Most homeowners know what their kitchen looks like. Far fewer could tell you what is over their heads or under their feet. An inspector goes to both on every house, and what he writes about the attic and the crawl space often has more to do with a repair request than anything a buyer saw on the walk-through.
This Sunday’s homework is those two spaces. Bring a flashlight, a phone for photos and a notepad. The rule for the day is simple: look, don’t fix. If a space is cramped, hot, or unfloored, shine the light in from the hatch and leave it at that. No house is worth a fall through a ceiling.
1. The Insulation Itself
🏠 Even, Dry and Not Smashed Flat
From the hatch, look at how the insulation lies. It should be fairly even, dry, and not matted down or pushed into corners. Bare spots, trails where something has been dragging, or areas where you can see the ceiling below are worth a photo.
One caution: if the loose fill looks like small gray-brown pebbles, it may be vermiculite, and some older vermiculite can contain asbestos. Do not disturb it or send anyone up to “just move it.” Get it evaluated by a qualified professional first.
Cheap now: knowing what you have. Expensive later: finding out in the middle of a buyer’s inspection.
2. The Underside of the Roof
🌧 Stains, Dark Wood and Rusty Nail Tips
Look up at the roof boards. Dark patches, water rings, or rusty nail points can mean a slow leak or a moisture problem. Check around the chimney, plumbing vents and any skylight. Daylight where it doesn’t belong is a clue too.
A small flashing repair is a modest call to a roofer. Wet, stained decking that has been ignored for years is a much bigger one, and it is the sort of thing a buyer’s inspector circles.
3. Where the Fans and Vents End Up
💨 Bath Fans Belong Outside
Follow the ducts from the bathroom fans and the range hood if you can see them. They should lead outdoors, not stop at the attic floor. Check that the soffit vents along the eaves aren’t buried under insulation, since the attic needs a way to breathe.
Reconnecting a loose duct is usually a small job. Moist air dumped into the attic every shower is how a small job turns into a moisture problem.
4. Signs of Visitors
🐀 Droppings, Nests and Chewed Wires
Look for droppings, shredded insulation, nesting material or chewed wiring. Note any gaps where a pipe or wire passes through a wall or the roofline. Pests tell you there is a way in, and the way in is the part to fix.
5. The Crawl Space
💦 Dry Ground, Clean Insulation, No Wood on Dirt
If your house has a crawl space, open the access and look before you go in. You want dry ground or a vapor barrier that is intact, insulation that is still attached to the floor above rather than hanging down, and no standing water or musty smell. Wood that touches soil, and pipes that sag or drip, belong in your notes.
If the access is awkward or the space is wet, stay at the opening. A damp crawl space is a conversation with a qualified contractor, not a Sunday project.
Why These Two Spaces Matter at Sale Time
Buyers rarely climb into an attic, but their inspectors do, and the notes from up there and down there tend to turn into repair requests. Walking it yourself first means no surprises, and it gives you time to fix the small things on your schedule rather than at the end of a negotiation.
None of this replaces a licensed roofer, electrician or other professional, and it is not a way around disclosure. If you know about a real problem, you disclose it. This list is for catching the small stuff while it is still small.
✅ Print This: Above and Below
- Look at the insulation from the hatch: even, dry, not matted
- Check the roof boards for stains, dark wood and rusty nail tips
- Confirm bath fans and the range hood duct outdoors, and soffit vents are clear
- Look for droppings, nests, chewed wires and gaps
- Check the crawl space for dry ground, attached insulation and no wood on soil
🏠 Thinking About Listing This Winter or Spring?
Send us your address and we’ll tell you what your house is worth today and what, if anything, is worth fixing before it hits the market — and what isn’t. We run sales, mortgage and title under one roof, so we see every inspection that comes through.
Attic and Crawl Space FAQ
Is it safe to walk around in my attic?
What if my attic insulation looks like small gray-brown pebbles?
Should bathroom fans vent into the attic?
Do I have to disclose roof or moisture problems when I sell?
📱 Got a Question About Your House? Text Greg.
Not sure whether something you saw up there is worth fixing? Text Greg Holthaus directly — just tell him you saw his blog. He’ll give you a straight answer, match you with the right broker, and tell you honestly if the answer is “don’t worry about it.”
Text Greg · 618.925.8654About this post: General homeowner guidance based on 25+ years of listing and closing homes across Southern Illinois. It is not a home inspection, not roofing, electrical, plumbing, environmental or structural advice, and not a statement of what any inspector, lender or code official will require — those vary by property and jurisdiction. Hire licensed professionals for roofing, electrical, plumbing, structural and gas work, and have any suspected asbestos-containing material evaluated by a qualified professional. Nothing here replaces the Illinois Residential Real Property Disclosure Report or your obligation to disclose known defects, and nothing here is a guarantee of sale price, closing date, or outcome. Want a specific read on your house? Ask us for a Comparative Market Analysis.
