Marion · Herrin · Carbondale, IL |618.925.8671|info@sirealtyexperts.com
HomeHome ValuationCommercialLots & LandMultifamilyBuyersSellersFinancingOur TeamBlogVideosAbout UsContact Us
Home › Blog › Getting Pre-Qualified

Every House Price That Moved Here This Week Went Down. The Middle of the List Went Up.

All 24 house prices that moved across four counties this week moved down, $389,400 of reductions — and the middle of the list went up anyway. Here is the arithmetic, and what it means for the ceiling in a pre-qualification letter.

228
houses on both readings
24
changed price, every one downward
$389,400
of reductions in seven days
$1,550
the median still rose

By Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker · November 14, 2026 · Getting Pre-Qualified

A pre-qualification ends in a ceiling, and then you go looking at what sits under it. The natural assumption — ours too, until this morning — is that price cuts are what bring houses down under a ceiling, so a buyer watching for reductions is watching the right thing. We measured that across four counties this week, and reductions turn out to move the list under a ceiling hardly at all.

Two readings of our own listing data, seven days apart. 228 houses appear on both. 24 of them changed their asking price, and every single one came down — $389,400 of reductions, a median reduction of $10,000. Not one house asked more this week than last.

And the median asking price of the house list went up $1,550, from $228,450 to $230,000. Both of those sentences are true at the same time, and the gap between them is the whole post.

Running the week again, one force at a time

There are only two reasons a median can move between readings. Houses on both readings can change price, or the set of houses can change. So we ran the week twice, with one of those switched off each time.

The week as we ran itWhat the median does
Last week, as it stood$228,450
Only the reductions applied — nobody arrives, nobody leaves$226,200, down $2,250
Only the arrivals and departures — nobody reduces anything$230,000, up $1,550
This week, as it actually is$230,000, up $1,550

The reductions-only version holds last week’s 248 houses and the churn-only version holds this week’s 249, each one an identified listing rather than an estimate. The bottom two rows are the same figure, and that is the finding rather than a mistake — the churn-only version does not come close to what we observe, it reproduces it.

So the reductions pull the middle of the list down $2,250. The arrivals and departures pull it up $1,550 — exactly the move we see. Composition accounts for the rise, all of it, and the reductions are a real force pulling the other way and losing.

One thing that median is not: a statement about what houses are worth. It is the middle asking price of the houses on a list, and the list changed. Nobody’s house became $1,550 more valuable this week.

What a ceiling reaches, and what moved it

A pre-qualification ceiling is a line through that list. Count the houses at or below it and the change over a week breaks into exactly three pieces: houses on both readings that crossed the line by reducing, houses that arrived under it, and houses that left from under it. That is not a model of the change. The three pieces add up to it exactly, and the derivation refuses to run if they do not.

CeilingHouses at or below, November 7TodayChangeFrom reductionsArrived underLeft from under
$100,0004341−2none+1−3
$150,0008585none+1+6−7
$200,000113109−4none+11−15
$250,000139139none+1+14−15
$300,000159161+2+2+16−16
$400,000194195+1+1+17−17

The last three columns sum to the Change column on every row. Reductions are the smallest of the three forces on every row of this table, and at two of these ceilings they did nothing at all. No ceiling here is a recommendation, and these are asking prices rather than sale prices.

Take the $200,000 line. A week ago 113 houses sat at or below it; today 109 do, so the list of houses a $200,000 ceiling reaches got 4 houses shorter in a week in which 24 houses cut their prices. The reductions moved that line by nothing at all. 11 houses arrived under it and 15 left from under it, and that is the entire story of the change.

And it is not an artifact of round numbers

Every ceiling in that table is a round number, and round numbers are exactly where a finding like this can be an accident of where the lines happen to fall. So we slid the grid. Every line from $100,000 to $400,000 in $5,000 steps — 61 lines — was decomposed the same way.

Across all 61 of them, the reductions never moved a line by more than two houses, and on average they moved it by well under one. The arrivals and departures together swung lines by as much as five houses in one direction. Turnover was the larger of the two forces at 41 of the 61 lines. The table above is not a lucky choice of ceilings.

The near-zero is exactly what the arithmetic predicts

It would be easy to present that as a surprise, and it is not one. A reduction changes the count under your ceiling only if your ceiling happens to fall between the old price and the new one. Picture any house you like dropping from $240,000 to $230,000: it crosses nothing at a $200,000 line, because it was above that line before and it is above it after. Those two figures are an illustration, not a listing.

