence says any price will move. What the data supports is narrower and more useful — the figure in front of you may already be a reduced one, and a broker can tell you off this morning’s reading whether it is and by how much. Text 618.925.8654 and ask.

Want to know whether the price in front of you has already come down, and by how much? Send a broker the address and you will get the figure off this morning’s data rather than last month’s. Find your broker › or text 618.925.8654.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About these figures: Everything above comes from local MLS listing data read with the same four county queries throughout — Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union, status set to active, one request per county, read this morning. This morning’s reading holds 267 in Williamson, 64 in Jackson, 74 in Franklin, 47 in Union, 452 in all, of which 249 are houses. Each county’s returned count equals its own reported total, all 452 identifiers are distinct and none appears in more than one county, and every reading echoes a byte-identical query; the queries are loaded out of the stored earlier responses rather than retyped, because a retyped query once came back with zero results and no error at all. This morning’s reading was run two times and returned the identical set of listings both times. The tally walks eleven named readings, 2026-10-24 to 2026-11-16, each against the one before it; the list of readings is written out in the derivation rather than discovered, so the published figure is the figure that was checked. Listings are matched one to one on a stable record identifier, never on the address text, and a price move is counted only where the same identifier carries a price in both readings. The week’s 23 moves were counted twice over — once by comparing November 9 directly with November 16 and once by adding up the readings in between — and the two agree, which they can only do if no listing changed price more than once in the week. No reduction is attributed to a date: the records carry one and this series has watched twelve records in this feed run their own dates backwards. No individual listing, address or seller is named and no address appears anywhere above, and the single increase is reported without its town, because one listing at that price in a small place would be identifiable from the two figures alone. The twelve Carterville lots are described as lots on two streets and are not individually named here. Nothing on this page is a loan offer, a rate quote or any statement about financing: no interest rate, no monthly payment and no lender appears in it, and no pre-qualification figure either; and no percentage appears anywhere above — every figure is a count or an amount of money. No days-on-market figure, no property-tax figure and no price per square foot appears: the records this post reads carry none of those, and no office field and no agent field either, so nothing about who lists these properties is stated or inferred. Prices are asking prices, not sale prices, and nothing here is described as sold, pending or contingent — the 23 listings that left the active list are reported as having left it and nothing more. A reduction is a change in an asking price, not a sale and not a valuation. No county and no town is ranked against another: the order is not worth knowing and none is given. No broker other than Greg, and no other brokerage, is named. No forecast appears: nothing above says any price will move.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us