Four new listings came on under the Southern Illinois Realty Experts sign in the past week: two in Marion, one in Carterville and one in DeSoto. All four are three-bedroom houses. That is about where the similarity ends, so here are the numbers side by side, and then a word on what a listing sheet cannot tell you.
Marion: Two Houses, Same Size
1804 N Holmes Drive — $215,000
| Asking price | $215,000 |
| Bedrooms / baths | 3 / 2 |
| Living area | 1,561 sq ft |
| Asking per square foot | about $138 |
| Garage | Attached, 2-car |
The listing leans on the location: a dead-end street means less through traffic, and the yards are described as spacious front and back. It has a covered front entry, an arched front window and an attached two-car garage.
2208 Jennifer Lane — $227,500
| Asking price | $227,500 |
| Bedrooms / baths | 3 / 2 |
| Living area | 1,560 sq ft |
| Asking per square foot | about $146 |
| Garage | Attached, 2-car, with storage room |
These two are the cleanest comparison in the batch. Holmes is 1,561 square feet and Jennifer is 1,560. The difference in asking price is $12,500, which works out to about $8 more per square foot for Jennifer. What would explain it? The listing for Jennifer mentions an updated kitchen, new flooring and a storage room off the garage. The Holmes listing talks about the street and the yards. Neither listing tells us the age of the roof, the furnace or the water heater, and that is where I would start asking before deciding that either price is high or low.
Carterville: The Lowest Price Per Foot
703 Mulberry Street — $152,000
| Asking price | $152,000 |
| Bedrooms / baths | 3 / 3 |
| Living area | 1,864 sq ft |
| Lot | 0.19 acre |
| Asking per square foot | about $82 |
At about $82 a square foot, this is the lowest of the four by a wide margin, and it is also the largest house at 1,864 square feet. The description lists a new roof, new plumbing and drywall, quartz counters, a large deck, a new privacy fence and a large outbuilding. Those are significant items if they are as described, and a good reason to ask for the permits and the invoices for the plumbing and roof work. A renovation is only as good as the work behind the walls, so book a home inspection and do not skip it on a remodeled house.
DeSoto: An Acre and a 2012 Build
37 Lavern Road — $250,000
| Asking price | $250,000 |
| Bedrooms / baths | 3 / 2 |
| Living area | 1,506 sq ft |
| Lot | 1 acre |
| Asking per square foot | about $166 |
This is the highest asking price and the smallest house of the four, which is why its per-foot figure is the highest. The reason is the acre. You are paying for land and quiet, and the listing describes the location as minutes from DeSoto, Carbondale and Carterville. If you plan to keep a garden, a few animals or a shop, an acre is hard to find inside a town. If you do not want to mow it, it is a lot of grass. Whether the district lines suit your family is worth confirming for the specific address, and our DeSoto page is a place to start.
How to Read a Per-Foot Number
The spread here runs from about $82 to about $166 a square foot, and it is tempting to read that as cheap versus expensive. Do not. Per-foot figures ignore land, age, condition and location. The DeSoto house costs the most per foot because of its acre. The Carterville house costs the least because it is large for its price. The two Marion houses sit in the middle and close together. The number is a way to compare, not a verdict on value.
Asking price is also not the sale price. It is where the seller starts, and what a house actually closes for depends on its condition and on what buyers are doing that month. We have not looked at how long these four will sit, and nothing here predicts it.
Search All Southern Illinois Listings
🏠 Want the Next Batch First?
Tell us your range and what matters most — price, condition, land, schools, or a lot to build on — and a SIRE broker will call you the day something new fits. You will hear about it before it hits the next post.
📱 Want to See One of These? Text Greg.
Want a private showing on one of this week's new listings? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him which address. He'll help you think through your decision, match you with the best broker for your situation, and point you in the right direction. He's open to a text any time.
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About the numbers: Asking price, bedrooms, bathrooms, square footage and lot size for 1804 N Holmes Drive, 2208 Jennifer Lane, 703 Mulberry Street and 37 Lavern Road come from the active listing data for those properties, retrieved October 16, 2026. Descriptions of features come from each listing's own remarks. Per-square-foot figures are calculated from asking price and published living area and rounded to the nearest dollar. Year built is stated only where the listing gives it. All four properties are listed by Southern Illinois Realty Experts. Asking prices are what sellers hope to get, not what homes close for. Any property described here can go under contract, sell, or change price at any time. Nothing here is a loan offer or rate quote.