So ask what this many reductions should do. Spread evenly from $100,000 to $400,000, $389,400 of reductions would cross those 61 lines about 79 times in all — more than once per line. We count 35.

The gap is not a mystery either, and it is worth doing properly, because the crude figure above counts dollars that were never in range. A reduction can only cross one of our lines where it overlaps the band, and 5 of the 24 reductions are on houses priced wholly outside $100,000 to $400,000, so they cross nothing we counted. Of the $389,400, $174,500 falls inside the band, and at $5,000 a step that predicts 35 crossings. That is not close to what we count. It is what we count.

A near-zero in that column is what reductions of this size and this number should produce. It is arithmetic, not a signal, and it would be dishonest to sell it as one.

What actually moved the lines

21 houses came onto the list this week and 20 came off it. What arrived asks more than what left: a median of $185,000 arriving against $164,250 leaving, a gap of $20,750. Houses left the bottom of the list and houses joined above them, and that is the whole mechanism behind both the rising median and the shortening list under a $200,000 ceiling.

We are not telling you what became of the 20 that left. A listing leaving an active search is not a sale: it can be sold, withdrawn, expired, or relisted under a different record. Finding out means looking each one up under every status the data exposes, which this post did not do, so it says nothing about them beyond the fact that they are no longer on the active list.

A footnote to yesterday’s post

Yesterday this series published a Carterville post about the field in this data that is supposed to flag a price change, and showed it catching 3 of 15 moves in that one town because the 12 it missed were all increases. Across these four counties this week that field missed nothing at all: it flags 207 listings, every one of them a reduction, and it caught all 24 of this week’s house reductions.

Those two findings agree rather than conflict. The field is a record of reductions. In a week with no increases to miss, a record of reductions and a record of price changes look identical. That is worth knowing before anyone leans on it in a week that is not like this one.

What this means for the number in your pocket

The useful part is not the median. It is this: at $150,000 and at $250,000, the count of houses under the ceiling did not change at all this week — and underneath those unchanged counts, 41 houses joined or left the list and 24 cut their asking price.

A stable count is not a stable list. If your ceiling is a few weeks old, the number is probably still right and the houses it reaches are not the houses it reached when you got it. That is an argument for looking again, and for having a ceiling that is current enough to act on when something does appear under it.

💰 Know your number before you tour. Free, no-pressure pre-qualification with Jarod Sanders, SIRE’s in-house lender, right inside our Marion office. Get pre-qualified ›

Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC · NMLS #2337228 · Equal Housing Opportunity. This is not a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility.

What this does not tell you

It does not tell you why any of the 24 sellers reduced a price. We did not ask and the records do not say.

It does not tell you that anything sold. Every price here is an asking price, and nothing on this page is described as sold, pending or contingent.

It does not tell you what any house is worth, and a median asking price never did.

It does not tell you what you can borrow. No interest rate and no monthly payment appears anywhere in this post, deliberately, as on every Saturday edition in this series. A ceiling comes from a lender who has seen your income, your debts and your credit; this page has seen none of those.

And it describes two mornings seven days apart. A week is a week. It is not a trend, and 24 reductions in four counties is not a market turning.

💬 Greg Holthaus on watching the wrong thing

“Buyers watch for price cuts, and I understand why — a reduction feels like the market moving toward you. This week every house price that moved in four counties moved down, $389,400 of it, and the list under a $200,000 ceiling got shorter anyway. What changes what you can see is which houses come on and which come off, and that happens every day without announcing itself. So the thing to be ready for is not a reduction. It is a house appearing on a Tuesday that fits, and somebody else being ready to act on it before you are. Get the number, keep it current, and watch the new ones.”

— Greg Holthaus, Owner & Designated Managing Broker

Questions we get about getting pre-qualified

Did house prices around here go up or down this week?

Both, and which answer you get depends on what you measure. Of the 228 houses on both of our readings, 24 changed their asking price, and every single one came down — $389,400 of reductions in seven days, a median reduction of $10,000. And the median asking price of the whole house list rose $1,550, from $228,450 to $230,000. Both statements are true. The reductions were outweighed by which houses joined the list and which left it.

How do you know the rise was not the price cuts?

We ran the week again with one force at a time. Last week’s list with only the reductions applied — nobody arriving, nobody leaving — has a median of $226,200, which is $2,250 lower than where it started. Last week’s list with only the arrivals and departures applied, and no reduction at all, has a median of $230,000 — exactly the figure we actually observe. So composition accounts for the rise, and the reductions are a real force pulling the other way and losing.

If I am pre-qualified to a ceiling, do price cuts bring more houses within reach?

