Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Neighborhood Thursday — Herrin, October 29, 2026

In Herrin, 12 of 20 Houses Wear a Price-Change Tag, and Only Three Are Recent

A price-change label looks like a sale sign. In Herrin it mostly is not one: the labels run back as far as February, and the feed never says which way the price went.

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · October 29, 2026

Herrin sits in the middle of Williamson County, between Marion and Carterville, with a historic downtown on Park Avenue and a lot of affordable, older housing. It is one of the places buyers ask about when Marion and Carbondale are out of their range. This week we read every Herrin listing in our local MLS feed, and one thing jumped off the page: more than half the houses carry a price-change label.

The feed holds 38 Herrin listings today. Twenty are houses, and twelve of those twenty carry a “Price Change” label. But only three of the twelve have a label date in the last six weeks. The rest are older, and four of them date back more than three months.

20
Houses for sale in Herrin
$140,000
Median house asking price
12
Houses with a price-change label
3
Label dates in the last six weeks

What the Label Does and Does Not Tell You

The label dates for the twelve houses run from February 1 to October 2. Three are newer than six weeks old (September 21, September 25 and October 2). Five fall between August and mid-September. Four are older than ninety days: June 30, March 26, February 3 and February 1.

That matters because a price-change label does not show the direction of the change. It does not say whether the price came down or went up, and it does not say by how much. A label from February sitting on a house in late October is a record that something changed once, not a house that is dropping its price now. If you are hoping to negotiate, ask the listing broker for the full price history. It takes them a minute to pull.

Is Herrin Unusual? Not Really

We checked the same label in neighboring towns in the same feed today. In Marion, 35 of 74 houses carry it. In Carterville it is 16 of 24, in Carbondale 12 of 20, and in West Frankfort 8 of 20. Herrin’s 12 of 20 is in the same range as its neighbors, so the tag is a feature of how listings are recorded, not a sign that Herrin sellers are panicking.

Herrin Houses, by Asking Price

Williamson County · Herrin · houses in the feed
Under $100,0004 houses (3 labeled)
$100,000 – $199,9998 houses (5 labeled)
$200,000 – $299,9996 houses (3 labeled)
$300,000 and up2 houses (1 labeled)
Median ask, labeled houses$139,950
Median ask, the other eight$212,000
How to read it: the labeled houses skew toward the lower end, which is where Herrin’s inventory is thickest. Twelve of the twenty houses ask under $200,000.

What $140,000 Buys, and Where Herrin Sits

The median asking price for a Herrin house in today’s feed is $140,000, and the median size is 1,483 square feet. Asking prices run from $22,000 to $424,000. For comparison, the same feed shows a median ask of $295,500 for Marion houses, $271,500 for Carterville and $124,999 for West Frankfort. Herrin is the affordable end of Williamson County, but it is not the cheapest town in the region.

Two houses are flagged new construction, asking $179,000 and $279,900. Those are the only newly built houses in town right now.

Downtown Herrin Is Where the Commercial Listings Are

Besides the houses, Herrin’s feed has eight commercial buildings for sale, and all eight are on Park Avenue or Park Street. They ask $99,000 to $1,400,000, with a median of $259,000. Two of the eight carry a price-change label. There are also six vacant land listings, asking $8,500 to $435,000, and two income properties. Commercial and income properties are a different kind of purchase from a house, so talk to a broker before you compare them.

Questions to Ask Before You Make an Offer in Herrin

Ask for the price history. If a listing carries a price-change label, the history will show you whether the price rose or fell, and when.

Ask about age and systems. Herrin has plenty of older houses, and we did not pull year built, roof, furnace or plumbing for this post. At these prices, a thorough inspection is worth the cost.

Ask about taxes. We did not pull property taxes either. Ask for the recorded tax bill before you build a payment around a number.

Ask how long it has been listed. The feed we used does not publish days on the market, so we are not making a claim about pace.

Herrin FAQ

How many houses are for sale in Herrin right now?
In SIRE’s local MLS feed on October 29, 2026, Herrin has 20 houses for sale, with a median asking price of $140,000 and a range of $22,000 to $424,000. Twelve ask less than $200,000.
What does a price-change label mean on a Herrin listing?
It means the listing record shows a price change. The feed does not say whether the price went up or down, by how much, or when beyond a label date. In Herrin, only three of the twelve labeled houses carry a label date in the last six weeks.
What do houses cost in Herrin?
The median asking price for Herrin houses in the feed is $140,000. Marion’s median in the same feed is $295,500, Carterville’s is $271,500 and West Frankfort’s is $124,999.
Is downtown Herrin commercial property for sale?
Yes. Eight commercial buildings are for sale in Herrin and all eight are on Park Avenue or Park Street, asking $99,000 to $1,400,000.
Does SIRE sell homes in Herrin?
Yes. Our Herrin office is at 121 N. 13th St, and SIRE brokers work across Williamson County and Southern Illinois.
Jarod Sanders, CrossCountry Mortgage

💰 Buying a House in Herrin?

Before you fall for a price, get a real pre-qualification number first.Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage · NMLS #2337228 · Not a loan offer, rate quote, or commitment to lend. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Get Pre-Qualified →

🏠 Want a Broker Watching Herrin for You?

Tell us what you are looking for, and a SIRE broker will watch for new Herrin listings and answer your questions.

Herrin Homes

📱 Got a Question About Herrin? Text Greg.

Buying, selling, or comparing Herrin to Marion or Carterville? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He'll help you think it through and match you with the right broker.

Text Greg · 618.925.8654
Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About the numbers: Counts, asking prices, bedrooms, square footage and label dates come from the 38 Herrin listings in SIRE’s local MLS feed on October 29, 2026: 20 houses, 6 vacant land listings, 8 commercial buildings for sale, 1 commercial lease, 2 residential income properties and 1 manufactured home. Neighboring-town label counts use the houses in the same feed under each town name. A price-change label does not show the direction, amount or date of the price change, and we have not read the label date as the date of a price cut. Days on the market, year built, property taxes and water and sewer details were not pulled for this post. Thirty-eight listings is a small set and changes daily. No single listing is featured in this post. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us