Hardly at all, on this week’s evidence. At a ceiling of $200,000 the number of houses at or below it fell by 4 houses, and the reductions contributed nothing to that at all: 11 houses arrived under the line and 15 left it. We then tested every line from $100,000 to $400,000 in $5,000 steps, 61 of them, and the reductions never moved any line by more than two houses.

Is that not strange, with that many price cuts?

No, and the arithmetic says why. A reduction only changes a count if your ceiling happens to fall between the old price and the new one. $389,400 of reductions spread evenly from $100,000 to $400,000 would cross those 61 lines about 79 times in all, more than once each. We count 35, and the difference is arithmetic rather than mystery: 5 of the 24 reductions are on houses priced wholly outside that band, so they cross none of our lines at all. Of the $389,400, $174,500 falls inside it, and at $5,000 a step that predicts exactly the 35 we count.

So what actually changed which houses I can see?

The turnover. 21 houses came onto the list and 20 came off it in seven days, and what arrived asks more than what left: a median of $185,000 arriving against $164,250 leaving, a gap of $20,750. What became of the 20 that left is not something this post knows. A listing leaving an active search is not a sale, and we did not look up their statuses for this post.

Does this mean my pre-qualification is out of date?

It means the number is probably still right and the list it was aimed at has changed under it. The count of houses under a ceiling barely moved this week — at $150,000 and $250,000 it did not move at all — while 41 houses joined or left and 24 cut their price. A stable count is not a stable list. Your ceiling itself comes from a lender who has seen your income, your debts and your credit, and nothing on this page is any of those. Jarod Sanders at CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC, NMLS #2337228, works out of our Marion office and the conversation costs nothing. This is not a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility.

Already have your number? Send it to a broker with the counties you are open to and you will get back the houses that actually fit it, not the whole list. Find your broker › or text 618.925.8654.

Greg Holthaus, Owner and Designated Managing Broker, Southern Illinois Realty Experts

Who is Greg Holthaus?

Greg Holthaus is the Owner and Designated Managing Broker of Southern Illinois Realty Experts, with 25+ years in Southern Illinois real estate and more than 10,000 transactions closed. He leads a full-service operation — home sales, mortgage, title, and property management under one roof — with offices in Marion, Herrin, and Carbondale. Meet Greg ›

About these figures: Everything above comes from two readings of local MLS listing data, seven days apart — November 7 and November 14 — taken one county at a time across Williamson, Jackson, Franklin and Union with status set to active on both: 271 in Williamson, 64 in Jackson, 74 in Franklin, 46 in Union, 455 listings in all, of which 249 are houses — the only listings this post counts. Each county’s returned count equals its own reported total, all 455 identifiers are distinct and none appears in more than one county, and both readings echo byte-identical queries; the queries were loaded out of the stored November 7 responses rather than retyped, because a retyped query once returned zero results with no error at all. This morning’s pull was run three times and returned the identical set of listings each time. The Carterville slice was checked a second, different way — the Carterville town query returns the identical 49 records that the four-county reading holds for that town, not merely the same count. Houses were matched one to one on a stable record identifier, never on the address text, and each one’s asking price was compared with its own figure from a week ago rather than with any field the data offers about price changes. The two counterfactual medians are computed from those same identified houses, not estimated: one applies the reductions and holds the set fixed, the other holds every price fixed and applies the arrivals and departures. The three-part breakdown at each ceiling is exact — the derivation refuses to run if the parts do not sum to the observed change — and it was repeated at all 61 lines from $100,000 to $400,000 in $5,000 steps rather than only at the round numbers in the table. No percentage, no interest rate and no monthly payment appears anywhere in this post, by design. No estimate of any reader’s borrowing capacity appears, because that comes from a lender who has seen the income, the debts and the credit. No days-on-market figure, no property-tax figure and no price per square foot appears: the records this post reads carry none of those, and they carry no office field and no agent field either, so nothing about who lists these houses is stated or inferred. No individual listing is named and no address appears; this post is about counts. Prices are asking prices, not sale prices, and nothing here is described as sold, pending or contingent — the 20 houses that left the active list are reported as having left it and nothing more. No county is ranked against another and no ceiling is recommended. Jarod Sanders · CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC · NMLS #2337228 · Equal Housing Opportunity. This is not a loan offer, a rate quote, a commitment to lend, or a guarantee of eligibility.

Thinking About a Move This Fall?

Talk to the team that knows these nine markets house by house — sales, financing, and title under one roof.

What's My Home Worth?Find Your BrokerContact Us